Captain America vs. Defenders

Started by Silent Master6 pages

Good question.

It appears he ran off after being exposed as a liar

Originally posted by Sable
I forgot, his entire house fell on him too and survived multiple missles😂

You also forgot that it was a different armor. Also he never got hit by multiple missiles ike ever jn my recollection. If you can point out
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Ahem
Friday: ""Multiple contusions detected""

Originally posted by Silent Master
So basically, bruises?

For someone whose RPG proof, there should be none.

Also, CW Iron Man was damaged by Redwing, and later hurt and grappled by Falcon. And as mentioned earlier, pierced by the arrow and damaged by the explosion. His repulsors barely damaged when it hit the concrete road and did zero damage to the cars thrown by SW. He was unable to catch up to the Quinjet, Falcon or the falling Rhodey.
All performances much below previous armors. And yet somehow the CW armor is equal to the previous ones? What a joke!

Originally posted by Silent Master
I see you mentioned all their good points, but you seem to have glossed over the fact that the two strongest people are significantly less skilled than Cap and that barring the IF(which hardly gets spammed during a single fight), the two skilled people don't have the damage output to even slow Cap down.

If you're going to call people out for not taking everything into account, you should really make sure you're not guilty of the same thing.

First of all, I've never claimed Luke or Jessica being as skilled as Cap, or that Matt or Danny can put Cap down without the IF.

On the other hand though, it is not out of the realm of possibility that Danny and Matt can create openings for Luke and Jessica. And neither of them are fodder that Cap mows down. And since Cap isn't untouchable to them, they are more than capable of bringing him down

Openings? In a fight this serious, Cap isn't gonna hold back. He might not kill them, but he'll definitely hit them hard enough to take them down in a hurry. We've seen how Elektra took all four of them down, and she's nowhere near as strong as Cap. Danny and Matt get ko'd quickly.

He's under the impression that Cap is going to hold back, while the Defenders are allowed to go all out.

Originally posted by Silent Master
He's under the impression that Cap is going to hold back, while the Defenders are allowed to go all out.

He's under the impression Cap is taking on four characters, two of whom could give him a good 1 vs 1, and two who can certainly hurt him. And that four on one will create openings.

Like he said.

Originally posted by KingD19
Openings? In a fight this serious, Cap isn't gonna hold back. He might not kill them, but he'll definitely hit them hard enough to take them down in a hurry. We've seen how Elektra took all four of them down, and she's nowhere near as strong as Cap. Danny and Matt get ko'd quickly.

You seriously overrate Cap.

Is he above each of the Netlix crew? Perhaps. But he's not leagues above them like many seem to be arguing.

Cap's solidly in the Nolan Batman/Bane/Matt/Danny level, just like in the comics. Veeery slight advantages in some areas, but hardly insurmountable.

Saying that MCU Cap is in the Nolan Batman level is ridiculous, by feats Cap could beat multiple Baleman's at the same time without much problem.

Originally posted by cdtm
You seriously overrate Cap.

Is he above each of the Netlix crew? Perhaps. But he's not leagues above them like many seem to be arguing.

Cap's solidly in the Nolan Batman/Bane/Matt/Danny level, just like in the comics. Veeery slight advantages in some areas, but hardly insurmountable.

Okay, so I'm gonna need you to show me pure strength feats from Baleman, Bane, Matt, and Danny that match this list.

Holding a helicopter from taking off.
Chucking Ultron 30 feet into a highway support beam and shattering it on impact.
Kicking a parked truck sideways into a human, which sent that human flying.
Throwing a full grown man casually into a ceiling.
Throwing grown men around like ragdolls.
Holding up about 1200lbs over his head for minutes at a time.
Holding a car with one hand while holding onto a bridge with the other.
Pushing a bulldozer.
Slinging Spider-Man around.
Ripping a log in half.
Punching through high tech submarine glass.
Backhanding a Chitauri at least ten feet into a bus.
Ripping Ultron Drones apart with his bare hands.

^ Isn't that bulldozer feat still an outlier? It hasn't actually happened on panel and it far outstrips the other feats that Captain America has?

With that said I'm surprised this thread made it this far. Cap would solidly beat Matt, Danny, and Jessica at once based on what we've seen of him. Luke is the one that makes this a fight IMO.

Originally posted by cdtm
You seriously overrate Cap.

Is he above each of the Netlix crew? Perhaps. But he's not leagues above them like many seem to be arguing.

Cap's solidly in the Nolan Batman/Bane/Matt/Danny level, just like in the comics. Veeery slight advantages in some areas, but hardly insurmountable.

Cap is significantly faster and stronger than all those people.

I'm a Danny fanboy like you, but he would make short work of Netflix IF.

Originally posted by cdtm
Cap's solidly in the Nolan Batman/Bane/Matt/Danny level, just like in the comics. Veeery slight advantages in some areas, but hardly insurmountable.

Dude seriously? Leave Cap, Nolan Bats isn't anywhere on Matt's or Danny's level either.

lol what had Bane done that places him on Dannys or Daredevils level of skill?

Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
You also forgot that it was a different armor. Also he never got hit by multiple missiles ike ever jn my recollection. If you can point out

For someone whose RPG proof, there should be none.

Also, CW Iron Man was damaged by Redwing, and later hurt and grappled by Falcon. And as mentioned earlier, pierced by the arrow and damaged by the explosion. His repulsors barely damaged when it hit the concrete road and did zero damage to the cars thrown by SW. He was unable to catch up to the Quinjet, Falcon or the falling Rhodey.
All performances much below previous armors. And yet somehow the CW armor is equal to the previous ones? What a joke!

Good so no proof👆

Concessions accepted.

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
^ Isn't that bulldozer feat still an outlier? It hasn't actually happened on panel and it far outstrips the other feats that Captain America has?

With that said I'm surprised this thread made it this far. Cap would solidly beat Matt, Danny, and Jessica at once based on what we've seen of him. Luke is the one that makes this a fight IMO.

Also depends on whether you accept Agents of SHIELD as canon for the Marvelverse. It happens in Episode 10:

"In the episode The Bridge (Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) superhuman Mike Peterson pushes a bulldozer across a football field.

Afterwards Mike and his trainer exchange these words:

Mike: Did I beat Captain America’s time?

Trainer: Not even close."

https://movies.stackexchange.com/questions/15829/does-captain-america-possess-superhuman-strength-in-the-mcu

Originally posted by Mindset
Cap is significantly faster and stronger than all those people.

I'm a Danny fanboy like you, but he would make short work of Netflix IF.

Cap is not faster than DD or IF. Are you gauging his speed by on screen speed (acting speed)?

Cap could theoretically hurt Luke with the edge of the shield (using both hands slamming), but not by much. The problem is it will be nearly impossible for Cap to hit Luke that way. Thus, for practical purposes, Cap isn't able to harm Luke. Luke solos.

Originally posted by h1a8
Cap is not faster than DD or IF. Are you gauging his speed by on screen speed (acting speed)?

Wrong, Cap is faster.

Originally posted by h1a8
Cap could theoretically hurt Luke with the edge of the shield (using both hands slamming), but not by much. The problem is it will be nearly impossible for Cap to hit Luke that way. Thus, for practical purposes, Cap isn't able to harm Luke. Luke solos.

HAHAHAHAHA