Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Started by MrMind1,926 pages

Originally posted by Astner
Sounds like it's influenced to the Marvel Method.

It could definitely work. Most of their problems seem to stem from editorial-favored writers getting to dictate the continuity.

they should've done this 10 years ago, flashpoint should've never happened

Wish they did this with Legion of Superheroes at least. Every single time DC mainstream rebooted, it mucked up Legion continuity.

The entire franchise post crisis should have been a permanent "Imaginary story" that kept its own Pre Crisis history.

Originally posted by -Pr-
For solo books yeah, it's fine.

But what do we do when in an issue of JLA he does something ridiculous and people are like "well i wanna use that feat!".

I mean, good ****ing luck using a character with none of the history or feats.

Unless of course, it's an Earth 1/Earth 2 type deal or something.

Ok, so let's say Superman.....speedblitzes Wally, Barry and WW all at once.

Abhi would...want to use that feat. I would hold firm and say no.

But Carver made the thread. So he would.....specify that it was specifically Superman in Batman/Superman, where Superman got blitzed by Joker.

If Abhi made the thread, he would either make it stipulating it was specifically Superman from that JL issue, or.....just say Superman, so all feats are allowed.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Ok, so let's say Superman.....speedblitzes Wally, Barry and WW all at once.

Abhi would...want to use that feat. I would hold firm and say no.

But Carver made the thread. So he would.....specify that it was specifically Superman in Batman/Superman, where Superman got blitzed by Joker.

If Abhi made the thread, he would either make it stipulating it was specifically Superman from that JL issue, or.....just say Superman, so all feats are allowed.

😂

Eg****ingxactly.

It's like a parody at this point with how DC can't decide on what it wants to be. After a year or two of this experiment we'll be getting another reboot to fix it.

Just a complete turn off for me. Will continue not reading any DC books. For all the issues Marvel has, at least it doesn't constantly mass retcon what's canon and what's not. No small touches to fix things, big reboots only.

Think I'd rather just get an infinite amount of Ultimate Alliance type games than comics continue tbh.

The only issue with having an ambiguous continuity is the fact that people will be justified to dismiss whatever feats they want. But that's more of a battle board problem.

Originally posted by -Pr-
😂

Eg****ingxactly.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Where Mephisto has been whispering sweet nothings into Marvel ever since its creation, and into the future:

As Bran already asked in the CO thread...

... who is the green text guy in the last panel?

Oh, nevermind.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It's in the far future. BEHOLD! Kid Thanos, Manbun Apoc, Green Man, and the Butts of Thor!

Doom the Living Planet that first appeared in Astonishing Wolverine&Spider-Man mini-series.

Originally posted by -Pr-
😂

Eg****ingxactly.

Well, I don't see the issue with it, personally. If Abhi wanted to make a point after every new issue is released, he would create new threads and bump ol-oh yeah, he does that already.

Carver already cherry picks specific low showings when it suits him.

It just means a more level playing field, I guess. Surfer/Thor/Hulk/IM/Cap get access to all of their feats dating back to the 60s or whatever, so would DC. Perhaps we could do it that way.

So alt realities/storylines aren't 'KMC canon', but 1930 to present day comics are.

And if we specifically wanted Silver Age Superman, the OP would specify. But if they don't, then Superman can use super hypnotism or imprison people in his S shield or whatever.

Twink teen Thanos with a gun vs Agamotto, Odin with Mjolnir, Phoenix, Black God, Ghost Rider, and Starbrand. Very good fight.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Well, I don't see the issue with it, personally. If Abhi wanted to make a point after every new issue is released, he would create new threads and bump ol-oh yeah, he does that already.

Carver already cherry picks specific low showings when it suits him.

It just means a more level playing field, I guess. Surfer/Thor/Hulk/IM/Cap get access to all of their feats dating back to the 60s or whatever, so would DC. Perhaps we could do it that way.

So alt realities/storylines aren't 'KMC canon', but 1930 to present day comics are.

And if we specifically wanted Silver Age Superman, the OP would specify. But if they don't, then Superman can use super hypnotism or imprison people in his S shield or whatever.

I'm not going to encourage people to be shittier than they are already, though. Or as shitty as they currently are.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
Twink teen Thanos with a gun vs Agamotto, Odin with Mjolnir, Phoenix, Black God, Ghost Rider, and Starbrand. Very good fight.

At least they had Manbun Apoc fighting what is apparently Tanaraq, so Mungi will be fappy.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
It's like a parody at this point with how DC can't decide on what it wants to be. After a year or two of this experiment we'll be getting another reboot to fix it.

Just a complete turn off for me. Will continue not reading any DC books. For all the issues Marvel has, at least it doesn't constantly mass retcon what's canon and what's not. No small touches to fix things, big reboots only.

Think I'd rather just get an infinite amount of Ultimate Alliance type games than comics continue tbh.

cry more

Originally posted by MrMind
cry more
I don't even read DC, this doesn't effect me in the slightest unlike everything that effects you. It just keeps me away bro.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
I don't even read DC

MrMind collapsed after that part.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
At least they had Manbun Apoc fighting what is apparently Tanaraq, so Mungi will be fappy.

😂

Also, nice to see young Thor wielding Mjolnir... and Nur effortlessly blocking a strike from it 😎

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
MrMind collapsed after that part.

speak out of turn again and I'll collapse your butthole

Originally posted by One Big Mob
I don't even read DC, this doesn't effect me in the slightest unlike everything that effects you. It just keeps me away bro.

Doom Patrol and Hfilblazer >>>>> anything in Marvel.

That's alright.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
😂

Also, nice to see young Thor wielding Mjolnir... and Nur effortlessly blocking a strike from it 😎

I don't like how we didn't have a panel of Apoc crushing his skull in. He's fought Thor like 4 times and looked physically beyond him everytime. Without the axe, I need to see Thor get his shit torn up. Hopefully we get some flashback panels with those fights... and Twink Thanos vs Odin.

https://ibb.co/M8mSYrP