Originally posted by Deronn_solo
how does Az love it put it
>_<
The feat is legit, arguing it's not because of a few others instances in the mythos is, how does Az love it put it, an argument from incredulity.
That's... not what an argument from incredulity is. An argument from incredulity is when a person refuses to accept/deny something simply because they find it hard to believe.
What we're dealing with here is the fallacy of division, meaning that a person argues that because something is true of the whole, it must be true for parts of the whole as well. For example:
'Speed feats with flowery and fancy descriptions are usually hyperbole.'
'Aryn Leneer reacting in nanoseconds is a speed feat that is described fancily.'
'Therefore, Aryn Leneer reacting in nanoseconds is hyperbole and invalid!'