Re: The Mountain, The Hound and Jaime vs. Wolverine
Originally posted by Stigma
GoT characters at their peak.Logan at his peak, but with bone claws.
Setting: Colosseum
They start 100 feet apart.
Who wins?
EDIT: Dang. Meant to say Wolverine in the title. 😬
Okay buddy. First of all, Wolverine is Immortal due to his healing factor!
So this is stupid.
Id say Old Logan seen on screen would make it more fair.
Eh, people seemingly aren't thinking straight. Bone claw Wolverine you say? He gets his head cut off.
Unless Wolverine has some feat that proves otherwise, his claws shouldn't even be able to penetrate the GOT team's armor. Tempered steel is a lot stronger than bone. Not only would his claws be unable to penetrate their armor, their swords should have no problem cutting through his claws.
And though I have often ridiculed GOT characters for having bad fight choreography, Wolverine is also a brawler, who has a nasty habit of running straight at the opponent and simply trying to tank whatever they throw at him. Even at his peak he was never really that skilled a fighter. This means that he'll get cut, stabbed and hacked. Now he might heal from stabs and cuts but he has no feats to prove he can heal from getting limbs completely hacked off. Heck, how will he heal from his head getting cut off?
Not only is he outnumbered and out-geared, he also has a massive reach disadvantage. How long are his claws in the movies, 1 foot? 1.5 feet? Longswords will be anywhere from 3-5 feet long.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Eh, people seemingly aren't thinking straight. Bone claw Wolverine you say? He gets his head cut off.Unless Wolverine has some feat that proves otherwise, his claws shouldn't even be able to penetrate the GOT team's armor. Tempered steel is a lot stronger than bone. Not only would his claws be unable to penetrate their armor, their swords should have no problem cutting through his claws.
And though I have often ridiculed GOT characters for having bad fight choreography, Wolverine is also a brawler, who has a nasty habit of running straight at the opponent and simply trying to tank whatever they throw at him. Even at his peak he was never really that skilled a fighter. This means that he'll get cut, stabbed and hacked. Now he might heal from stabs and cuts but he has no feats to prove he can heal from getting limbs completely hacked off. Heck, how will he heal from his head getting cut off?
Not only is he outnumbered and out-geared, he also has a massive reach disadvantage. How long are his claws in the movies, 1 foot? 1.5 feet? Longswords will be anywhere from 3-5 feet long.
VERY GOOD POINT. I FORGOT THAT! 👆
Yeah, they could cut his head off...
Team wins.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Eh, people seemingly aren't thinking straight. Bone claw Wolverine you say? He gets his head cut off.Unless Wolverine has some feat that proves otherwise, his claws shouldn't even be able to penetrate the GOT team's armor. Tempered steel is a lot stronger than bone. Not only would his claws be unable to penetrate their armor, their swords should have no problem cutting through his claws.
And though I have often ridiculed GOT characters for having bad fight choreography, Wolverine is also a brawler, who has a nasty habit of running straight at the opponent and simply trying to tank whatever they throw at him. Even at his peak he was never really that skilled a fighter. This means that he'll get cut, stabbed and hacked. Now he might heal from stabs and cuts but he has no feats to prove he can heal from getting limbs completely hacked off. Heck, how will he heal from his head getting cut off?
Not only is he outnumbered and out-geared, he also has a massive reach disadvantage. How long are his claws in the movies, 1 foot? 1.5 feet? Longswords will be anywhere from 3-5 feet long.
You might be the one not thinking straight here. First, Sabretooth's much smaller claws casually shredded the hood of a car. All he did was put them on the metal and walk forward. He cut clean through to the other side. So there's a good chance with all his strength he can punch straight through the armor if nothing else. Also, iirc Mountain is the only one to wear a helmet, and it has plenty of opening for Logan to stab into. So he can headshot all of them easily. Or just use his super strength to toss them around.
Secondly, you know good and well Logan is a brawler because he can afford to be. He knows he has a healing factor + Adamantium. If he doesn't have them, he'll fight more carefully. However, he has shown on multiple occasions just how fast and skilled he is. His single fight with Shingen(claws vs two katana) puts him on a different skill/speed set than GoT. They wouldn't be able to touch him.
YouTube video
Originally posted by KingD19
You might be the one not thinking straight here. First, Sabretooth's much smaller claws casually shredded the hood of a car. All he did was put them on the metal and walk forward. He cut clean through to the other side. So there's a good chance with all his strength he can punch straight through the armor if nothing else. Also, iirc Mountain is the only one to wear a helmet, and it has plenty of opening for Logan to stab into. So he can headshot all of them easily. Or just use his super strength to toss them around.Secondly, you know good and well Logan is a brawler because he can afford to be. He knows he has a healing factor + Adamantium. If he doesn't have them, he'll fight more carefully. However, he has shown on multiple occasions just how fast and skilled he is. His single fight with Shingen(claws vs two katana) puts him on a different skill/speed set than GoT. They wouldn't be able to touch him.
YouTube video
He is thinking straight.
Wolverine has no adamantium. He is going against 3 good swordsman.
The mountain has been shown to take a LOT. Meanwhile Jaime and Hound decapitate Logan!
Car metal and knignt armor isnt the same you realize right!?
Originally posted by KingD19
You might be the one not thinking straight here. First, Sabretooth's much smaller claws casually shredded the hood of a car. All he did was put them on the metal and walk forward. He cut clean through to the other side. So there's a good chance with all his strength he can punch straight through the armor if nothing else. Also, iirc Mountain is the only one to wear a helmet, and it has plenty of opening for Logan to stab into. So he can headshot all of them easily. Or just use his super strength to toss them around.Secondly, you know good and well Logan is a brawler because he can afford to be. He knows he has a healing factor + Adamantium. If he doesn't have them, he'll fight more carefully. However, he has shown on multiple occasions just how fast and skilled he is. His single fight with Shingen(claws vs two katana) puts him on a different skill/speed set than GoT. They wouldn't be able to touch him.
YouTube video
I hope you're not serious with that car example. You do realize there's a HUUUGE difference between the aluminum and sheet metal used on a car's body compared with the tempered steel of a knight's armor right?
Wolverine's fight against Shingen is a bad example to use. For one thing, Wolverine barely dodged any of Shingen's blows. Majority he blocked with his claws... which is something he won't be able to do with bone claws against longswords. Secondly, Wolverine got hit multiple times in that fight, and actually wasn't able to land a single hit on Shingen up until the last surprise attack. That's not exactly a good show of skill is it? And that was only against one opponent, he's fighting 3 opponents here who'll have swords quite longer than a katana and who'll be decently protected against his claws.
Wolverine is just not skilled enough to easily do headshots. Shingen wasn't wearing a helmet too, Wolverine couldn't land a hit on his head.
Originally posted by FrothByteSolid post
Eh, people seemingly aren't thinking straight. Bone claw Wolverine you say? He gets his head cut off.Unless Wolverine has some feat that proves otherwise, his claws shouldn't even be able to penetrate the GOT team's armor. Tempered steel is a lot stronger than bone. Not only would his claws be unable to penetrate their armor, their swords should have no problem cutting through his claws.
And though I have often ridiculed GOT characters for having bad fight choreography, Wolverine is also a brawler, who has a nasty habit of running straight at the opponent and simply trying to tank whatever they throw at him. Even at his peak he was never really that skilled a fighter. This means that he'll get cut, stabbed and hacked. Now he might heal from stabs and cuts but he has no feats to prove he can heal from getting limbs completely hacked off. Heck, how will he heal from his head getting cut off?
Not only is he outnumbered and out-geared, he also has a massive reach disadvantage. How long are his claws in the movies, 1 foot? 1.5 feet? Longswords will be anywhere from 3-5 feet long.
Originally posted by FrothBytejust off the top of my head, he threw sabertooth on top that logging truck in origins.
Strength won't really help you from getting cut up and your limbs chopped off.Also, I know Wolverine is strong but I don't recall him displaying super strength. Could you mention the specific feats?
Also sabertooth lifted one of those huge logs off Logan one handed with ease. Even though sabes was stronger than Logan, it wasn't a massive difference.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Strength won't really help you from getting cut up and your limbs chopped off.Also, I know Wolverine is strong but I don't recall him displaying super strength. Could you mention the specific feats?
He's faster than any of these guys, and nothing short of a decap will really slow him down.
He's ragdolled some niggas around through the series. Even a dying OML was stronger than the average man, and X-24 had some blatant displays of super strength with that armored truck at the end.
Originally posted by Psychotron
He's faster than any of these guys, and nothing short of a decap will really slow him down.He's ragdolled some niggas around through the series. Even a dying OML was stronger than the average man, and X-24 had some blatant displays of super strength with that armored truck at the end.
The Mountain and Hound entertain him while Jaime decapitates him!!
I love Logan, but against 3 good fighters and no adamantium....Logans Adamantium is what makes him most formidable.
Originally posted by Psychotron
He's faster than any of these guys, and nothing short of a decap will really slow him down.He's ragdolled some niggas around through the series. Even a dying OML was stronger than the average man, and X-24 had some blatant displays of super strength with that armored truck at the end.
Well X-24 is not Wolverine. He showed strength far more than what Wolverine has shown in the past. Wolverine is definitely stronger than the average man, stronger even than probably the strongest athlete. But I don't think he'd be in Captain America's league.
In any case, my main point stands, that his strength won't save him from getting dismembered. If he gets his claws cut off it will slow him down. You saw how much pain he was in when Creed broke his claws. Gets his hands or arms cut off will slow him down. Legs cut off will slow him down. A broken skull or a stab through the face will probably slow him down. Broken/cut spine will slow him down. I could go on...
Lol. People thinking Wolverine is some kind of ninja. Yes he moves faster than the GOT guys but not by that much, and he's definitely not skilled enough to simply dodge around all the sword blows of 3 skilled swordsmen.
Even if he does, that still doesn't address the issue that his bone claws won't penetrare tempered plate armor.