Emperor Joker vs Living Tribunal

Started by Josh_Alexander16 pages
Originally posted by Galan007
ikr? I mean, he's just a Marvel writer, ffs. Your interpretations as a fan > his published works. 👆

Starlin isnt the only writter in Marvel Comics nor is he the one which decideds the powers and abilities of the Marvel Characters!

Thats the reason most of his comics take place in alternate universes! Cause the info in this arent regarded as canon to the continuity characters but only for his comics!

Go and do some research before believing what a writter says 😉

Originally posted by Galan007
👆

I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt here, and just assume he's trolling hardcore... It's really hard for me to believe anyone is that f*cking stupid.

...Silly me, always trying to see the good in people. 😮

Originally posted by leonidas
😆

there really is a nearly admirable amount of stupid being displayed in this thread. for all his idiocy, it's also nearly commendable to simply state that a writer is just wrong, while a fan is right. i say nearly commendable because were i a mod i'd ban him for such a moronic statement, but bada and pr are apparently blessed with an infinitely greater amount of patience than i am. which, sort of makes me sad... 🙁

You clearly have no knowledge on the topic.

If you think insulting will help you in any way, let me tell you that you
only manage to prove your lack of education.

If you wont add anything productive to this thread, refrain yourself from replying.

Josh is owning hard 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
👆

I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt here, and just assume he's trolling hardcore... It's really hard for me to believe anyone is that f*cking stupid.

...Silly me, always trying to see the good in people. 😮

it is an annoying weakness of character on your part.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Go and do some research before believing what a writter says 😉

{edit}
Scratch everything I just said, leo. Turns out he might actually be that f*cking stupid... mmm

Originally posted by leonidas
it is an annoying weakness of character on your part.

All you have managed to do is throw garbage comments which i care less for and which this thread does as well!

Originally posted by Galan007

{edit}
Scratch everything I just said, leo. Turns out he might actually be that f*cking stupid... mmm

Youve proven more than enough. Let me get a moderator for you ok 😉

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Josh is owning hard 👆

👆

😂

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Starlin doesnt get to dictate what is and what isnt.

If not the original storyteller, then who does?

Originally posted by Astner
If not the original storyteller, then who does?

If Starlin says Spiderman is gay, should you believe him or is that right?

The powers/abilities of Marvel Characters are decided by ALL the writters as a whole.

When you are asked for a character's abilities or powers base yoir answer on the Continuity. In this case the Marvel Continuity. You dont bring What If's or Alternate Universe's ones!

Originally posted by Galan007

{edit}
Scratch everything I just said, leo. Turns out he might actually be that f*cking stupid... mmm

Originally posted by Astner
If not the original storyteller, then who does?

You mean Stan Lee?

Stan Lee wrote LT's first appearance. The page below is from that vey arc and shows LT explaining that all dimensions in existence are under his watch:

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NFYI48nv8iA/VlK2aYNZ7PI/AAAAAAAS6QU/KbVPLiotHqY/s1600/238_03.jpg

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Josh is owning hard 👆

Indeed 👆

Originally posted by Mr Master
I would be more than happy to honor a respectful debate, but please do the same and I'll always reciprocate accordingly. That aside, you cant say "Reed‘s canon > LT" because there's no evidence the "canon" on its own could faze LT. It was designed for 20 years to specifically affect Galactus not LT. Now had Reed shot LT you'd be right, had Reed and LT both shot at each other and Reed‘s canon overpowered LT's force bolt, you'd be right, but that's not the case friend. These are stipulated circumstances that led to LT's bfr. If you‘re being real, then you must agree and let this one go. I love you and God bless. 🙂

So he wasn't defeated?

Originally posted by TheHulkster
You mean Stan Lee?

Stan Lee wrote LT's first appearance. The page below is from that vey arc and shows LT explaining that all dimensions in existence are under his watch:

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NFYI48nv8iA/VlK2aYNZ7PI/AAAAAAAS6QU/KbVPLiotHqY/s1600/238_03.jpg


Roma does the same. Same LT was having trouble against Nobulus in a direct fight.

Stick to the topic. Lay off ad hominems and insults.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Roma does the same. Same LT was having trouble against Nobulus in a direct fight.

Strawman. We are discussing your clam that Starlin defines LT. Below is from Roy Thomas in 1989, before Infinity Guantlet and Starlin's 90s run.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/2/21281/2412527-1159592-thor_annual_1989__014_36_37.jpg

I guess we default to the most recent interpretation, I guess.

I mean,Siegel had the definitive Superman, and many other writers also put their stamp on Supes...but we have to use the latest retcon or feats or whatever.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Strawman. We are discussing your clam that Starlin defines LT. Below is from Roy Thomas in 1989, before Infinity Guantlet and Starlin's 90s run.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/2/21281/2412527-1159592-thor_annual_1989__014_36_37.jpg


That's not by Thomas.

http://www.comicbookdb.com/issue.php?ID=37290

It was written by Peter Sanderson who writes the handbooks and is little more than a handbook entry.

👆