Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Ehhh no. If Tony Stark comes out and claims Adamantium to be stronger than Vibranium then it is.
For the purposes of a debate you'd need more than Tony Starks word.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No. Movies use statements to reveal details on things.If the movie states that Captain America is 30 years old, then he is 30 years old!
If the movie says that Adamantium>Vibranium then it is.
Period!
This example does not fit. There is more than a statement going on. We have all the screen time of Cap. We can see how old he looks, maybe not an exact age, but at least a general idea. Whereas if all we had is a mere statement about adamantium it wouldn't be corroborated by anything.
Originally posted by Silent Master
Right, if Tony stated he ran an analysis of the metals and x or y was stronger. that would hold some weight. but him just out of the blue saying one is stronger would mean nothing without feats.
Indeed, feats are the best way to go about it if people are going to debate it.
Originally posted by FrothByte
And yet Mystique was running circles around him, and if she had claws of her own and an indestructible suit would have ripped him apart.
You mean the 2000 X Men film where Wolverine was much younger and arguably the weakest?
Also Mystique is arguably more agile than BP!
Furthermore, Mystique ran away from the fight and didnt manage to actually defeat Logan!
Yeah sure! BP gets opened in half.
Originally posted by Silent Master
We don't know how much Vibranium that Ultron contained and it was hit by Thor, Iron-man and a Infinity stone. which is far better than Fox's admantium getting cut.
Vibranium:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jpNYG5AoAI
Adamantium:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1oUy-RwW9c
Vibranium clearly melt and even exploded. Adamantium got red due to the heat, but didn't melt nor deformed.
There are no actual numbers as to how much heat these metals received in the above videos. So there isn't a direct comparison.
However i would say the heat received by both Adamantium and Vibranium above must be arround the same.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNtJlpGKL2Y
Which one cuts better?
A sharp knife or a sharp HOT KNIFE?
The Silver Samurai used a super hot Adamantium Katana to cut Wolverine's claws!
Considering we saw Wolverine's claws blocking Energy Beams without damage, that Sword must have been RIDICULOUSLY HOT!
Adamantium>Vibranium.
Originally posted by Surtur
For the purposes of a debate you'd need more than Tony Starks word.This example does not fit. There is more than a statement going on. We have all the screen time of Cap. We can see how old he looks, maybe not an exact age, but at least a general idea. Whereas if all we had is a mere statement about adamantium it wouldn't be corroborated by anything.
Ehh no. If in any upcoming movie a scientist or a character says that Ad>Vib then you got your answer.
Movies use characters to reveal information.
If a character in the MCU claims that Ad is above Vib then it's all i need for this debate.
Originally posted by Silent Master
Right, if Tony stated he ran an analysis of the metals and x or y was stronger. that would hold some weight. but him just out of the blue saying one is stronger would mean nothing without feats.
Lol. If it were to ment nothing then why in the heck would the movie post it or have a character say it in the first place??
You are lacking logic!