The Battle for the Title: Jane Thor vs Thor

Started by Flyattractor7 pages

Thor wins.

Mjolnir favors her more than it ever favored Odinsn.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
How are Thor sales anyway? Did they improve with the change or stayed the same, worse?

Initially it was due to the mystery of who she was. Its dropped dramatically

Originally posted by darthgoober
IDK... I'd def credit Thor with better highs, but from what I've seen she does have the edge in "averages". I mean she's racked up quite a feat catelog within a relatively short period of time.

Such as?

Originally posted by darthgoober
IDK... I'd def credit Thor with better highs, but from what I've seen she does have the edge in "averages". I mean she's racked up quite a feat catelog within a relatively short period of time.

His highs are so ridiculous it pushes his average pretty up there.

She has no where near the high showings he has.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Is this a bait thread? Odinson is his last name. Thor is his title he chose not to lift Ult Mjolnir and Fury/Gorr mindphucked him. Jane is a fill in just like Masterson, Norvell, Tarene. Every title character has their title usurped Cap, Batman, Spiderman, Superman, Wonder Woman there are a million Laterns (well lanterns dont count) but at the end of the day it always comes back to the OG.

Are you asking who jas the best average? Odinson. Best highs? Odinson. Better fighter, more durable, better damage soak? Odinson. Who has fought a beaten a higher pedigree of opponents? Odinson. Just because Marvel did a soft retcon and made the hammer sentient, moody and sexist doesnt cast aside decades of feats. Nor does it "flying for her better than him" prove anything. I recently read an article where its stated Cho has the potential to be a stronger Hulk than Banner. Does that make Cho a better Hulk than Banner? No. Hes just the flavor of the month.

Well said.

Jane best feats are:
- Stoping a Supernova comet with a storm.
- Dent adamantium plates with bare hands.
- Summon a giant Storm in Jupiter (maybe bigger than earth?)
- Send Odin across Saturn moons (and tank punchs like that).
- The Speed feat in Dr.Strange issue.
- Good fights against Gladiator and Odinson.

I think at least She has a better average( and possible the best feat) if we talk about storm sizes (one planetary another bigger than a star). If we talk in pure power output, Godblast is above anything she did.

Btw, imo the Odin her fight dont have Odinforce or only part of it. Also i think we should scale any phisical feat for Odinson.

Originally posted by eaebiakuya
Jane best feats are:
- Stoping a Supernova comet with a storm.
- Dent adamantium plates with bare hands.
- Summon a giant Storm in Jupiter (maybe bigger than earth?)
- Send Odin across Saturn moons (and tank punchs like that).
- The Speed feat in Dr.Strange issue.
- Good fights against Gladiator and Odinson.

I think at least She has a better average( and possible the best feat) if we talk about storm sizes (one planetary another bigger than a star). If we talk in pure power output, Godblast is above anything she did.

Btw, imo the Odin her fight dont have Odinforce or only part of it. Also i think we should scale any phisical feat for Odinson.

Thor blasted Glory with storms that could tear apart 10,000 worlds or something like that, Jane manipulating Jupiters red spot is nothing in comparison to that.

Originally posted by eaebiakuya
Jane best feats are:
- Stoping a Supernova comet with a storm.
- Dent adamantium plates with bare hands.
- Summon a giant Storm in Jupiter (maybe bigger than earth?)
- Send Odin across Saturn moons (and tank punchs like that).
- The Speed feat in Dr.Strange issue.
- Good fights against Gladiator and Odinson.

I think at least She has a better average( and possible the best feat) if we talk about storm sizes (one planetary another bigger than a star). If we talk in pure power output, Godblast is above anything she did.

Btw, imo the Odin her fight dont have Odinforce or only part of it. Also i think we should scale any phisical feat for Odinson.


Punching Odin and sending him moon distances is questionable .. They were engaged in fisticuffs while traveling great distances.

She would lose the high end game with Odinson.... By a country mile.

He was able to hurt a being that had absorbed 98.7% of the multiverse with a lightning shot.

Jane got owned by the Phoenix force. So did he, but he was still able to clip its wings in one encounter and even knocked it out with a hammer throw that sent it flying planetary distances.

He was able to absorb the entirety of the godbomb blast into himself long enough to save the day. Said bomb was in the process of killing all gods in the omniverse.. We're talking past, present, and future.

He went Probe busting with Hyperion, but instead of measly probes he was cracking the physical forms of beyonders.

I could go on, but u get the picture.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Such as?

Ripping apart a large adamantium/vibranium alloy door with her bare hands, preforming multiple surgeries so fast that she was melting the metal instruments, and her fight against Odin are the first to spring to mind.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
His highs are so ridiculous it pushes his average pretty up there.

She has no where near the high showings he has.


Oh I know he's got a bunch on high end feats and you'll never hear me say she can match them, but he has SOOO many more appearances it just seems to me that her average is higher. Now if I was to read every one of his appearances back to back and see all of his high end stuff in a more rapid fasion it might tip the scales of "averages" back into his favor, but at a casual glance I'm inclined to giving her the nod.

Im gonna correct some misinformation thats out there...Jane didnt stop that Super Comet. Mjolnir did. She prayed to the god Tempest to produce the super storm and IT took out the comet.

As opposed to Thor whose own INNATE power took out Glory. His godly spark created cosmic fire which resulted in a quantum tsunami which temporarily tore thru reality to wit Odinson was at the center if it. This was an ENTIRE pantheon and their worlds fighting 1 Thor.

hardly comparable feats

This isn't a feat war, this is a fight. Who wins and why? Thor is the better fighter. Jane is stronger and faster and has better Mjolnir attacks. She can just send Mjolnir at Thor in a frenzy.

In close combat then Odinson should have the slight edge because of skill (but her strength and speed might make up for that).

Jane wins this.

Originally posted by h1a8
This isn't a feat war, this is a fight. Who wins and why? Thor is the better fighter. Jane is stronger and faster and has better Mjolnir attacks. She can just send Mjolnir at Thor in a frenzy.

In close combat then Odinson should have the slight edge because of skill (but her strength and speed might make up for that).

Jane wins this.

We base "fights" here off "feats" boy do try and keep up. Lol at strength..Jane is NOT stronger. She has ONE notable speed feat which IS NOT even combat related. Spamming mjolnir is her only tactic. If youre gonna pull shit out your ass atleast make sure it aint bull.

Originally posted by h1a8
This isn't a feat war, this is a fight. Who wins and why? Thor is the better fighter. Jane is stronger and faster and has better Mjolnir attacks. She can just send Mjolnir at Thor in a frenzy.

In close combat then Odinson should have the slight edge because of skill (but her strength and speed might make up for that).

Jane wins this.


All the showings I mentioned were all battle feats.

So when did Marvel jump the shit shark and start this "Thor is a Title" Bullshit exactly?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Im gonna correct some misinformation thats out there...Jane didnt stop that Super Comet. Mjolnir did. She prayed to the god Tempest to produce the super storm and IT took out the comet.

As opposed to Thor whose own INNATE power took out Glory. His godly spark created cosmic fire which resulted in a quantum tsunami which temporarily tore thru reality to wit Odinson was at the center if it. This was an ENTIRE pantheon and their worlds fighting 1 Thor.

hardly comparable feats

Did you read the Glory fight? He absorbed Glory attack via Mjlonir and sent it back at him. That's not using hisbinnate power, that's using Glory power.

Originally posted by carver9
Did you read the Glory fight? He absorbed Glory attack via Mjlonir and sent it back at him. That's not using hisbinnate power, that's using Glory power.

Im talking abour the spark carver. That kept him alive when he couldnt go on...when Glory was crushing hin, which Glory also sensed and pissed his pants.

That was spark of TOAA.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
We base "fights" here off "feats" boy do try and keep up. Lol at strength..Jane is NOT stronger. She has ONE notable speed feat which IS NOT even combat related. Spamming mjolnir is her only tactic. If youre gonna pull shit out your ass atleast make sure it aint bull.

You do, I don't. It's stupid to do that. That's a fact and not an opinion.
Feats are only relevant is if they the correspond to the actual forum fight.

Jane is stronger. Odinson can not bend adamantium/vibranium. He once hit adamantium will all his might and visually did no damage.
Her speed feat can be applied to combat.
It just takes common sense.

And spamming Mjolnir is an automatic win for her.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
All the showings I mentioned were all battle feats.
That has nothing to do with this fight. They are irrelevant.