You completely ignored my entire post. It proves the bottles were intended to be empty.
If the writer intended them to NOT be empty then he either
1. He Wouldn't have used empty prop bottles without creating the illusion of filled bottles.
And
2. He wouldn't had multiple bottles on the hood to give the impression that the men completely drunk beer after beer and used the hood as a garbage can.
Why are you even arguing this common sense?
Originally posted by h1a8
You completely ignored my entire post. It proves the bottles were intended to be empty.If the writer intended them to NOT be empty then he either
1. He Wouldn't have used empty prop bottles without creating the illusion of filled bottles.
And
2. He wouldn't had multiple bottles on the hood to give the impression that the men completely drunk beer after beer and used the hood as a garbage can.Why are you even arguing this common sense?
This is just your opinion and as last I checked, your opinion and proof are two different things.
Originally posted by Silent Master
This is just your opinion and as last I checked, your opinion and proof are two different things.
If there is no evidence to support something existing then it simply doesn't exist in the fiction world. This is a fact. Otherwise, I can just make up shit. For example, Miyagi claps his hands together and makes ip man instantly unconscious.
Originally posted by h1a8
If there is no evidence to support something existing then it simply doesn't exist in the fiction world. This is a fact. Otherwise, I can just make up shit. For example, Miyagi claps his hands together and makes ip man instantly unconscious.
So you're saying that Georgia doesn't exist in the KK universe?
Originally posted by h1a8
You completely ignored my entire post. It proves the bottles were intended to be empty.If the writer intended them to NOT be empty then he either
1. He Wouldn't have used empty prop bottles without creating the illusion of filled bottles.
And
2. He wouldn't had multiple bottles on the hood to give the impression that the men completely drunk beer after beer and used the hood as a garbage can.Why are you even arguing this common sense?
Lol at you using "because they were props" as an argument in the MvF. That's like saying Cap can't really do the things he did because those were stunts with wires.
Seems you don't know what common sense means.
Originally posted by h1a8
If there is no evidence to support something existing then it simply doesn't exist in the fiction world. This is a fact. Otherwise, I can just make up shit. For example, Miyagi claps his hands together and makes ip man instantly unconscious.
Correct and there is no proof that the bottles were empty. Such a hypocrite you are.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Correct and there is no proof that the bottles were empty. Such a hypocrite you are.
"Empty" means nonexistent. I said something doesn't exist if there is no evidence towards it existing.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Lol at you using "because they were props" as an argument in the MvF. That's like saying Cap can't really do the things he did because those were stunts with wires.Seems you don't know what common sense means.
It's more than that. There was no illusion or effect created to show that the bottles were filled.
In other words, the bottles were not intended to be filled since
1. the prop bottles were empty
and
2. there was no effect to create the illusion of filled bottles
and
3. It's understood that multiple bottles on the hood where the drinkers of the bottles are CURRENTLY still drinking.
Originally posted by h1a8
"Empty" means nonexistent. I said something doesn't exist if there is no evidence towards it existing.It's more than that. There was no illusion or effect created to show that the bottles were filled.
In other words, the bottles were not intended to be filled since
1. the prop bottles were empty
and
2. there was no effect to create the illusion of filled bottles
and
3. It's understood that multiple bottles on the hood where the drinkers of the bottles are CURRENTLY still drinking.
In the movie, they were not "prop bottles'. You cannot mix behind the scenes real world facts with movie facts. In the movie, they were beer bottles and beer bottles come filled with beer by default. Regardless of whether they are open or not, they are filled by default. If you want to claim they're empty, then onus is on you to prove they are empty. Simply being open does not imply the contents had already been drunk.
Originally posted by h1a8
KK has other meanings too. Anyway, if present day Earth exists and USA, as we know it, exists in the KK universe then that's the evidence towards Georgia existing.
What other meanings could KK have in a discussion about the Karate Kid movies?
That is just your speculation, something existing in the real world doesn't mean it exists in all works of fiction, try again.
Originally posted by Silent Master
What other meanings could KK have in a discussion about the Karate Kid movies?That is just your speculation, something existing in the real world doesn't mean it exists in all works of fiction, try again.
KK has meaning meanings. The discussion has nothing to do with what someone mean.
I said "if the USA, AS WE KNOW IT, exists in fiction, then Georgia exists."
It's an "if then" statement.
The USA as we know it exists in the KK universe.
Originally posted by h1a8
KK has meaning meanings. The discussion has nothing to do with what someone mean.I said "if the USA, [b]AS WE KNOW IT
, exists in fiction, then Georgia exists."
It's an "if then" statement.
The USA as we know it exists in the KK universe. [/B]
What other meanings could it have when mentioned in a thread about the Karate Kid movies?
Based on what proof?
Originally posted by FrothByte
In the movie, they were not "prop bottles'. You cannot mix behind the scenes real world facts with movie facts. In the movie, they were beer bottles and beer bottles come filled with beer by default. Regardless of whether they are open or not, they are filled by default. If you want to claim they're empty, then onus is on you to prove they are empty. Simply being open does not imply the contents had already been drunk.
They were prop bottles, unless you think the actor actually broke real bottles.
The men drunk all the beer from the older opened bottles, that's why they were multiple bottles as trash while the men were drinking a fresh bottle.
The bottles were opened and drunk from. Thus they are not filled by default. They are empty by default.
Originally posted by h1a8
They were prop bottles, unless you think the actor actually broke real bottles.
The men drunk all the beer from the older opened bottles, that's why they were multiple bottles as trash while the men were drinking a fresh bottle.The bottles were opened and drunk from. Thus they are not filled by default. They are empty by default.
Do you want to debate about movie feats or behind the scenes? Because in the movie they definitely weren't prop bottles. Beer bottles are full by default. You want to claim they're empty then you need to prove it. There were multiple bottles because there were multiple people around.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Do you want to debate about movie feats or behind the scenes? Because in the movie they definitely weren't prop bottles. Beer bottles are full by default. You want to claim they're empty then you need to prove it. There were multiple bottles because there were multiple people around.
Why troll me?
Please address my post. Don't ignore what I said and repeat your statements in a different form.
There were only two men drinking beer. They finished several beers and was currently drinking one when Miyagi addressed them.