Originally posted by quanchi112
That is in existence not seen or referenced in season seven. I'm not arguing for all races and additional numbers that exist around this time for my side.
See thats why i dont like your thread. If you were to make it General I could use actual numbers and not those seen on screwn cause then i have to assume things!!@
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderWhere is the 50 number coming from ? If we ballpark in what is shown they aren't close to fifty. That's unfair for the spirit of the thread.
Okay just cause you insist.50 giants. Cause you are stubborn. AND DONT EVEN THINK I WILL REDUCE THAT MORE.
65000 Shields in the front line.
Everything remains the same.
And we have 500 boats.
Where is that 65,000 shields number coming from ? Source ?
Originally posted by quanchi112
Where is the 50 number coming from ? If we ballpark in what is shown they aren't close to fifty. That's unfair for the spirit of the thread.Where is that 65,000 shields number coming from ? Source ?
I said no more! 50 it is.
If i were to follow what you say then we only have 5 giants and about 10000 dead!! Just cause 100000 exact werent shown on screen. And just because 100s of Giants werent shown neither!
The official numbers say that Lannisters have 35k and Starks 35k. That makes up 70. Am giving you 65.
Again go research.
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderWhen we do the larger thread we can use total numbers in existence but here we have to keep it season and film contained. We can't make exceptions for one side to include greater numbers not available for the other.
See thats why i dont like your thread. If you were to make it General I could use actual numbers and not those seen on screwn cause then i have to assume things!!@
Originally posted by quanchi112
When we do the larger thread we can use total numbers in existence but here we have to keep it season and film contained. We can't make exceptions for one side to include greater numbers not available for the other.
Naah you just came up with that. Am not reducing my numbers any further. I already did by taking out 100 giants.
You either decide to battle or admit you lose.
DARK will admit that 50 Giants is too little.
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderIf you can't referre a number given I season seven or count them in the white Walker army then it's a baseless claim.
Naah you just came up with that. Am not reducing my numbers any further. I already did by taking out 100 giants.You either decide to battle or admit you lose.
DARK will admit that 50 Giants is too little.
10 is fair.
This isn't about who exists it's about what is shown or referenced in season seven. Read the op.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Be back in fifteen. Agree to 10 Giants and we can agree on the rest of the numbers and get this on.
Man. Idk. 10 is irrational.
Dark will surly disagree on this too!
I can give you 30. Lesd that that i will leave Dark to decide so it doesnt feel like am the only one deciding stuff hahahaha.
Can you agree on 30?
Originally posted by quanchi112
Be back in fifteen. Agree to 10 Giants and we can agree on the rest of the numbers and get this on.
7) When the thread starter makes a new thread, it is very important to cement the conditions of the scenario in the first few posts. This is to avoid confusion and frustration among the other posters. It will not be acceptable for the thread starter to randomly change the conditions of the thread at random intervals. Once the settings/weapons/gear/handicaps/abilities/etc have been cemented in the first few posts of the thread, that is how they will stay. Therefore, be very sure and for certain of how you want your thread to be constructed.
Rules...Next time specify further Quanchi.
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderWe don't see or hear about 30 ever. This isn't about who exists it's about what's referenced or shown.
Man. Idk. 10 is irrational.Dark will surly disagree on this too!
I can give you 30. Lesd that that i will leave Dark to decide so it doesnt feel like am the only one deciding stuff hahahaha.
Can you agree on 30?
Look at that. If you watvh in detail we can see 2 giants in the front ranks. Then we see 1000s of 1000s of dead in the woods...imaginr how much giants are there within! A shame they dont do a close look at them.
At the very last we see 3 more at the back . Almost 5-6 just in the first ranks.
Man that music makes the scene so terrifying and mighty. I cant imagine how much fear will the orcs and elfs and humans from LoTR have when seeing that coming at them. Even Sauron would admit defeat!!!!
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderWhen were they referenced in this season ? We haven't seen more than five in any given battle. Total I'm being more than fair in giving you ten.
100+ were referenced.Am giving you 30. Lets wait for Dark to respond and see what he thinks if you arent comfortable with my numbers.
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderThis is how it always is we only see a few and you want to round up to fifty without proof. I'm being more than fair since we don't even see ten this season which is what the thread is about.
https://youtu.be/4QMQOJTYRBULook at that. If you watvh in detail we can see 2 giants in the front ranks. Then we see 1000s of 1000s of dead in the woods...imaginr how much giants are there within! A shame they dont do a close look at them.
At the very last we see 3 more at the back . Almost 5-6 just in the first ranks.
Man that music makes the scene so terrifying and mighty. I cant imagine how much fear will the orcs and elfs and humans from LoTR have when seeing that coming at them. Even Sauron would admit defeat!!!!
We saw Jon Snow and his band of misfits take on the entire horde and they weren't quivering in fear. Conversely we see Sauron instill fear in his opposition the one time he took to the battlefield. Do you see the difference ? My side has actual fear in battle yours doesn't.
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderSo you believe you win but are arguing for greater numbers you can't prove because ?? If you already feel you win and have the numerical advantage what's the problem ?
Now that i see that scene i believe the sead alone can win this. We are taling about more than 100k dead. Giants, wolves, Direwolfs, Bears, Shaddow Cats, etc.They make a terrifying army...
Oh and one dragon
Originally posted by quanchi112
So you believe you win but are arguing for greater numbers you can't prove because ?? If you already feel you win and have the numerical advantage what's the problem ?
How many more will they kill before losing all 100k dead plus giants, bears etc?
Then all those dead orcs and elfs will be risen by the WE to fight again.
Eiher way the Westeros are still taking part in these. The winner seems clear to me.
Don't fight the inevitable.
Make another thread. Maybe The entire LoTR armies have better chances....
And I've shared valid points on the giants. Don't be stubborn
Originally posted by Josh_AlexanderAll they have to do is kill the Night King, friend.
How many more will they kill before losing all 100k dead plus giants, bears etc?Then all those dead orcs and elfs will be risen by the WE to fight again.
Eiher way the Westeros are still taking part in these. The winner seems clear to me.
Don't fight the inevitable.
Make another thread. Maybe The entire LoTR armies have better chances....
And I've shared valid points on the giants. Don't be stubborn
All negated.
There's no roof just speculation you can't back up. Ten is a fair number and you believe they win despite the Giants so what's wrong ? The entire universe will hammer you into oblivion. Balrog, Uruk Hai, lots of orcs, elves, humans, etc.
Originally posted by quanchi112
All they have to do is kill the Night King, friend.All negated.
There's no roof just speculation you can't back up. Ten is a fair number and you believe they win despite the Giants so what's wrong ? The entire universe will hammer you into oblivion. Balrog, Uruk Hai, lots of orcs, elves, humans, etc.
Lol. Well they h ave to pass 100k dead to do that.
Sido í feel like it is untar. 10 Guante and 15 Bears.