Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Started by abhilegend1,926 pages

Not only that but Green Arrow's connection to Seven Soldiers oc Victory was reestablished. From Stargirl Spring Break Special 1

Its just that Oliver used time travel to be the same Green Arrow in 1940s.

Originally posted by abhilegend
From Stargirl Spring Break Special 1
Sounds like something Stilt would write.

laughcry

Ridiculous showings for DC top tiers all around. Rock of Eternity can shatter every dimension it is connected to (which is literally every reality) and it's linked to Billy's emotions. So when ROE starts endangering every reality, The captain literally punches it out of reality.

****ing ridonkulus.

Shang Chi blitzes Cap, Wasp and Monica Rambeau together.

https://ibb.co/k3BRnLZ

Originally posted by abhilegend
Ridiculous showings for DC top tiers all around. Rock of Eternity can shatter every dimension it is connected to (which is literally every reality) and it's linked to Billy's emotions. So when ROE starts endangering every reality, The captain literally punches it out of reality.

****ing ridonkulus.

Where did he punch it out of reality? What page?

Originally posted by carver9
Where did he punch it out of reality? What page?

Carvster, here's the Captain saying he needs to remove the rock of eternity from reality to save reality.

https://ibb.co/f88Yk3b

Here's him punching it.

https://ibb.co/GQftZVt

Here's the confirmation that it is gone along with Billy.

https://ibb.co/zh6pmZw

Are you sure you can read?

Originally posted by carver9
Where did he punch it out of reality? What page?

Second to last page. Where he's punching the rock,lmao.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Carvster, here's the Captain saying he needs to remove the rock of eternity from reality to save reality.

https://ibb.co/f88Yk3b

Here's him punching it.

https://ibb.co/GQftZVt

Here's the confirmation that it is gone along with Billy.

https://ibb.co/zh6pmZw

Are you sure you can read?

Carver basically cannot read. He just looked at the scans, and is probably arguing that he punched the rock Really Far Away lmao.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Shang Chi blitzes Cap, Wasp and Monica Rambeau together.

https://ibb.co/k3BRnLZ

lol "blitz"

They were 100% in their right mind. Stop Asian Hate.

Also they were shouting but not actually fighting, and he.... thumbed them on the forehead.

"Shang Chi blitzes all three!" is pretty... sensationalized

They were compromised. 🤷🏾‍♂️

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Because I don't see the question has any relation to actually support your position?

Wonder Woman's WW2 career summarization? Well, see the wiki or whatever articles summarize it.

Justice Society in current continuity has no plans to tap into the topic as far as I know

I'm not asking how DC comics have historically portrayed WW2 Wonder Woman's career. I'm asking you how we should conglomerate WW2 Wonder Woman's pre-Crisis career into the singular canon history of current Wonder Woman.

Stop evading. We both know exactly why I am needling you over this. I'll label it aloud: reductio ad absurdum. Do what you can to dispel it.

Originally posted by carver9
They were compromised.
They were. Until Shang tapped them.

Originally posted by Smurph
They were. Until Shang tapped them.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Then every single retcon since then, or contradiction, then overlays on top of it. But the central premise still remains - that Pre Crisis is canon to current, EXCEPT where it is retconned.
Well, among other things, Wonder Woman's first adventure with Superman and Batman was just re-re-retconned in last month's Batman/Superman: World's Finest #30.

So you and I should have no argument? My argument is with qwertyuiop1998 who is continually evading a standard that you and I both apparently endorse.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Wonder Woman actually inspired the creation of Justice Society of America.

https://postimg.cc/K18VJkQ5
https://postimg.cc/5j3WgVbb
https://postimg.cc/B8dVSh3h
https://postimg.cc/1VKCKsqT

From Wonder Woman 750, written by Scott Snyder. Now what, you idiot? You move on to another idiotic question?

If you truly read current DC comics, I can deconstruct your surreptitious bullsh1ttery several ways towards Sunday.

First way is, did you even read The Golden Age #1?

Alright... two observations on this week's Marvel comic releases:

1) Venomverse Reborn #4 just hinted at there being a final King in Crimson that rivals the Eventuality, aka the final Ebony King, aka the final King in Black. That's nuts.

2) Fantastic Four vol.7 #25 just showed that Reed Richards invented a Quantum Flux Accelerator that "produc[ed] . . . a parallel universe [by] . . . manually add[ing] a new space-time frame to the Multiverse."

belch

Originally posted by ODG
If you truly read current DC comics, I can deconstruct your surreptitious bullsh1ttery several ways towards Sunday.

😂

Sure thing buddy.

First way is, did you even read The Golden Age #1?

You mean The new Golden Age 1? Yes. What about it?

Originally posted by ODG
I'm not asking how DC comics have historically portrayed WW2 Wonder Woman's career. I'm asking you how we should conglomerate WW2 Wonder Woman's pre-Crisis career into the singular canon history of current Wonder Woman.

Stop evading. We both know exactly why I am needling you over this. I'll label it aloud: reductio ad absurdum. Do what you can to dispel it.


Because DC said so/DC gives very specific proofs that pre-crisis history is canon?
Maybe because Wonder Woman has some time travel gimmick like Green Arrow did. Maybe it's simply just another comic inconsistency, which happens all the time in comics.

I would say it's not evading, more like I'm not trying to project my headcanon like you're trying to do here.
I mean...you're the one who can't provide explicit proofs that invalidate Death Metal's single combined continuity here. All you're doing is throwing some pretty arbitrary connections and terms, like equal some certain retcons to invalidating all continuity, or when people give you proofs that all history is canon you just say it's easter egg(despite your example can be argued is even more arbitrary than these)