Captain America vs. Defenders

Started by h1a86 pages

Originally posted by Sable
No you tried to fool SM by quoting me and changing what I said by changing the quote, you disgraceful liar.
I always meant Cap can't damage IM without the shield. You changed my argument to, yes Cap can damage IM with the shield. I changed your post because you tried to change my argument into something else.

Bullshit liar. I didnt change anything. You changed my quotes.

Originally posted by h1a8
JJ flesh is tougher or on par with steel.

You gotta get me some of this stuff you're smoking. Now Jessica is Superwoman? 😆

She is strong, not invulnerable or bulletproof.

Originally posted by Dreampanther
You gotta get me some of this stuff you're smoking. Now Jessica is Superwoman? 😆

She is strong, not invulnerable or bulletproof.

Further evidence that H1 either does not watch the shows before commenting or he is just not smart enough to understand what he seeing.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Further evidence that H1 either does not watch the shows before commenting or he is just not smart enough to understand what he seeing.

How about option c, hes just a dumb troll.

Originally posted by Dreampanther
You gotta get me some of this stuff you're smoking. Now Jessica is Superwoman? 😆

She is strong, not invulnerable or bulletproof.

In some scenes yes. But theoretically, she can't do most of her breaking steel (casually) feats without being extremely durable.

Inconsistency.

Originally posted by h1a8
In some scenes yes. But theoretically, she can't do most of her breaking steel (casually) feats without being extremely durable.

Inconsistency.

You can't call it inconsistency when she is consistently shown to be very strong, and very durable, but not to a level where she can't be hurt by regular people. Aside from Cage, Cap is the strongest person she will have fought. And she had trouble with people far weaker, less skilled, less ruthless, etc... than Steve.

Originally posted by KingD19
You can't call it inconsistency when she is consistently shown to be very strong, and very durable, but not to a level where she can't be hurt by regular people. Aside from Cage, Cap is the strongest person she will have fought. And she had trouble with people far weaker, less skilled, less ruthless, etc... than Steve.
It's a contradiction to tank a full hit by Luke Cage and get hurt by regular people.

Contradictions exists in all media. Reeves Superman lifted tectonic plates, yet struggled with a 300 ton boulder. Supergirl lifting the key yet didn't have the strength to one shot many enemies.

In a forum, there are no inconsistencies in durability. A character will fight at a nearly fixed level.

Again, she tanked a full hit from Luke Cage. Cage is significantly stronger than Cap.

So basically like always, you're going to blatantly ignore everything you don't agree with and use what you do as the gospel? Yeah, Cap wins. You're getting old with this bullshit.

Originally posted by Sable
True, but the suit he was wearing was certainly bullet and Rpg proof.

Proof? He wasn't even shot at with a toy gun in armor while in CW. And yeah, Hawkeye's arrow pierced him. So no.

Adjusting H1's post

Originally posted by h1a8
JJ tanked Luke Cage sending her flying 30 feet .

And got pulled through a wall by him
Got ran over by a truck and only got few broken ribs and a flash ko while the truck's engine got wrecked. And this was while being sleep deprived.
And then got into a fight with Nuke where she got thrown through a wall. Geez you guys have H1 sounding more reasonable than you.

Originally posted by KingD19
So basically like always, you're going to blatantly ignore everything you don't agree with and use what you do as the gospel? Yeah, Cap wins. You're getting old with this bullshit.

Yeah, Cap's gonna beat a team with good, instinctive team work and consisting on someone whose on his strength level atleast and much more durable and has decent fighting skills (Cage), another person whose pretty close in stfength herself (Jess), two martial artists both with decent damage soak, arguably more skilled than Cap and one with at his command far more striking power than anyone Cap has looked good against. Lets just agree to disagree on that.

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Yeah, Cap's gonna beat a team with good, instinctive team work and consisting on someone whose on his strength level atleast and much more durable and has decent fighting skills (Cage), another person whose pretty close in stfength herself (Jess), two martial artists both with decent damage soak, arguably more skilled than Cap and one with at his command far more striking power than anyone Cap has looked good against. Lets just agree to disagree on that.

I see you mentioned all their good points, but you seem to have glossed over the fact that the two strongest people are significantly less skilled than Cap and that barring the IF(which hardly gets spammed during a single fight), the two skilled people don't have the damage output to even slow Cap down.

If you're going to call people out for not taking everything into account, you should really make sure you're not guilty of the same thing.

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Proof? He wasn't even shot at with a toy gun in armor while in CW. And yeah, Hawkeye's arrow pierced him. So no.

Are you stupid? He got crushed by 3 cars falling off a parking garage and nothing happened.

Ahem
Friday: ""Multiple contusions detected""

So basically, bruises?

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Ahem
Friday: ""Multiple contusions detected""

This idiot doesnt even know what a contusion is😂

Concession accepted👆

I forgot, his entire house fell on him too and survived multiple missles😂

Originally posted by KingD19
So basically like always, you're going to blatantly ignore everything you don't agree with and use what you do as the gospel? Yeah, Cap wins. You're getting old with this bullshit.
You can't account for everything. You would get contradictions. Either, in a forum, she can tank blows from Luke Cage or she gets hurt by regular people. Which is it?

Hey SM where did HulkisHulk go😂