Starkiller vs. Darth Nihilus (TK battle)

Started by Haschwalth8 pages

Lol 150 meters, try 1.2km of the ravager

You're aware of the difference between holding something together and moving it in comparison to completely blowing it apart...

Originally posted by Naugrim
You're aware of the difference between holding something together and moving it in comparison to completely blowing it apart...

Yeah, and it's a lot less, than what is shown here.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba

Only 50 megatons.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba#/media/File:Tsar_Bomba_Paris.png

3.5km, would be completely incinerated.

150m frigate shattered, much gasps, so strong, yeah nah.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
https://www.narutoforums.org/xfa-blog-entry/star-wars-feat-darth-nihilius-tks-the-ravager.19653/#comment-175643

Yeah, that doesn't touch Marek's cannon feat which is several orders of magnitude above it and the calc is likely off given they assumed the artificial gravity the MSG had upon activating was still present when Nihilus accomplished the feat, something that was likely not the case given Meetra was able to pilot a ship off planet as Freshest pointed out earlier..

"Given the planet was still under the effects of the artificial gravity generated by the MSG, I'll be using treating the planet's mass as though it's the artificial one from that blog." - The blog you linked.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
Yeah, and it's a lot less, than what is shown here.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba

Only 50 megatons.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba#/media/File:Tsar_Bomba_Paris.png

3.5km, would be completely incinerated.

Wtf are you talking about? We're not comparing blast radius's here. We're comparing the effects of their respective manipulation.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
150m frigate shattered, much gasps, so strong, yeah nah.

You get that there's a difference between a blast having a radius of 150 meters and a blast having the power to shatter a shielded scifi frigate, correct?

Originally posted by Naugrim
Yeah, that doesn't touch Marek's cannon feat which is several orders of magnitude above it and the calc is likely off given they assumed the artificial gravity the MSG had upon activating was still present when Nihilus accomplished the feat, something that was likely not the case given Meetra was able to pilot a ship off planet as Freshest pointed out earlier.

You do realize, energy cores in starwars are insane.
Republic ships at the time had"planet shattering" power sources. A ship could easily get off even without, a thousandth of that power.

Originally posted by Naugrim
You get that there's a difference between a blast having a radius of 150 meters and a blast having the power to shatter a shielded scifi frigate, correct?

Didn't realize Shields stopped the force being used inside the Ship.
This is Tk we are talking about right?

Originally posted by Haschwalth
You do realize, energy cores in starwars are insane.
Republic ships at the time had"planet shattering" power sources. A ship could easily get off even without, a thousandth of that power.

Gonna need a quote for that.

Originally posted by Naugrim
Wtf are you talking about? We're not comparing blast radius's here. We're comparing the effects of their respective manipulation.

mHmm, and by your logic, this should be more powerful than shattering it.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
Didn't realize Shields stopped the force being used inside the Ship.
This is Tk we are talking about right?

You're aware that ships in Star Wars possess interior shielding and that Starkiller was outside of the ship when he blew it up, correct?

Originally posted by Haschwalth
mHmm, and by your logic, this should be more powerful than shattering it.

And how do you figure that?

Originally posted by Naugrim
Gonna need a quote for that.

"Remember the four wrecked Republic ships you passed earlier? Each of them contains an active power core that can be turned into an energy source for a planet-shattering explosion. You must take control of the little remote droid and pilot it to each of the four ships to bring them online."

http://www.theberserker.net/berserk...otor_II_OSG.pdf

Originally posted by Naugrim
And how do you figure that?

You know basic physics right shattering(i'm guessing pulverization)<vaporization<Atomize

The link you posted takes you to an error page.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
You know basic physics right shattering(i'm guessing pulverization)<vaporization<Atomize

The difference being that a scifi frigate is going to be more durable then modern age building material...

Originally posted by Naugrim
Your link takes you to an error page.

Weird it's the Kotor 2 hand guide.

206 Prima official game guide.
at 210/304


After entering Trayus
Academy, the scene shifts
back to the Ebon Hawk's
crash site. Bao-Dur has
programmed his trusty
remote droid to accomplish one final task: the destruction of
Malachor V. Remember the four wrecked Republic ships you
passed earlier? Each of them contains an active power core that
can be turned into an energy source for a planet-shattering
explosion. You must take control of the little remote droid and
pilot it to each of the four ships to bring them online.

Originally posted by Naugrim
The difference being that a scifi frigate is going to be more durable then modern age building material...

No shit, this is only 50 Megatons with the range, which is nothing.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
No shit, this is only 50 Megatons with the range, which is nothing.

What's only 50MT? The frigate feat? If you're using a nuclear blast calculator to calc that then you're proving my point. Such a tool can't take into account the durability of materials from a scifi universe or its shielding and thus can't give us an accurate estimation of the force needed to blow it apart. If that wasn't what you were saying, then I'm curious what that "50 megatons" you're talking about is in reference to.