Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Started by Galan0071,926 pages

I really wish they'd do a SCW adaption...

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
So basically you're saying you think Superman destroyed the wf's multiverse was due to he destroyed the anvil thus indirectly destroyed the multiverse? You thinking a shockwave that propagating through multiple infinities is hard to believe?It was fine, I've no problem with other people's interpretation.
But we knew the universes that WF created wouldn't self-destruct per Scott Snyder, they need to be consumed by Barbatos
, The multiverse was completed, It has it own hypertime, Also he literally said to Diana that she never experienced truth as pure as this place(WF's multiverse).
https://ibb.co/4SNBmLv
And through the entire arc, We only saw the anvil only was used to replace his multiverse with main multiverse
So I can't see any reason that his multiverse would be destroyed by destroying his anvil [/b]

Yes. Process stopped, his new multiverse ceased to exist.

You are creating this "self destruct" scenario. We dont know what happened to this new multiverse. We don't what happened to the inhabitants from the different realities within.

I think this scene is more about what a multiverse "should be" and not whether it is an actual working universe. When he says "pure", he is explaining that this is a "good" or "just" reality(?). It's meant to drive home that wf's new multiverse is the more ideal reality, which he believes will obtain a more favorable judgement from the cosmic judges. In any case, I'm not disputing wether it was a multiverse or not. It was a working multiverse for all intents and purposes.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998

Besides, Superman just koed a guy who created the main multiverse, Dark Multiverse, Hypertime etcetc cosmic being, I genuinly thinking His shockwave can propagate through multiple infinities is not a hard to believe idea
Or let's use other comics to exemplify.During DOS, Superman and Doomsday punching each other and their shockwaves creating massive explosions, Even shaking the entire planet, But lois,jimmy,even bystanders are fine, And the only visual damage that we've seen is the building's glass was shattered by their shockwaves
All in all, Just like I said before, This multiverse was directly or indirectly destroyed by Superman we don't know, DC hasn't given us any explanation, The only thing that we can be sure about is: Superman koed WF, obliterated his anvil, Destroyed his multiverse. Any other statement that made by other people is fanfiction/Headcanon

He can create multvrses. Also im abit confused regarding multiverse. In essence he can I'm sure, but i was under the impression that perpetua created the "main" multiverse as we know it. And wf populates it with his own universes etc. I know it has gone through a lot of change and upheaval, but I thought it's still essentially perptua's baby.

Anyways, that is hard to believe. Characters that are supposed to be infinitely more powerful than their seemingly much punier opponent have been hurt badly, damaged extensively, and in this case knocked down or knocked out by their comparitvely much punier said opponent. It has happened again and again.
What you have suggested, shockwaves blowing up a multiverse is an incredibel reach based on what was presented on panel. On panel, we don't actually see a multiverse destroyed by shockwaves. What we actually see on panel is the planet they were on getting cratered and the alternate justleague "blinking out of reality", as described.
Then you bring up "head canon", yet that result you're favoring basically can't be reconciled.
Using DoS in terms of collateral damage comparison is a stretch. During DoS, we see windows breaking and art that looks to immitate quakes induced from their battle. For one your basing this comparison from one off hand statetement about shaking the planet to its core, that originated from a bio page many years later(i believe). Certainly a huge departure from the actual comic because nothing since the comic or anything in between hinted at that. It can almost be hyperbolic. But even if it was true since i dont really have a prob with that claim, a simple earthquake can wobble earth rotation. That is vastly different from a a shockwave(that wasnt even shown on panel) supposedly propagate through multiple infinities and to make matters worse, picked and chose who to kill and what to destroy in 1 second. A shockwave that on panel winked out a multiverse? Even if that was your head canon, does that even make any sort of sense?

Originally posted by Galan007
I really wish they'd do a SCW adaption...

Me too, but I don't see it working in one movie.

Maybe DC could separate SCW in two parts, Like they did in Dark Knight Returns

Also, they can't possibly put Prime in there and have it make sense, so it would inherently and inexorably suck. 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
I really wish they'd do a SCW adaption...

Agreed. It's high time for a full featured Starwars Clone Wars movie. 👆

Originally posted by -Pr-
I actually agree with you. As much as I have enjoyed some of the movies in the "series", I wish they had just stuck with making one-off adaptations.

Though if I'm being honest, I found myself enjoying some of the "series" ones more than the one-offs.

Don't wanna see anymore of the mainstream characters from JL or Suicide Squad or any Batman/Superman arcs. They should do one on the New Gods or JSA

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Don't wanna see anymore of the mainstream characters from JL or Suicide Squad or any Batman/Superman arcs. They should do one on the New Gods or JSA

The first Post-Crisis movie is a Superman one called Man of Tomorrow, but I expect them to start giving us more obscure ones now that they're back in that universe.

Originally posted by -Pr-
The first Post-Crisis movie is a Superman one called Man of Tomorrow, but I expect them to start giving us more obscure ones now that they're back in that universe.

I got ya, I'm just not interested in anything Superman or Batman or their ilk. I really hope DC expands

Originally posted by Sin I AM
I got ya, I'm just not interested in anything Superman or Batman or their ilk. I really hope DC expands

I personally want to see more "classic" stuff like post crisis Aquaman and Red Tornado myself.

We need Dial H for Hero.

Show the Ben 10 groupies where it originated.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Me too, but I don't see it working in one movie.
Yeah, it would have to be a two-parter for sure.

The first movie would showcase the buildup and explain the key players involved. The second movie would showcase the war itself.

It could be brilliant IF(key word) done right.

Originally posted by cdtm
We need Dial H for Hero.

Show the Ben 10 groupies where it originated.

👆

Originally posted by Galan007
Yeah, it would have to be a two-parter for sure.

The first movie would showcase the buildup and explain the key players involved. The second movie would showcase the war itself.

It could be brilliant IF(key word) done right.

Now i'm trying to decide when the split would be. the attack on oa maybe? the climax is the end of part 1 and we see the reveal of henshaw, anti-monitor etc.

Originally posted by Galan007
I really wish they'd do a SCW adaption...

I really hoped Reign of the Supermen would spin off into Parallax, into Rebirth into...SCW. So I was pretty disappointed when they announced Apokalips war.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Yes. Process stopped, his new multiverse ceased to exist.

Fanfiction. Cite proof of this.

You are creating this "self destruct" scenario. We dont know what happened to this new multiverse. We don't what happened to the inhabitants from the different realities within.

Yes, we do.

I think this scene is more about what a multiverse "should be" and not whether it is an actual working universe. When he says "pure", he is explaining that this is a "good" or "just" reality(?). It's meant to drive home that wf's new multiverse is the more ideal reality, which he believes will obtain a more favorable judgement from the cosmic judges. In any case, I'm not disputing wether it was a multiverse or not. It was a working multiverse for all intents and purposes.

He can create multvrses. Also im abit confused regarding multiverse. In essence he can I'm sure, but i was under the impression that perpetua created the "main" multiverse as we know it. And wf populates it with his own universes etc. I know it has gone through a lot of change and upheaval, but I thought it's still essentially perptua's baby.

Anyways, that is hard to believe. Characters that are supposed to be infinitely more powerful than their seemingly much punier opponent have been hurt badly, damaged extensively, and in this case knocked down or knocked out by their comparitvely much punier said opponent. It has happened again and again.
What you have suggested, shockwaves blowing up a multiverse is an incredibel reach based on what was presented on panel. On panel, we don't actually see a multiverse destroyed by shockwaves. What we actually see on panel is the planet they were on getting cratered and the alternate justleague "blinking out of reality", as described.
Then you bring up "head canon", yet that result you're favoring basically can't be reconciled.
Using DoS in terms of collateral damage comparison is a stretch. During DoS, we see windows breaking and art that looks to immitate quakes induced from their battle. For one your basing this comparison from one off hand statetement about shaking the planet to its core, that originated from a bio page many years later(i believe). Certainly a huge departure from the actual comic because nothing since the comic or anything in between hinted at that. It can almost be hyperbolic. But even if it was true since i dont really have a prob with that claim, a simple earthquake can wobble earth rotation. That is vastly different from a a shockwave(that wasnt even shown on panel) supposedly propagate through multiple infinities and to make matters worse, picked and chose who to kill and what to destroy in 1 second. A shockwave that on panel winked out a multiverse? Even if that was your head canon, does that even make any sort of sense?

More fanfiction. Cite proof of this "theory".

Originally posted by -Pr-
Now i'm trying to decide when the split would be. the attack on oa maybe? the climax is the end of part 1 and we see the reveal of henshaw, anti-monitor etc.
Yeah, I think they could end a first movie here:
https://i.imgur.com/EBsLB07.jpg

As long as they gave some backstory on the baddies and explained what their motivations are.

Originally posted by Galan007
Yeah, I think they could end a first movie here:
https://i.imgur.com/EBsLB07.jpg

As long as they gave some backstory on the baddies and explained what their motivations are.

👆 Had something similar in mind.

Anyone else always wish He-Man supporting characters would get time in the spotlight?

Say, a Man at Arms movie.

Originally posted by cdtm
Anyone else always wish He-Man supporting characters would get time in the spotlight?

Say, a Man at Arms movie.

This is the first and only thing I've ever agreed with you about. He-Man is a great character.

Originally posted by cdtm
Anyone else always wish He-Man supporting characters would get time in the spotlight?

Say, a Man at Arms movie.

YES

EVERYONE WANTS SOME HARDCORE FISTING PORN WITH FISTO IN IT