Why is Hulk above Herald tier...

Originally posted by xJLxKing
A lot like how Superman has done it on many occassion

http://i.imgur.com/QVo1Tv9.jpg

This has been debunked on so many occasions.

Originally posted by Baziemarc123
that scaling's kinda iffy. and i don't think "cutting' through time would be quantifiable

What scaling? Cutting through time is a ft though.

I think youre missing the point Carver.

So yes Hulk is strong and granted he has some pretty uber feats. My issue with saying he is trans is that he rarely gets to prove it outside his weight class. He is either depicted fighting a random monster or groups that just want to talk him down. Maybe he needs a decent rogue gallery or do something off planet, i dunno. Imo hes not used very well in marvel. Id like to see him getting some different plots.

Originally posted by carver9
No, he cant. Are you saying he can cover the distance before anyone can do anything about it? His reflexes are sharp but I never knew of Doomsday as a runner.

DD ran more than 0.5km when he attacked DS. Basically DS heard DD get up from the rubble And before he can turn, DD was there beating him up.

DD also attacked the entire JL from about 0.1km back before anyone could react.

DD outran flash in DD wars.

Originally posted by carver9
This has been debunked on so many occasions.

Still lying eh. pathetic.

Originally posted by carver9
I'm using Hulk within a 10 yr span and yes, you can refute. I opened it for you all just in case you wanted to go against what I am saying.

Originally posted by carver9
Phil, I'm not doing a battle zone. We could do a battlezone where I had Surfer and you was repping Cyclops and I would lose. You're better than me at those. You have far more experience. My thread isnt to attract a battle zone, its to prove a point. We have been going 2 pages off topic. The plan that I want for this thread is for me to post my reasoning and you all debating against THAT reason.

Posters coming back from the dead left and right

Originally posted by Damborgson
Posters coming back from the dead left and right

Pretty sure I've seen Neme in the movie vs forum and I'm certain Neme in the star wars vs forum.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Are you referring to me? I've been here the whole time lol. Don't post as much or debate much anymore, but I've been here.

Ah, my mistake! Good to see you regardless

Originally posted by carver9
People can bash Ironman all they want but the guy is durable when he is armored up. He has withstood hits from Namor, to Wonderman, from Thor to cosmic Heralds like Surfer and even Sentry and Starbrand. I cant think of a time where Tony has been one shot koed. Someone is entitled to fill me in on that. Anyways, his gets out of his normal armor and ramps up in a more powerful armor

Name a time he prepped beyond his level (Low Herald) and didn't get his armour trashed.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Is the challenge specifically for Carver?

But it would be nice if it was him. Story wise.

Originally posted by Philosophía
No

But it would be nice if it was him. Story wise.

Alright, if you accept I'm down 👆

I'm pent up after this whole tournament.

Originally posted by Damborgson
Alright, if you accept I'm down 👆

I'm pent up after this whole tournament.

Let me know when you're ok to start a week before. WWH [baring WBH] vs Magneto? [of course, you get the showings of the other versions, too, but as a starting point]

Originally posted by carver9
Phil, I'm not doing a battle zone. We could do a battlezone where I had Surfer and you was repping Cyclops and I would lose. You're better than me at those. You have far more experience. My thread isnt to attract a battle zone, its to prove a point. We have been going 2 pages off topic. The plan that I want for this thread is for me to post my reasoning and you all debating against THAT reason.

Basically, PIS, lol. If you can't do a BZ with proof, it means that one's character is highly dependent on the writer's wank.....and that you're just not as good as the writer in wanking.

For a example. Is Hulk green? Of course. This is without a doubt. I will happily BZ something like that. I can challenge abhi.

Is he greener than Green Lantern? 'oh, abhi is better than me at this, so I won't BZ him'.

IOW, it's well within the realms of doubt. No matter how good Phildo is, he's not going to BZ Magneto being Chinese. Because that's a losing proposition for one side.

But Hulk being able to beat a Low Herald? With BFR turned off? Boom. This is suddenly debatable.

And this is why Hulk is not above HH.

If good ol Carv had actual proof that Hulk is trans he could wipe the floor with everyone in a battlezone who challanges him with low herald.

You'd need like 5 scans and say: That's it I'm done.

Yeah I mean let's take others in the trans tier. Thanos? Zoom? Amazo? SBP? S1M? Silver Age Kryptonians?

Put them up against Magneto,no BFR. See how that goes.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Basically, PIS, lol. If you can't do a BZ with proof, it means that one's character is highly dependent on the writer's wank.....and that you're just not as good as the writer in wanking.

For a example. Is Hulk green? Of course. This is without a doubt. I will happily BZ something like that. I can challenge abhi.

Is he greener than Green Lantern? 'oh, abhi is better than me at this, so I won't BZ him'.

IOW, it's well within the realms of doubt. No matter how good Phildo is, he's not going to BZ Magneto being Chinese. Because that's a losing proposition for one side.

But Hulk being able to beat a Low Herald? With BFR turned off? Boom. This is suddenly debatable.

And this is why Hulk is not above HH.

I agree, this is why HP Doomsday needs to be knocked down to HH. Blink would beat him 10/10 and she is a meta.

WITH BFR TURNED OFF

READ THE POST. READ PHILDOS CHALLENGE.