KMC Comic Book Tiers (v2.0)

Started by victreebelvictr30 pages

Originally posted by leonidas
black order is a good one. hmm...

as far as atlas and poseidon--dc or marvel? not many appearances to go off of tbh.

corvus? lh
proxima? lh
maw? ??
black dwarf? lh
supergiant? ?? lh

Both DC. :3

Proxima-MH (I drools over her, also the weight of the star...on the strongest one there is 😖hifty: ) 🤣
Ebony Maw-isn't he even weaker than his movie counterpart?

also victre, check out the battlezone, I'm replacing Alberto for the match, OP already sent to your pm

Originally posted by MrMind
Proxima-MH (I drools over her, also the weight of the star...on the strongest one there is 😖hifty: ) 🤣
Ebony Maw-isn't he even weaker than his movie counterpart?
In the comics, he was more of a manipulator then anything else. 😬

maw definitely has power--his voice allows for control, or maybe it's a form of tp. he's really hard to gauge because i'm not sure exactly how long it takes him to influence someone. he was able to control strange though, so clearly he has a very powerful ability. like i said, not sure how long he needs to work on someone though.

i could see proxima at mh maybe, but she would be the only one i think.

what about purple man? hm? i know he had a couple good showings sort of recently, but i don't think he can be seen as a herald though. /shrug

Originally posted by leonidas
maw definitely has power--his voice allows for control, or maybe it's a form of tp. he's really hard to gauge because i'm not sure exactly how long it takes him to influence someone. he was able to control strange though, so clearly he has a very powerful ability. like i said, not sure how long he needs to work on someone though.

i could see proxima at mh maybe, but she would be the only one i think.

what about purple man? hm? i know he had a couple good showings sort of recently, but i don't think he can be seen as a herald though. /shrug

Purple Man is HM, in my opinion. :3

So here are the current proposed characters:

Black Dwarf
Corvus Glaive
Ebony Maw
Proxima Midnight
Supergiant
Atlas (DC)
Poseidon (DC)
Purple Man

i'd say lh for atlas and trans for poseidon. not sure we have enough to go off of for sure for poseidon, but given that he has been shown to be very near zeus ovgerall, and some of the recent feats of the water gods, i think trans is a pretty safe bet.

i guess to get us to 10 proposals would about some of the newer guys out there:

godspeed?
siphon (marvel)?

What places him near Zeus?

Cool, so the current 10 proposals are as follows:

Black Dwarf
Corvus Glaive
Ebony Maw
Proxima Midnight
Supergiant
Atlas (DC)
Poseidon (DC)
Purple Man
Godspeed
Siphon (marvel)

I'll try and weigh-in on a few of them soon.

Ebony Maw is probably a LH/MH for me. :3

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
What places him near Zeus?

he is zeus's brother, (elder brother) along with pluto. all of them, according to myth--a myth followed by the comics--are near equals, and zeus became ruler of the sky by luck of the draw. his claim of the thunderbolts is generally what makes him more powerful than the other 2.

how close are they really? hard to say. again, not that many appearances or feats to draw on.

Originally posted by leonidas
he is zeus's brother, (elder brother) along with pluto. all of them, according to myth--a myth followed by the comics--are near equals, and zeus became ruler of the sky by luck of the draw. his claim of the thunderbolts is generally what makes him more powerful than the other 2.

how close are they really? hard to say. again, not that many appearances or feats to draw on.

Oh, yes, forgot that this all links to Greek mythology, stupid me. X3

I see why now, but didn’t he lose to First Born WW, or am I nuts?

What has Corvus done that would place him at LH?

His whole unkillable shtick, but I don't remember any other physicals that seemed herald level.

Some opinions:

Black Dwarf- LH
Corvus Glaive- HM
Ebony Maw- LH
Proxima Midnight- MH
Supergiant- LH
Atlas (DC)- MH
Poseidon (DC)- Trans or off the list entirely.
Purple Man- HM
Godspeed- HH
Siphon (marvel)- Defer, as I'm not sure what his 'average' would be.

Originally posted by Galan007
Some opinions:

Black Dwarf- LH
Corvus Glaive- HM
Ebony Maw- LH
Proxima Midnight- MH
Supergiant- LH
Atlas (DC)- MH
Poseidon (DC)- Trans or off the list entirely.
Purple Man- HM
Godspeed- HH
Siphon (marvel)- Defer, as I'm not sure what his 'average' would be.

I say we leave him off the list.

Poseidon=LSk (Sk=Skyfather)

Godspeed is def HH
Poseidon from the recent JLA Drowned Earth or from Injustice? didn't read either, I don't know his feats...
Purple Man HM he is awesome

Godspeed=Trans

Purple Man= HM

missing a lot of voices. bentley, ds, phil, smurph, and haven't seen borg weight in for quite a while. got some others i'd like to propose so hopefully we get some votes in soon. probably my fault--that thread i opened seems to be...distracting people. lol

Originally posted by leonidas
probably my fault--that thread i opened seems to be...distracting people. lol