Supergirl vs. MCU Thor

Started by abhilegend39 pages

Originally posted by TheHulkster
At 0:32, the Leviathan explodes completely. Cry more on this site also.

Uh-huh. You are saying after Electrocuted, the leviathan explodes due to internal explosions?
Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Never mind the fact that Thor was caught directly in the line of fire when Ultron was shooting at everything, using the Quinjet minigun, in AoU, or that space metals, such as that of Asgardians and their rivals, are shown to be much tougher than Earth metals.

Thor wasn't shown hit by a bullet there. Cap was also alongside Thor there.

Cap is bulletproof too?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thor wasn't shown hit by a bullet there. Cap was also alongside Thor there.

Cap is bulletproof too?

You should go rewatch the scene before asking these kinds of questions. Cap ducked behind a statue whereas Thor was caught directly in the path of the fire.

But hey, keep trying to use a showing where Thor was NOT hit by any bullets, when he'd only been on Earth for a brief period while powered (in his previous visit, while de-powered, Earth tech had affected him), and was therefore still ignorant about how/if the weapons could affect him (seeing as Iron Man had put up a fight and Cap's shield had tanked one of his hits only a bit earlier), as an argument that they would hurt him.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
You should go rewatch the scene before asking these kinds of questions. Cap ducked behind a statue whereas Thor was caught directly in the path of the fire.

You should do the same and watch the scene where Cap was right alongside Thor and neither of them were shown to be hit.

But hey, Thor ducked bullets for shits and giggles.

That works too for showing cowardice if nothing else.

But hey, keep trying to use a showing where Thor was NOT hit by any bullets, when he'd only been on Earth for a brief period while powered (in his previous visit, while de-powered, Earth tech had affected him), and was therefore still ignorant about how/if the weapons could affect him (seeing as Iron Man had put up a fight and Cap's shield had tanked one of his hits only a bit earlier), as an argument that they would hurt him.

Or maybe, just maybe that was shown to show Thor wasn't bulletproof.

Instead of making things up, why don't you provide any kind of proof about Thor worrying about bullets?

Originally posted by abhilegend
You should do the same and watch the scene where Cap was right alongside Thor and neither of them were shown to be hit.

But hey, Thor ducked bullets for shits and giggles.

That works too for showing cowardice if nothing else.

Or maybe, just maybe that was shown to show Thor wasn't bulletproof.

Instead of making things up, why don't you provide any kind of proof about Thor worrying about bullets?

Here is the clip. You can visibly see Cap moving behind the statue (while also trying to block with his shield) whereas Thor actually gets knocked over by the barrage, from the 0:04 to 0:07 mark:

YouTube video

Now how about you provide a showing where Thor actually visibly gets hurt by bullets. Not just speculation for which there is a reasonable alternative explanation.

^ Lol don't show clips. It makes it harder for Thor haters to troll.

Edit: Those are clearly pretty high powered bullets as well. Easily a match for anything that jet firing at Hulk and Thor in A1 was able to unleash.

Originally posted by abhilegend
It's like talking to kindergarten kids. Yeah, Supergirl had a low showing when they were still establishing her power levels but even back then she stopped a plane crashing which is beyond Thor level.

Thor ducking from bullets isn't nothing happening. It's a verifiable low showing which shows he is vulnerable to ****ing bullets.

Why, did Thor actually get injured by the bullets? Does lifting a plane excuse SG from being a crappy fighter?

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Here is the clip. You can visibly see Cap moving behind the statue (while also trying to block with his shield) whereas Thor actually gets knocked over by the barrage, from the 0:04 to 0:07 mark:

YouTube video

Now how about you provide a showing where Thor actually visibly gets hurt by bullets. Not just speculation for which there is a reasonable alternative explanation.

It's inconclusive whether Thor got hit. The scene never showed him getting hit.

Originally posted by h1a8
It's inconclusive whether Thor got hit. The scene never showed him getting hit.

Do you have any proof that bullets would injure Thor?

Originally posted by h1a8
It's inconclusive whether Thor got hit. The scene never showed him getting hit.

So Cap dodging out of the way and Thor standing there in the line of fire is inconclusive? He was in the same fire trail as Hawkeye and we saw what happened when Quicksilver pushed him out of the way.

Also Loki who is much weaker got shot in the face and was fine.

Originally posted by KingD19
So Cap dodging out of the way and Thor standing there in the line of fire is inconclusive? He was in the same fire trail as Hawkeye and we saw what happened when Quicksilver pushed him out of the way.

Also Loki who is much weaker got shot in the face and was fine.

Not that it matters as this board operates on feats and Thor has feats of tanking things far more powerful than bullets. if h1 or anyone else wants to claim bullets would injure Thor. then they would have to show bullets actually injuring him.

Originally posted by h1a8
It's inconclusive whether Thor got hit. The scene never showed him getting hit.

There is an impact against his left shoulder at the 5 second mark, and the barrage literally knocks him over. And as KingD pointed out, when QS entered the same line of fire he got shot to shit (along with some random SHIELD guy in that same line). But either way, him making very little attempt to go for cover, unlike Cap, goes against the helicarrier fight where he dived to avoid the fire. And he was more savvy with regards to Earth tech by AoU.

Also, the sheer fact that Hulk can cave a Leviathan's head in with a punch, but only give Thor a nosebleed, supports the notion of being bulletproof. If Thor's tissue is weak enough that it can be pierced by man-made bullets, then a punch from the Hulk should turn his head into a bloody mist cloud.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller

Also, the sheer fact that Hulk can cave a Leviathan's head in with a punch, but only give Thor a nosebleed, supports the notion of being bulletproof. If Thor's tissue is weak enough that it can be pierced by man-made bullets, then a punch from the Hulk should turn his head into a bloody mist cloud.

Unless it's that dumb "backwards durability" thing they do in the comics sometimes with Thor and Wonder Woman. Not that that would help SG in the slightest.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Unless it's that dumb "backwards durability" thing they do in the comics sometimes with Thor and Wonder Woman. Not that that would help SG in the slightest.

Well, I have yet to see anything to suggest that's the case with MCU Thor, so I see no reason to assume it is. Comics are separate from the movies. After all, the Hulk shrugged off jet fire, yet was affected by hits from Thor and Veronica, the latter even KOing him. I also have a hard time believing that they would make Luke Cage have better piercing durability than Thor, considering it took the Judas bullets to get through his skin.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Unless it's that dumb "backwards durability" thing they do in the comics sometimes with Thor and Wonder Woman. Not that that would help SG in the slightest.

If they want to claim "backwards durability" in regards to bullets, they would have to prove it by showing bullets injuring Thor. Thor merely dodging isn't proof.

Nor is Loki being able to stab him as Loki has super-strength, plus used magical knives and before anyone claims they weren't magical. they glowed several times when used against the Frost Giants.

Thor also has bulletproof armor on top of being bulletproof. Loki and Sif both showed that Asgardian armor sparks at most when it gets shot. They don't even seem to really register impact, as Sif got shotgunned in her hip armor point blank and swayed a bit, but that was it.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
There is an impact against his left shoulder at the 5 second mark, and the barrage literally knocks him over. And as KingD pointed out, when QS entered the same line of fire he got shot to shit (along with some random SHIELD guy in that same line). But either way, him making very little attempt to go for cover, unlike Cap, goes against the helicarrier fight where he dived to avoid the fire. And he was more savvy with regards to Earth tech by AoU.

Also, the sheer fact that Hulk can cave a Leviathan's head in with a punch, but only give Thor a nosebleed, supports the notion of being bulletproof. If Thor's tissue is weak enough that it can be pierced by man-made bullets, then a punch from the Hulk should turn his head into a bloody mist cloud.

I don't see any of that honestly.
Character's operate at different levels at different times. That type of ABC logic isn't proof. Hulk can hit Spidey, Cap, etc. hard and not kill them. That doesn't mean they are bulletproof.

Originally posted by KingD19
Thor also has bulletproof armor on top of being bulletproof. Loki and Sif both showed that Asgardian armor sparks at most when it gets shot. They don't even seem to really register impact, as Sif got shotgunned in her hip armor point blank and swayed a bit, but that was it.
Good thing the face isn't covered with armor.

Originally posted by h1a8
Good thing the face isn't covered with armor.

Do you have any proof that Thor isn't bulletproof?

Originally posted by Silent Master
If they want to claim "backwards durability" in regards to bullets, they would have to prove it by showing bullets injuring Thor. Thor merely dodging isn't proof.

Nor is Loki being able to stab him as Loki has super-strength, plus used magical knives and before anyone claims they weren't magical. they glowed several times when used against the Frost Giants.

Yeah of course.

Wouldn't even say Thor actively dodged those bullets. Just made the sensible decision to get out of the way. Which we've seen he doesn't even bother doing by AOU.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
There is an impact against his left shoulder at the 5 second mark, and the barrage literally knocks him over. And as KingD pointed out, when QS entered the same line of fire he got shot to shit (along with some random SHIELD guy in that same line). But either way, him making very little attempt to go for cover, unlike Cap, goes against the helicarrier fight where he dived to avoid the fire. And he was more savvy with regards to Earth tech by AoU.

Also, the sheer fact that Hulk can cave a Leviathan's head in with a punch, but only give Thor a nosebleed, supports the notion of being bulletproof. If Thor's tissue is weak enough that it can be pierced by man-made bullets, then a punch from the Hulk should turn his head into a bloody mist cloud.

Yeah, but if you want to go that route, the fact that Supergirl picked up a small object weighing billions of tons and it didn't put a hole in her palm suggests better durability than anything Thor will ever have by magnitudes. A bullet or a punch from Hulk isn't anywhere near more impressive than that.