Rebels Maul vs Shaak Ti

Maul as of Rebels, Ti in her prime. Battle takes place on Lothal. Who wins?

Bonus round: Ti gets two elite magnas as backup, Maul gets Savage Opress.

Maul loses alone but with Savage he takes her

Ti makes ILS cry.

Isn't Maul supposed to be better than in TCW? In either case, he was near enough matching Ahsoka, who goes on to contend with a Vader that'd shame Shaak. Horny red wins.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Isn't Maul supposed to be better than in TCW? In either case, he was near enough matching Ahsoka, who goes on to contend with a Vader that'd shame Shaak. Horny red wins.

Very unsmart opinions coming from Ching right now. 🙁

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Very unsmart opinions coming from Ching right now. 🙁

Shaak blitzed five MagnaGuards; three were enough to beat RotS Obi, who is > ANH Obi, who is > Rebels Obi, who is >>>> Maul.

So, Shaak >> Rots Obi > Rebels Obi >>>> Maul.

Yeah Maul still wins...

And the notion of Shaak actually matching Vader similarly to Ahsoka is rather absurd.

Originally posted by MythLord
Shaak blitzed five MagnaGuards; three were enough to beat RotS Obi, who is > ANH Obi, who is > Rebels Obi, who is >>>> Maul.

So, Shaak >> Rots Obi > Rebels Obi >>>> Maul.

I am going to assume your not serious.

What about my not serious?

Ok I gotta ask cause it's bugging me, but what exactly has Vader done up to the Rebels time period saber wise, that makes matching him great? Far as I know, the only lightsaber combat he has done was tooling Kanan and Ezra in a non serious manner.

But...I don't really see that as much a lightsaber feat considered he outclassed them anyway.

Maul slaughter house

Shaak Ti.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Ok I gotta ask cause it's bugging me, but what exactly has Vader done up to the Rebels time period saber wise, that makes matching him great? Far as I know, the only lightsaber combat he has done was tooling Kanan and Ezra in a non serious manner.

But...I don't really see that as much a lightsaber feat considered he outclassed them anyway.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Rebels is his prime, so all his feats apply. 😱

That's it?...You'll forgive if I can't really believe he didn't get better saber wise over the years given how long it's been from Rebels to ROTJ.

It's less than three years before ANH, not a big leap for someone whose had decades to develop his power and skill, ESB and RotJ are set only a few years after that, but by the latter (and maybe even before that) he's not at his best.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Rebels is his prime, so all his feats apply. 😱

Anything other than non canon author statements to back that up?

Even so, what feats. All Canon Vader has that's great in duelling is beating Luke, whose only strong feat is being a match for Vader mmm

Hell, Vader's best feat might actually just be matching Kenobi, and even that could be put down to Kenobi being a Soresu duellist 😱

Originally posted by SunRazer
Isn't Maul supposed to be better than in TCW? In either case, he was near enough matching Ahsoka, who goes on to contend with a Vader that'd shame Shaak. Horny red wins.

No, unless you believe quotes which have literally no canon authority. Doesn't take much to notice Maul atrophied.

What's your proof that he'd shame Shaak? I don't buy it. TFU Vader has superior feats to his Canon self at this point in time, and Galen did significantly better than Ahsoka, because, you know, he actually won. Even if you think Marek improved, there's not much to suggest his blade skill increased significantly after fighting Shaak (who was considered strong enough to be his final test). I'll accept that his ability to actually control his force powers did, however.

So if she can effectively out-duel a duelist who mildly improved, then butchered a stronger Vader than the Canon one..... why would Canon Vader shame her? mmm

Seems like pretty trash tier logic Nova, though that seems par for the course recently.

Pablo Hidalgo, a member of the Lucasfilm Story Group... is a non-canon author? Who knew. 😕

Originally posted by Beniboybling
It's less than three years before ANH, not a big leap for someone whose had decades to develop his power and skill, ESB and RotJ are set only a few years after that, but by the latter (and maybe even before that) he's not at his best.

Well Force Users aren't exactly bound by human limitations, they can learn/improve much faster.

But if this is really what Canon is going for....then...yikes.