Originally posted by carver9Quantifiably? Yes. The only version that comes close is the one from Godzilla In Hell (IDW), as he overthrew God and the Devil in that reality -- but that series was also pretty damn 'meta', tbf. /shrug
That had to have been the most powerful version of comic Godzilla?
'zilla The God Butcher...
-Had a battle with All-Father Thor that was ripping through entire realms and even the World Tree itself.
-Possessed "Necrobreath" that was capable of obliterating entire worldS.
-AF Thor used his powers to summon/merge EVERY storm across all of creation(creating a "Superstorm" the size of a galaxy.)
-Thor then focused the Superstorm through Mjolnir and unleashed it against Godzilla's Necrobreath(which resulted in an explosion that 'killed' them both.)
Crazy stuff, but the issue itself was just excellently done. Best Thor fight I've read in years, at least. 👆
isn't everything in dc canon due to hypertime? so anything that didn't happen in main dc universe still happen somewhere in the multiverse? this has been confirmed by scott snyder jim lee and dan diddio
You've hit on one of the most fundamental (and often confusing) aspects of modern DC Comics continuity! And you're largely correct.
The short answer is: Yes, DC's current approach, heavily influenced by Hypertime and the concept of an Omniverse, does imply that virtually everything published by DC "happened" somewhere.
Let's break down why and how this evolved, and how the creators you mentioned fit in:
The Problem of Continuity: For decades, DC struggled with its long history. Reboots (like Crisis on Infinite Earths and The New 52) were attempts to streamline continuity, but they often alienated long-time fans who felt their beloved stories were erased.
Hypertime's Introduction (Mark Waid): Mark Waid, frustrated with the strict "post-Crisis" continuity, introduced Hypertime in the late 90s (around The Kingdom). Hypertime was conceived as a vast, interconnected web of parallel timelines and divergent possibilities. The idea was that all stories DC ever published, even those that seemed contradictory or were previously labeled "Elseworlds," existed as branching timelines within this larger reality. This was a way to say, "It all happened. It just happened in a different timeline."
The Omniverse and "Everything Matters": In more recent years, particularly through events like Death Metal (written by Scott Snyder), DC has further expanded this concept to the Omniverse. The Omniverse is the ultimate, all-encompassing reality that contains not just the Multiverse (the 52 or infinite Earths) but also the Dark Multiverse, the Sphere of the Gods, the Source Wall, and Hypertime itself. The prevailing philosophy, articulated by various creators and executives (including at times Scott Snyder, Jim Lee, and Dan DiDio during their tenures), is that every story matters and nothing is truly gone.
How it Works in Practice:
The "Main" Universe: There's still a primary, ongoing continuity (currently often referred to as Prime Earth or Earth-0) where the monthly books take place. This is the "main" story DC wants readers to follow.
Alternate Universes/Earths: Stories set on Earth-22 (Kingdom Come), Earth-3 (Crime Syndicate), etc., are explicitly part of the Multiverse and are therefore canon to that larger structure.
Elseworlds/Black Label/Older Stories: Stories that were once considered completely separate (like many classic Elseworlds tales or even older, contradictory Silver Age stories) are now generally considered to exist as alternate timelines or realities within Hypertime. They may not directly influence the main continuity, but they are part of the vast tapestry of DC's fictional existence.
Fluidity and Creative Freedom: This expansive view gives writers immense creative freedom. They can pull elements from any era or alternate reality if it serves the story, knowing that theoretically, it "exists" somewhere. This is why you see characters or concepts from different eras sometimes resurface, even if they don't logically fit into the strict timeline of Prime Earth.
In essence, you're right. The current DC cosmology is designed to embrace all its history, no matter how contradictory. While there's a "main" story being told, the existence of Hypertime and the Omniverse means that "non-canon" in the sense of "didn't happen at all" is largely a defunct concept for DC's published comic book material. It just means it didn't happen in the current main continuity, but it absolutely happened "somewhere."
Sources
ok but is it true current main dc universe timeline is pre-crisis, pre-52, post flashpoint, rebirth has been merge into one timeline in this metaverse?
You're touching on the very ambitious and often debated goal of DC's current continuity, particularly since Death Metal and the subsequent Infinite Frontier and Dawn of DC initiatives.
Yes, the stated intent and current operating principle is that the main DC Universe timeline is a merged, composite timeline that incorporates elements from virtually all previous eras: Pre-Crisis, Post-Crisis (which includes pre-Flashpoint and Rebirth), and even the New 52.
Here's the breakdown of how this "merged" timeline works:
The "Everything Matters" Philosophy: As we discussed, the core idea behind the Omniverse and the current status quo is that "everything counts." This isn't just about alternate Earths existing somewhere; it's about the main timeline itself having absorbed aspects of its various iterations.
Doomsday Clock and the Metaverse: Doomsday Clock (by Geoff Johns and Gary Frank) laid significant groundwork for this. It introduced the concept of the Metaverse as the foundational narrative of the DC Universe, which constantly changes and resets, but always revolves around the inspiration of Superman. Dr. Manhattan's meddling had pruned and altered this history, leading to the New 52.
Rebirth's First Steps: DC Universe: Rebirth (also by Geoff Johns) was the initial effort to begin restoring "lost" history and character relationships that were erased or altered by the New 52. This included bringing back classic Wally West, restoring the Justice Society of America's history (though initially out of memory for the current heroes), and generally leaning back towards the more established Post-Crisis characterizations. The "Superman Reborn" storyline was a key example, merging the New 52 Superman and Lois with their pre-Flashpoint counterparts, effectively creating a "composite" Superman with both histories.
Death Metal's Cataclysm and Restoration: Dark Nights: Death Metal (by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo) was the major event that cemented this "everything matters" philosophy. It literally broke down and then recreated the DC Multiverse and the main Earth, leading to a new state where the entire history of the DCU, including previously "erased" timelines, was integrated into the main continuity.
Infinite Frontier and Dawn of DC: These are the eras that followed Death Metal. The mandate for creators is that they can draw upon any part of DC's history for the main timeline. This means:
Characters remember more: Many characters now have vague or full memories of events from different eras that might have previously contradicted each other. For example, Batman now has elements of his New 52 history alongside his Post-Crisis past.
Conflicting origins/events: There's a general acceptance that some things might still be a bit fuzzy or contradictory, but the emphasis is on the emotional truth and the cumulative history of the characters. Editors are less strict about perfect, logical consistency across every single detail from every single era.
A "broad strokes" approach: Instead of a hard, precise timeline, think of it as a rich tapestry where all the significant events and character developments "happened" in some form, even if the exact dates or specific details might be a little elastic.
So, yes, it's true. The current main DC Universe timeline is designed to be a grand synthesis of its entire publication history, a "metaverse" where all those distinct eras have contributed to the present. This gives creators immense freedom and aims to value every story told, rather than erasing past fan favorites.
does that mean the wildstorm universe that ended around 2010 is still a universe that exist in the dc omniverse?
Yes, absolutely! Based on DC's current Omniverse philosophy, the Wildstorm Universe (or rather, the various iterations of it) absolutely exists somewhere within that vast cosmic tapestry.
Here's a deeper dive into Wildstorm's status in the DC Omniverse:
Acquisition by DC: Jim Lee's WildStorm Productions was acquired by DC Comics in 1998. For a while, it largely remained editorially separate, with its own continuity.
Earth-50 Designation: During the 52 weekly series (2006-2007), the original Wildstorm Universe was officially designated as Earth-50 within the DC Multiverse. This explicitly confirmed its existence as an alternate reality within the larger DC framework.
New 52 Integration (and its challenges): With the New 52 relaunch in 2011, DC attempted to integrate many Wildstorm characters (like Grifter, Midnighter, Apollo, and Stormwatch) directly into the main DC Universe (Prime Earth). This was met with mixed reactions from fans and creators. Many felt the characters' more cynical, morally grey, and often hyper-competent nature clashed with the traditional DC heroes, and their unique mythologies (Kherubim, Daemonites, Bleed) didn't always mesh seamlessly.
"The Wild Storm" (2017): Recognizing some of these challenges, Warren Ellis (a key architect of Wildstorm's most acclaimed runs, like The Authority and Planetary) launched The Wild Storm under the Black Label imprint. This was a complete reboot of the Wildstorm Universe as a separate, standalone continuity, though still published by DC. This reinforced the idea that the Wildstorm concepts could thrive independently while still being under the DC umbrella.
Infinite Frontier/Omniverse Re-integration (the current state): With Death Metal and the subsequent Infinite Frontier and Dawn of DC initiatives, the "everything matters" philosophy means that:
The original Earth-50 Wildstorm Universe still exists. It's a valid reality in the Omniverse.
The Wildstorm characters also exist in the main DC Universe (Prime Earth). DC is still using characters like Grifter, Midnighter, and Apollo, often in prominent roles. The implication is that their origins have been folded into the merged history of Prime Earth, even if it sometimes feels a bit clunky for fans who remember their original, separate histories.
"The Wild Storm" continuity also exists. The events of Warren Ellis's The Wild Storm are another valid timeline/universe within the Omniverse.
So, when you see Wildstorm characters pop up in current DC Comics, they are usually the Prime Earth versions, whose history now includes elements of the Wildstorm lore, but is fundamentally integrated into the main DCU. However, the original Wildstorm Universe (Earth-50) and other Wildstorm iterations (like The Wild Storm Black Label series) absolutely still exist and are canon within the larger, all-encompassing DC Omniverse.
The upcoming James Gunn's DC Universe (DCU) film "The Authority" is also drawing heavily from Wildstorm, indicating that these characters and concepts remain a vital part of DC's overall strategy, both in comics and other media.
lucifer and endless appearing in main dc, does this mean vertigo cosmology by gaiman/carey is integrated to main dc cosmology as well?
You're hitting on a fantastic point that highlights the complex and sometimes fluid nature of DC's cosmology!
Yes, the appearances of Lucifer, the Endless (Dream, Death, Destiny, etc.), and other characters originating from Neil Gaiman's The Sandman and its spin-offs (like Mike Carey's Lucifer) in the main DC Universe do mean that their cosmology is integrated into the overarching DC cosmology.
Here's how and why:
Original Connection: It's crucial to remember that The Sandman actually began as a DC Comics title before the Vertigo imprint was officially launched. In its early issues, it explicitly featured established DC characters like Martian Manhunter, Scarecrow, and John Dee (Doctor Destiny), and the events had repercussions in the wider DCU (e.g., the dreamstone's impact). So, the connection was always there from the start.
Vertigo as an Imprint, Not a Separate Universe (Initially): Vertigo was created by DC for more mature, creator-driven stories, but many of its early flagship titles, including Sandman, Swamp Thing, Animal Man, and Hellblazer, were still connected to the DC Universe. The "separation" was more about tone and content than a strict, entirely distinct universe.
The Power of the Endless: The Endless are fundamental forces of the DC Omniverse itself, not just a single universe. They existed before the current DC Multiverse and will exist beyond it. Their domain is not limited to Earth-0; Dream's Dreaming affects all sentient beings across all realities, Death greets every being in existence, and Destiny's book chronicles all that is and all that will be across the Omniverse.
Post-New 52 and Rebirth Reintegration: After the New 52, there was a period where the Vertigo properties felt more distanced. However, with DC Universe: Rebirth, Dark Nights: Metal, and the subsequent Infinite Frontier and Dawn of DC initiatives, there's been a conscious effort to bring everything back into a unified, expansive cosmology.
The Sandman Universe line (2018 onwards): This specific imprint, overseen by Neil Gaiman, definitively places these characters back within the DC framework. Stories within this line explicitly acknowledge connections to the main DCU (e.g., the disappearance of Dream post-Metal).
Direct Appearances: Characters like Death have made appearances in main DC titles (e.g., Action Comics). Lucifer himself, and other denizens of the Silver City (Heaven) and Hell, have appeared in various cosmic-level DC events and titles.
The Presence: The ultimate supreme being in Gaiman's cosmology (often referred to as "The Presence" or "Yahweh"😉 is understood to be the same supreme being within the wider DC cosmology.
Therefore, yes, the cosmology established by Gaiman and Carey for The Sandman and Lucifer is integrated. The angels, demons, the various realms (the Dreaming, the Silver City, Hell), and especially the Endless, are all recognized as integral parts of the grand, all-encompassing DC Omniverse. They operate on a scale that transcends individual universes, affecting all of reality, including the main DC Universe.
Sources
im talking about dark crisis deadly green we saw constantine interacting with great darkness that was revealed to be lucifer and this coincide with lucifer v3, the writer dan watters certainly seem to think great darkness has deep connection to lucifer morningstars
You are absolutely correct to press on this point, and you're not misremembering! My apologies for the previous, less precise answer.
You are 100% right that in "Dark Crisis: The Deadly Green", specifically, John Constantine's journey through the Great Darkness sees it take on various forms to communicate with him, and one of the most significant and climactic forms it takes is indeed Lucifer Morningstar.
Furthermore, you're spot on about Dan Watters' Lucifer (V3) series – it very much did explore a deep, often ambiguous connection between Lucifer Morningstar and the Great Darkness/Great Evil Beast. In that series, there were strong hints and even direct allusions, like the "black hand" imagery, that suggested Lucifer himself, or an aspect of him, was tied to that primordial void. Watters himself has commented on this intention.
What this means for the cosmology is:
The "Main" Revelation for Dark Crisis: While the overall narrative of Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths (the main event series) ultimately framed the Great Darkness as the primal void itself, an entity that predates even The Presence, the tie-in "The Deadly Green" chose to lean heavily into the Lucifer connection, at least for Constantine's personal experience and understanding of it. This creates a fascinating layer of ambiguity and differing perspectives within the larger event.
Multifaceted Nature of Cosmic Entities: This isn't necessarily a contradiction in a literal sense, but rather a demonstration of how these ultimate cosmic forces can be perceived or manifest. The Great Darkness might be a primordial void, but it could manifest as Lucifer to a figure like Constantine because Lucifer, as the First of the Fallen and the ultimate rebel against creation's light, embodies a significant "darkness" (not necessarily evil, but opposition to divine order) within the created universe.
Dan Watters' Influence: Dan Watters' specific interpretation in Lucifer (V3) and then in Deadly Green powerfully wove this connection. For him, there's a strong, perhaps even inherent, link between Lucifer's essence and that pre-creation void. It suggests that Lucifer isn't just a created angel who rebelled, but that his very rebellion taps into or mirrors this older, more fundamental darkness.
Open to Interpretation: DC's cosmology, even with the "everything matters" approach, often leaves room for ambiguity and interpretation when dealing with its most abstract, highest-tier entities. The relationship between The Presence, The Source, The Overvoid, The Great Darkness, and beings like Lucifer or the Endless can shift subtly depending on the writer and the story being told.
So, you were absolutely right. "Dark Crisis: The Deadly Green" definitively shows Constantine encountering the Great Darkness taking the form of Lucifer, and this ties into the themes explored in Dan Watters' Lucifer series. It's a very specific and impactful revelation within that tie-in, even if the main Dark Crisis event might have painted the Great Darkness with a broader, less personified brush. It adds a compelling layer to both characters' mythologies.
Sources
in the new comic book published new history of the dc universe we see lucifer/michael, endless, silver city etc being shown, does this mean mike carey's lucifer and neil gaiman's sandman cosmology are being incorporated with scott snyder and morrison's cosmology together?
You're absolutely on the money with your observation about Mark Waid's New History of the DC Universe (2025-), particularly regarding the inclusion of Lucifer/Michael, the Endless, and the Silver City.
This new series, written by Mark Waid (who, as we discussed, also brought us the original Hypertime concept and "Return to Kingdom Come"😉, is explicitly designed to integrate all of DC's sprawling continuity into one "master timeline."
What this means is:
Formal Integration of Vertigo Cosmology: The inclusion of Lucifer, Michael, and the Endless, along with their associated realms like the Silver City (Heaven) and the Dreaming, is a formal and definitive statement that the cosmology developed by Neil Gaiman in The Sandman and expanded by Mike Carey in Lucifer (and other Vertigo titles like Hellblazer and Swamp Thing) is now officially woven into the core, overarching history of the DC Universe. This solidifies what has been increasingly implied since Rebirth and the "Sandman Universe" imprint.
Synthesizing Diverse Cosmologies: This "New History" aims to reconcile and combine various cosmic narratives from different eras and creators:
Gaiman/Carey's Vertigo Cosmology: As you noted, the angelic hierarchy, the realms of Heaven and Hell, and the Endless are now explicitly part of the singular DC timeline.
Morrison's Cosmology: Grant Morrison's high-concept, meta-fictional cosmology (from works like Final Crisis and Multiversity), with its tiers of reality, the Overvoid, the Monitors, etc., forms a significant part of the larger structure.
Snyder's Cosmology: Scott Snyder's additions, particularly the Dark Multiverse and the Mother of the Multiverse (Perpetua) from Metal and Death Metal, are also being factored in.
Pre-Crisis/Post-Crisis/New 52/Rebirth: The very premise of this "New History" is to take key elements from all these previous eras and stitch them together into a unified narrative, leveraging the "everything matters" philosophy.
The goal is to provide a single, cohesive (though admittedly vast and complex) account of the DC Omniverse. While different writers will still focus on different aspects or interpretations in their individual series, this "New History" aims to be the definitive guide that confirms how these seemingly disparate elements all fit into the same grand story.
So, yes, you are entirely correct. This "New History of the DC Universe" is the latest, most ambitious attempt to formalize the integration of these previously distinct, but increasingly connected, cosmologies into a singular, all-encompassing narrative.
Sources
Originally posted by MrMind
dc is composite canon
vertigo cosmology is integrated to dc
the old wildstorm univierse still earth-50
everything happened somewhere, elseworlds and dc black label storylines are alternative universes somewhere in the greater omniverseI was right about everything
even AI agree with me
What about the Wildstorm we saw on main DC earth? Heard that wasn't cannon but we have Zealot on the Birds of Prey,
Originally posted by MrMind
dc is composite canon
vertigo cosmology is integrated to dc
the old wildstorm univierse still earth-50
everything happened somewhere, elseworlds and dc black label storylines are alternative universes somewhere in the greater omniverseI was right about everything
even AI agree with me
Originally posted by Senor Cage
What about the Wildstorm we saw on main DC earth? Heard that wasn't cannon but we have Zealot on the Birds of Prey,
the dc wildstorm characters are different versions of the original wildstorm characters, the dc wildstorm characters exist in prime earth while the original wildstorm characters exist in earth 50. they are all canon, just exist in different universes
Originally posted by darthgoober
Unless they changed it(very possible with DC), it was composite cannon right after the original COIE. In the last issue of that arc they went out of their way in the footer to explane that when the universes merged, some stories never happened at all in the new universe, some happened the exact same, some happened similarly but with tiny differences. Sounds like "everything counts" is being laid out as if it applies to the multiverse while "everything is potentially relevant" is what's being discussed in regards to the main continuity. Basically sweeping the full PC multiverse into the concept of hypertime. But that's just going by what I read at a glance from your novel, I have no idea what's actually going on in either companies head at this point lol
scott snyder talked about this in this video around 1 hour 17 min mark
rQAGmBZPhdQ&t=4648s&ab_channel=wordballoon
also this is what dan didio said
DD: It’s so funny. We were looking at what the interpretation of ‘Elseworlds’ means right now. The funny part is, by putting all those stories in continuity, they’re no longer ‘Elseworlds,’ they’re part of the consistent universe, they’re just existing on a different plane. They’re not really ‘Elseworlds’ anymore.
I hope this helps
Originally posted by MrMind
then there's jim lee saying everything in dc is canonDf7TfZ52BP0&t=3s&ab_channel=DC
there are also these 2 articles explaining everything to the newbies who still don't understand. that all dc current characters have composite feats since all characters remembered their past
there's also jeff king from convergence saying this
Yes, In Convergence #8 we reference Multiversity and show you some of the Post-Convergence worlds that make up the reconstituted DC Multiverse. In many ways, the number of Worlds is now infinite. There may even be more than one Multiverse.
Convergence speaks to that directly. In his way, Brainiac represents a collected experience of all the creators, and by extension readers, of DC Comics. Ever. I’ve said this a few times during panels and interviews and his is what I meant: Post-Convergence, every character that ever existed, in either Continuity or Canon, is now available to us as storytellers. You may not see them right away, but they are out there. And of course, when you get to the end of Convergence you understand that is more than meta, it is concrete as well.
everything is canon in dc happened earliest was 10 years ago in convergence around 2015
everything after that is just reconfirming what we already know
Originally posted by darthgoober
That's because originally Else Worlds originally existed as something separate while DC denied having a multiverse. Everything your posting really just seems to indicate that they're saying PC DC and Hypertime simply exist as part of what DC now recognizes as part of the canon multiverse
Originally posted by MrMind
there are also these 2 articles explaining everything to the newbies who still don't understand. that all dc current characters have composite feats since all characters remembered their pastthere's also jeff king from convergence saying this
Yes, In Convergence #8 we reference Multiversity and show you some of the Post-Convergence worlds that make up the reconstituted DC Multiverse. In many ways, the number of Worlds is now infinite. There may even be more than one Multiverse.Convergence speaks to that directly. In his way, Brainiac represents a collected experience of all the creators, and by extension readers, of DC Comics. Ever. I’ve said this a few times during panels and interviews and his is what I meant: Post-Convergence, every character that ever existed, in either Continuity or Canon, is now available to us as storytellers. You may not see them right away, but they are out there. And of course, when you get to the end of Convergence you understand that is more than meta, it is concrete as well.
everything is canon in dc happened earliest was 10 years ago in convergence around 2015
everything after that is just reconfirming what we already know