Supergirl vs. MCU Thor

Started by Darth Thor39 pages

Originally posted by h1a8
Boxers hit with more force than they can lift.

Striking is always greater than lifting.

Even if it wasn't then common sense states that if someone can casually lift something without effort then they can punch with at least similar force.

This is nonesense.

Bodybuilders lift more than Boxers, but Boxers hit harder.

Prime Tyson would destroy Prime Arny in a fight, but there's no way he could lift as much.

Originally posted by h1a8
A person only experiences a tiny fraction of the total explosion power (Thor less than 1/1000). This is because the majority of the power goes out in all the other directions.

That's why resisting a planet explosion is astronomically less than resisting an attack that directly explodes a planet.

Finally, it wasn't all an explosion. It was part a crumbling domino effect. Just like trying to lift a building will cause it to collapse.

Okay you responded to the wrong thing here, but whatever.

Thor was point blank when it exploded. A device with the power to eventually destroy a planet blew up with him basically ground zero and he was fine. Stop trying to downplay everything not in your favorite's favor.

Originally posted by KingD19
Okay you responded to the wrong thing here, but whatever.

Thor was point blank when it exploded. A device with the power to eventually destroy a planet blew up with him basically ground zero and he was fine. Stop trying to downplay everything not in your favorite's favor.

I don't think H1 understands how explosions actually work.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I don't think H1 understands how explosions actually work.

Yeah because like, being at ground zero for an explosion is usually 100% certain death. For normal people being ground zero for a hand grenade or pipe bomb is a death sentence. Thor was ground zero for a massive transpatial-transdimensional teleportation system capable of wiping out planets. In his face. In his perfect face. He got smudges for his trouble.

Originally posted by KingD19
Yeah because like, being at ground zero for an explosion is usually 100% certain death. For normal people being ground zero for a hand grenade or pipe bomb is a death sentence. Thor was ground zero for a massive transpatial-transdimensional teleportation system capable of wiping out planets. In his face. In his perfect face. He got smudges for his trouble.

Not to mention, by his numbers, he thinks that entire explosion only contained a total of 100,000 tons of force.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Electrocuted. Not literally destroyed.

Destroyed.

https://youtu.be/WbLI-mk6R-0

^ Honestly You can't trust any "Thor facts" coming from abhi.

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
So I'm assuming your up to date on S2 of Supergirl and can provide some additional context: Seems like that would be helpful to this debate. Afterall stats aren't the end all to a fight and going by S1 Supergirl would loose handily despite her supeior stats over Thor given her consistent under performance against villains of the week.

I don't think anyone is arguing Thor's stronger than Supergirl however Thor does have better on-screen striking feats and an ability to genuinely hurt Supergirl. It doesn't help that regular humans give Supergirl trouble too...least in S1.


She doesn't has any such low showings in S2 AFAIK.

Originally posted by KingD19
Striking the ground? He's going to bop her on the f*cking head with it. Her combat speed 90% of the time is laughable. He does to her, what he did to Cap's shield when they first met. Except it's the top of her head.

That's such idiocy I'm not sure if I should laugh or report you.
Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
Well there's always this infamous scene to go back to if your really want to argue Sueprgirl' strength is the end all of this match:

YouTube video


*Shows Thor running away from bullets and Sif saving him from a spear*

Yeah, Kara oneshots Thor.

👆

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Destroyed.

https://youtu.be/WbLI-mk6R-0


I seriously think you need to start kindergarten again.

The leviathan were Electrocuted with some explosions from them. Thor didn't outright destroy any of them.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
^ Honestly You can't trust any "Thor facts" coming from abhi.

Did you bring your pom-poms at least?

Originally posted by KingD19
Yeah because like, being at ground zero for an explosion is usually 100% certain death. For normal people being ground zero for a hand grenade or pipe bomb is a death sentence. Thor was ground zero for a massive transpatial-transdimensional teleportation system capable of wiping out planets. In his face. In his perfect face. He got smudges for his trouble.

You mean the same blast which didn't destroy any planets? Or the same blast which Loki tanked?

Because if you are thinking of the same one, I think you're in for some shock.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
This is nonesense.

Bodybuilders lift more than Boxers, but Boxers hit harder.

Prime Tyson would destroy Prime Arny in a fight, but there's no way he could lift as much.

who cares? that's irrelevant. Both can hit harder than they lift. As I already proved and provided evidence

Originally posted by KingD19
Okay you responded to the wrong thing here, but whatever.

Thor was point blank when it exploded. A device with the power to eventually destroy a planet blew up with him basically ground zero and he was fine. Stop trying to downplay everything not in your favorite's favor.

He wasn't at point blank. The land exploded in all directions. The energy from the engines exploded the whole land mass. Plus part was a crumbling domino effect. Like lifting a building.

Originally posted by abhilegend

*Shows Thor running away from bullets and Sif saving him from a spear*

Yeah, Kara oneshots Thor.

👆

So... you're comparing Nothing happening to Thor, to SG getting stuck in Quicksand?

Great argument, but you've actually proven nothing 👆

Originally posted by h1a8
who cares? that's irrelevant. Both can hit harder than they lift. As I already proved and provided evidence

What she's capable of doing in her best potential punch is irrelevant. What's relevant is how hard she's likely to hit in combat, which you've still not proven is above what Thor can handle.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I seriously think you need to start kindergarten again.

The leviathan were Electrocuted with some explosions from them. Thor didn't outright destroy any of them.
Did you bring your pom-poms at least?

At 0:32, the Leviathan explodes completely. Cry more on this site also.

Originally posted by h1a8
He wasn't at point blank. The land exploded in all directions. The energy from the engines exploded the whole land mass. Plus part was a crumbling domino effect. Like lifting a building.

You really need to watch the movies.

Supergirl grapples Thor and breaks his bones.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
So... you're comparing Nothing happening to Thor, to SG getting stuck in Quicksand?

Great argument, but you've actually proven nothing 👆

What she's capable of doing in her best potential punch is irrelevant. What's relevant is how hard she's likely to hit in combat, which you've still not proven is above what Thor can handle.

Now you are debating like a champion. This argument of yours is now very relevant. She is not likely to strike with that type of force. She doesn't kill. So she should hold back considerably.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
So... you're comparing Nothing happening to Thor, to SG getting stuck in Quicksand?

Great argument, but you've actually proven nothing 👆

Never mind the fact that Thor was caught directly in the line of fire when Ultron was shooting at everything, using the Quinjet minigun, in AoU, or that space metals, such as that of Asgardians and their rivals, are shown to be much tougher than Earth metals.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
[B]So... you're comparing Nothing happening to Thor, to SG getting stuck in Quicksand?

Great argument, but you've actually proven nothing 👆

It's like talking to kindergarten kids. Yeah, Supergirl had a low showing when they were still establishing her power levels but even back then she stopped a plane crashing which is beyond Thor level.

Thor ducking from bullets isn't nothing happening. It's a verifiable low showing which shows he is vulnerable to ****ing bullets.