Prime Anakin/Vader

Started by Rebel954 pages
Rebel95 Senior Member

Prime Anakin/Vader

When was Anakin/Vader at his best? Invisible hand, Knightfall, Rebels, or ROTJ? Discuss

MythLord Diamond

Knightfall, assuming there wasn't confliction. If there was, then Invisible Hand.

Rebel95 Senior Member

I think it's Knightfall in legends, rebels in canon. They're all really close though.

Ursumeles Traitor
Originally posted by MythLord
Knightfall, assuming there wasn't confliction. If there was, then Invisible Hand.
Azronger Azronger Reborn

Knightfall, without a doubt.

TenebrousWay God Tier Vaylin

Knightfall. Sidious must've masturbated himself watching the holovid of Vader's massacre.

MythLord Diamond

I mean, Hayden's a pretty guy.

Rebel95 Senior Member

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Knightfall. Sidious must've masturbated himself watching the holovid of Vader's massacre.

😂

ares834 Senior Member

ESB.

Beniboybling Worst Member

Knightfall in light of recent revelations.

Rebel95 Senior Member

What are these revelations you speak of

Beniboybling Worst Member

This Canon statement also makes a lot more sense if it's referring to Rots Anakin & Knightfall Vader:

On the other hand (Canon) evidence against Anakin > Vader is not solid, and can be rebut.

ares834 Senior Member

That's not solid evidence either.

Beniboybling Worst Member

I look forward to your rebuttal then. 🙂

Rebel95 Senior Member

Originally posted by Beniboybling

This Canon statement also makes a lot more sense if it's referring to Rots Anakin & Knightfall Vader:

On the other hand (Canon) evidence against Anakin > Vader is not solid, and can be rebut.


Oh yeah I've seen that before. It could just be talking about his lost potential though, and it's contradicted by the quote in LOTS that says his injuries strengthened his connection to the force. Star Wars is so annoying with all of its inconsistencies.

And the one that's talking about Kylo Ren is saying Anakin/Vader, as a whole, is the most powerful jedi and sith. At least that's how I interpreted it.

That being said, I think Knightfall Vader and peak suit Vader are probably about the same overall, they both have their own strengths.

Kurk Restricted

Canon: Rebels/LotS/ANH
Legends: RotJ

composite: Knightfall/Zonakin

Beniboybling Worst Member

Originally posted by Rebel95
Oh yeah I've seen that before. It could just be talking about his lost potential though, and it's contradicted by the quote in LOTS that says his injuries strengthened his connection to the force. Star Wars is so annoying with all of its inconsistencies.
It said before, so its evidently not referring to his potential but to the power he had as Anakin.

And LotS is from Vader's perspective, this is objective.

And the one that's talking about Kylo Ren is saying Anakin/Vader, as a whole, is the most powerful jedi and sith. At least that's how I interpreted it.
???

That being said, I think Knightfall Vader and peak suit Vader are probably about the same overall, they both have their own strengths.
And yet he's described as the most powerful Sith, which obviously isn't the case for suited Vader. mmm

ares834 Senior Member
Originally posted by Kurk
Canon: Rebels/LotS/ANH

Interesting. Why do you think ANH Vader > ESB Vader?

Originally posted by Beniboybling
I look forward to your rebuttal then. 🙂

The latter is certainly referring to potential as Anakin is not more powerful than Yoda nor is any version of Vader more powerful than Sidious.

The first could also be referring to potential.

Regardless, neither is a definitive indication that pre-Mustafar Vader > suited!Vader.

UCanShootMyNova Senior Member

RotJ easily.

Rebel95 Senior Member

Originally posted by Beniboybling
It said before, so its evidently not referring to his potential but to the power he had as Anakin.

And LotS is from Vader's perspective, this is objective.

???

And yet he's described as the most powerful Sith, which obviously isn't the case for suited Vader. mmm


Isn't the quote from a 3rd person point of view? And you realize objective means it's not influenced by personal feelings, right? Lol, anyways, the same could be said for the picture you posted, it's Palpatine's opinion.

I'm saying that the quote is referring to Anakin/Vader being the most powerful force user in regards to his raw power. Obviously he wasn't stronger than Yoda as Anakin or Sidious as Vader.