Immortal Hulk vs All-Star Superman,

Started by carver917 pages

Hulk stomps. The guy stood in one spot and tanked punches from beings who can stop a planet from spinning. Not only that, the planetary guy actually hurt his hand punching Hulk. Then to add on to that, he flexed his muscles and brushed both of these planetary beings off of him.

I always find these Hulk versus Superman threads really silly. Even if one assumes that the two are equal in strength (and valid points can be made that one or the other is ‘stronger,’ but even if they are taken as equal), the point still remains that one of them has a variety of other (high-level) powers that simply make this into a non-fight.

Sure, in a comic book it can be written where they both face each other and start trading punches WWE-style like idiots. But in a forum fight ...even taking out fanboys on both sides - it really is a non-fight.

All in, Superman (and other high-level multi-capable characters like him) will always defeat the Hulk (and other one-dimensional characters like him). Always. Anything but that either means PIS (required to make comic books interesting), or fanboyism.

Same reason why Gladiator/Supreme beats Solomon Grundy ...every single time.

It would be really difficult (in a forum) for a character like Solomon Grundy or the Hulk to beat someone with similar strength levels, high level speed that can be compared to that of (almost) any speedster, and a variety of other powers and abilities (all at very high levels).

Ridiculous - it would be like me giving the Hulk speed significantly greater than Quicksilver, eye blasts greater than Cyclop’s, flight ability better than Ms Marvel, the ability to generate winds like Storm, the ability to freeze things like Ice Man, senses better than Wolverine’s ...and then take this Super-Hulk and have it fight Abomination!

It would be ridiculous. Yet every second week there’s a Superman vs Hulk (or similar ...eg, Silver Surfer vs Superman, which Kal loses hard in a forum fight) thread.

Superman will always beat Hulk, unless someone can show me how the ‘Super Hulk’ I described could be defeated by Abomination!

👆

I don't even know why Abomination is being mentioned for Hulk. It's like bringing up Superman struggling against Grundy and almost getting one hit killed by Titus. Anyways, Hulk and Abomination last fight, Hulk tanked Abomination all out assault and 3 pieces him with ease in their latest fight...

Dont get why people haven't realized Hulk is a different beast now. Some of the people Supermsn struggle with, Hulk would problem treat them like fodder.

That doesn't looks like treating Abomination as fodder.

Also that is a flashback when Abomination was still Depowered.

Who are the characters who Hulk will treat like fodder Carter? Sun God?

Originally posted by abhilegend
That doesn't looks like treating Abomination as fodder.

Also that is a flashback when Abomination was still Depowered.

Who are the characters who Hulk will treat like fodder Carter? Sun God?

Titus. Konvikt. Grundy (lol). Kalibak (lol).

Originally posted by carver9
Titus. Konvikt. Grundy (lol). Kalibak (lol).

How would Hulk treat Titus and Konvikt as fodder? Superman treats Grundy and Kalibak as fodder.

By being more powerful.

Superman vs Damage is going to give one of you an aneurysm.

Tbf, Hulk would fold almost all those guys in half.

Originally posted by carver9
By being more powerful.

Based on?
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Superman vs Damage is going to give one of you an aneurysm.

Tbf, Hulk would fold almost all those guys in half.


Just like he did to sun god, right?

Originally posted by spetznaz
I always find these Hulk versus Superman threads really silly. Even if one assumes that the two are equal in strength (and valid points can be made that one or the other is ‘stronger,’ but even if they are taken as equal), the point still remains that one of them has a variety of other (high-level) powers that simply make this into a non-fight.

Sure, in a comic book it can be written where they both face each other and start trading punches WWE-style like idiots. But in a forum fight ...even taking out fanboys on both sides - it really is a non-fight.

All in, Superman (and other high-level multi-capable characters like him) will always defeat the Hulk (and other one-dimensional characters like him). Always. Anything but that either means PIS (required to make comic books interesting), or fanboyism.

Same reason why Gladiator/Supreme beats Solomon Grundy ...every single time.

It would be really difficult (in a forum) for a character like Solomon Grundy or the Hulk to beat someone with similar strength levels, high level speed that can be compared to that of (almost) any speedster, and a variety of other powers and abilities (all at very high levels).

Ridiculous - it would be like me giving the Hulk speed significantly greater than Quicksilver, eye blasts greater than Cyclop’s, flight ability better than Ms Marvel, the ability to generate winds like Storm, the ability to freeze things like Ice Man, senses better than Wolverine’s ...and then take this Super-Hulk and have it fight Abomination!

It would be ridiculous. Yet every second week there’s a Superman vs Hulk (or similar ...eg, Silver Surfer vs Superman, which Kal loses hard in a forum fight) thread.

Superman will always beat Hulk, unless someone can show me how the ‘Super Hulk’ I described could be defeated by Abomination!

I agree, which is why Superman losing to Doomsday is pretty unbelievable.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Based on?
Just like he did to sun god, right?

See you keep mentioning Sun God. Mention everyone Superman lost to recently. Hell, Frankenstein of all people flash koed him with a tractor. Aquaman was wrecking him. He stands no chance against Hulk.

Originally posted by carver9
See you keep mentioning Sun God. Mention everyone Superman lost to recently. Hell, Frankenstein of all people flash koed him with a tractor. Aquaman was wrecking him. He stands no chance against Hulk.

Uh-huh. I guess Superman can beat up Sun God and that alternate Hulk which defeated the Hulk, right?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Uh-huh. I guess Superman can beat up Sun God and that alternate Hulk which defeated the Hulk, right?

Scans of alternate Hulk beating Hulk.

Originally posted by carver9
Scans of alternate Hulk beating Hulk.

As you wish.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-G3KftfKWGnU/VmAePKZYXJI/AAAAAAAADAs/9B8X5iiB1GA/s1600-Ic42/RCO008.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-xSyNhb4i4fE/VmAePkEG-tI/AAAAAAAADAs/gZ7rKYI_boI/s1600-Ic42/RCO009.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-hQPR806Wwls/VmAeP1LfeRI/AAAAAAAADAs/Fi9RPulcYhM/s1600-Ic42/RCO010.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NRB-F5lyEkw/VmAeQnCxRqI/AAAAAAAADAs/3YlRq9g_qZM/s1600-Ic42/RCO014.jpg

Did I mention that this Hulk could not get stronger with anger?

Originally posted by abhilegend
As you wish.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-G3KftfKWGnU/VmAePKZYXJI/AAAAAAAADAs/9B8X5iiB1GA/s1600-Ic42/RCO008.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-xSyNhb4i4fE/VmAePkEG-tI/AAAAAAAADAs/gZ7rKYI_boI/s1600-Ic42/RCO009.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-hQPR806Wwls/VmAeP1LfeRI/AAAAAAAADAs/Fi9RPulcYhM/s1600-Ic42/RCO010.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NRB-F5lyEkw/VmAeQnCxRqI/AAAAAAAADAs/3YlRq9g_qZM/s1600-Ic42/RCO014.jpg

Did I mention that this Hulk could not get stronger with anger?

That was 616 Hulk that lost? Holy, i never seen this scene. Was that alternate Hulk featless, if so pis

Ah, of course. That's doc green that was Ko'ed, Not WBH

Originally posted by Baziemarc123
That was 616 Hulk that lost? Holy, i never seen this scene. Was that alternate Hulk featless, if so pis
Originally posted by Baziemarc123
Ah, of course. That's doc green that was Ko'ed, Not WBH

Doc Green isn't Hulk?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Doc Green isn't Hulk?

Yea he is, but weaker incarnation

How is he weaker?

Originally posted by abhilegend
How is he weaker?

call it a fallacy, but should be widely known Doc Green doesn't have relative feats that's on par with WBH. and WBH is regarded as the strongest before Immortal Hulk