Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Ofcourse. I get that. We agree in something 😂 😂Well, to "ME" again HOTU should win. But again this is my opinion, and i respect yours. 😉
We need more posts like this, the willingness to acknowledge that our stances are merely personal opinions and not objectively right or wrong.
Thank you for being humble enough to respect the equally as valid opinions of others here in regards to the HOTU being universal or etc.
Originally posted by Rao Kal El
I never got that quite right.Is canon for what ever universe it happen?
Is it canon for 616?
Was this 616 thanos?
Is it canon only for the LT?
Everything that happens withing 616 earth is considered canon (In most cases), since all the major events (the streamline) occurs in this reality. Like the infinity war events, civil war, and other major canon events. A canon comic is one which follows the line of events, but is also validated by upcoming comics. Non canon comics are those which are connected to the main streamline of events; like Adam Warlock becoming the Living Tribunal. If it was a canon event, then it should have been validated by other upcoming comics which portray the Tribunal. For instance, the Living Tribunal that was killed by Lord Chaos and Master Order in the Ultimates should have had the face of Adam (Since it didn't that comic isn't canon).
Now, a canon comic like The Ultimates, is validated since it follows the stream line of events (This comic takes place after the Secret Wars and continues with the story of the formation of the 8th Multiverse/universe).
We can also see examples of these in movies. For instance, the events that take place in the X Men movies can be considered Non Canon, since the main steamline of events are those of the MCU. Movies like Captain America, etc, are validated by other movies. (A good example would be Spiderman Homecoming, in where it is validated by the events of Captain America Civil War).
If the X Men were to be sold back to Marvel, all the events that occured in the previous movies would be considered Non canon, and would be Retcon.
*correct me if am wrong.
Originally posted by Board Walker
We need more posts like this, the willingness to acknowledge that our stances are merely personal opinions and not objectively right or wrong.Thank you for being humble enough to respect the equally as valid opinions of others here in regards to the HOTU being universal or etc.
Thank you so much.
Originally posted by Rao Kal ElThanos mentions it in other Starlin works and its in the old bios for some of the cosmic beings like Tribunal and Infinity. But even all those places still say universe.
I never got that quite right.Is canon for what ever universe it happen?
Is it canon for 616?
Was this 616 thanos?
Is it canon only for the LT?
Marvunapp, points out , alongside hanbooks, that the story was in universe 4321 and affected only that timeline, but as all duplicate universes are divergent, its hard to gauge where the timeline diverted and what events actually may have transpired.
http://www.marvunapp.com/Appendix/akhenaton.htm
But we know from everything else, that it did not happen in 616. Which is what Brevoort was suggesting. That it's not canon to the main marvel universe.
There is some cool theories about how and why Thanos alone knows though.