MCU Thor vs MCU Hulk compared

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Nope, my logic is supreme and untouchable by your foul hands...

Feats are quantifiable and Thor has the advantage here...

Until you can produce a durability feat by the Hulk on par with tanking a Neutron Star, Thor wins...

Originally posted by quanchi112
If Gandalf has greater feats than Sauron that doesn’t mean he’s more powerful than him it just means we didn’t see a greater feat from Sauron not that he isn’t capable just we didn’t see it. You’re a moron. You’ll always be a moron. You come from a family of morons.

Stop attempting to use a strawman argument...

Hulk doesn't have a feat of durability on par with Thor...

End of discussion...

Thor wins...

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Stop attempting to use a strawman argument...

Hulk doesn't have a feat of durability on par with Thor...

End of discussion...

Thor wins...

Here's a direct durability comparison:

Hulk was dropped 30,000 ft in the air. He got knocked out and reverted back to Banner. Thor was dropped thousands of feet from outer space, he immediately got up after crash landing.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Here's a direct durability comparison:

Hulk was dropped 30,000 ft in the air. He got knocked out and reverted back to Banner. Thor was dropped thousands of feet from outer space, he immediately got up after crash landing.

^ Except none of those are direct comparisons.

Originally posted by quanchi112
We see banner fall and more than likely break bones on the Asgard bridge but Hulk comes out and he’s completely fine. Or we see Thor dodge bullets while Hulk swats them away. He doesn’t need to duck. We see how each interacts against Thanos in the film. Thor isn’t as strong or as durable as the Hulk. It makes no sense to claim Thor is on par physically with the Hulk. He relies on his skill and versatility. He’s strong and very durable just not on Hulk’s level. This is consistent with the comics.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
As already been mentioned, in direct comparison Thor was hurt after the arena fight and Hulk wasn't despite taking most of the hits being dished out.

Thor has the skill and versatility of course.

Completely untrue. Hulk threw more attacks in that ground and pound than all the other attacks in the entire fight probably.

I like how Hulk was recuperating in a hot tub to soothe his sore body after Thor beat the shit out of him.

Let's see, WHO was 2v1'd because they were winning?

1. Thor?
2. Hulk?

Oh, that's right, the answer is THOR. That says all that needs be said.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
So the fact of the matter is that Hulk has no feat on par with tanking a Neutron Star...

Thor is superior as pertains durability as a result...

👆

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Completely untrue. Hulk threw more attacks in that ground and pound than all the other attacks in the entire fight probably.

Had a quick rewatch of the scene just in case I was remembering it wrong, yes Thor had the power within himself but he clearly needed those visions to unlock it he looks shocked when he sees the lightning flowing through his body initially. Then against Hela his body doesn't crackle until after Odins appears again and basically tells him about powers, prior to that moment he was defenceless.

I can agree the lightning gives him some type of rejuvenating effect but it doesn't seem to completely heal him or has limits he was still notably fatigued after the Hela fight for example and didn't seem to think it would be useful when Thanos was killing him and his people on the Asgardian ship. When he healed from near death in IW they needed to get his hammer to him first... I'm skeptical. There's also the fact that if it does "erase all previous damage" once he transforms then Hulk effectively one shotted Thor at the end of that arena fight.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Then you need to rewatch the fight. The ground n pound was roughly a dozen hits, Thor landed more than that throughout the fight and landed 2 of the biggest hits at the end besides Hulks atomic punch. Hulk was unharmed while Thor needed nursing after that's undeniable and a direct comparison of durability.

Had a quick rewatch of the scene just in case I was remembering it wrong, yes Thor had the power within himself but he clearly needed those visions to unlock it he looks shocked when he sees the lightning flowing through his body initially. Then against Hela his body doesn't crackle until after Odins appears again and basically tells him about powers, prior to that moment he was defenceless.

I can agree the lightning gives him some type of rejuvenating effect but it doesn't seem to completely heal him or has limits he was still notably fatigued after the Hela fight for example and didn't seem to think it would be useful when Thanos was killing him and his people on the Asgardian ship. When he healed from near death in IW they needed to get his hammer to him first... I'm skeptical. There's also the fact that if it does "erase all previous damage" once he transforms then Hulk effectively one shotted Thor at the end of that arena fight.

Originally posted by FrothByte
^ Except none of those are direct comparisons.

Originally posted by Nevan
Are you really saying that Thor would be hurt by bullets?

originally posted by quanchi112-

Yes, they are. Both are in the same scene reacting to bullets. Hulk looked superior to a guy dodging. Against Thanos for ****s sake Thor looked pitiful compared to Hulk’s strength. He even had a weapon.

Again, this is a horrible example. Thor was beaten to the point where he could barely move. He couldn't even summon lightning. Thanos and crew wrecked Thor, that is true. But ask yourself, why the **** did Hulk not Help Thor out? Obviously Hulk was hiding like a ***** letting Thor get owned by Thanos and his entire crew before he decided to fight.

Anyway, a weakened, ****ed up Thor that can barely move of course won't impact Thanos much. However, Thor at full strength with Stormbreaker sure as hell did. Damn near killed him. Meanwhile, Hulk was such a pussy that after he got his ass beat he didn't even have the guts to fight lesser mobs, let alone Thanos or his children.

Thor > Hulk, and it's not even close.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb

Thor > Hulk, and it's not even close.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Again, this is a horrible example. Thor was beaten to the point where he could barely move. He couldn't even summon lightning. Thanos and crew wrecked Thor, that is true. But ask yourself, why the **** did Hulk not Help Thor out? Obviously Hulk was hiding like a ***** letting Thor get owned by Thanos and his entire crew before he decided to fight.

Anyway, a weakened, ****ed up Thor that can barely move of course won't impact Thanos much. However, Thor at full strength with Stormbreaker sure as hell did. Damn near killed him. Meanwhile, Hulk was such a pussy that after he got his ass beat he didn't even have the guts to fight lesser mobs, let alone Thanos or his children.

Thor > Hulk, and it's not even close.

Thor admitted he needed the axe so it’s the axe. Hulk is pissed off at Banner but make no mistake he will be there when they need him. They definitely will since Thanos is the best villain in the history of marvel.

They fight twice Thor didn’t win so continue to believe whatever you want. You can’t prove it. I believe it’s as close as it gets with each guy having advantages. I favor Hulk slightly straight up beat with the axe Thor would annihilate him.

Originally posted by Darth Thor

Actually your opinion as well. As youve finally kneeled to my superior Wisdom and admitted Thor is the teams true Powerhouse.

Hopefully Hulk will get a better showing in Avengers 4 because he was the LVP of the film. Thor MVP, Hulk LVP.