KMC Comic Book Tiers (v2.0)

Proposal:
In Betweener?

Well above trans....

Mysterio is high street imo.

*Added the following to the List:

Imus Champion- MS
Moses Magnum- MM
Lady Bullseye- MS
Lord Mar-vell- Trans

The new proposals:

Originally posted by leonidas
what about quake (daisy?): hm?
coulson? ms? ls?
leader? mm? hm? (he's always been a disappointment...)
baron mordo? hm? lh?
what about he enigma force or captain universe? too variable?
doctor voodoo? hm? has he reached lh?
mojo? hm?

Mysterio- HS

Leader: MM
Doctor Voodoo: Wanna say HM

with his tech i might put mysterio at lm. he always gives spidey trouble because of prep, but his guns, holograms and ability to mislead even without prep should get him out of street. maybe....?

I could go LM as well. :3

btw nice job on the redesign galan. the tiers thread looks really good. 👆

Originally posted by leonidas
what about quake (daisy?): hm?
coulson? ms? ls?
leader? mm? hm? (he's always been a disappointment...)
baron mordo? hm? lh?
what about he enigma force or captain universe? too variable?
doctor voodoo? hm? has he reached lh?
mojo? hm?

Daisy would be a HM
Coulso - LS
Leader - LM
Mysterio - HS (with CIS on, he always seemed a loser).

Can't speak for the rest.

you need to chime in more too!

Quake (Daisy) for HM 👆

I have a request

What is the opinion of this committee (is there one) about splitting. tier up

Currently, tier 4, Trans (Sub Skyfather) has a pretty big gap between the strongest and weakest T4 member. I would like to split the tier up in to “Low Trans” and “High Trans”. We would be able to add a few overperforming members from the T3/High Herald to the new Low Trans tier.

Originally posted by leonidas
btw nice job on the redesign galan. the tiers thread looks really good. 👆

Originally posted by Smurph
Quake (Daisy) for HM 👆

Originally posted by xJLxKing
We would be able to add a few overperforming members from the T3/High Herald to the new Low Trans tier.

Any HH's who consistently operate outside their 'weight class' as a norm should be placed in the general Trans tier anyway. That's why Superman was bumped up, for example. /shrug

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Daisy would be a HM
Coulso - LS
Leader - LM
Mysterio - HS (with CIS on, he always seemed a loser).

Can't speak for the rest.

I turn back to HS, But is there anything placing him in LM? 😬

Baron Mordo-HM
Doctor Voodoo- HM
honestly both can made a cast to be LH, but then again mages are hard to determine
Jack O'Lantern -HS to LM
Coulson - LS
Leader - LM
Mysterio - HS
Captain Nazi- HM
Lord Satanus- Neron is skyfather level, Lord Satanus is a notch below him so.....def Trans minimum
Asmodel- HH

Originally posted by Galan007
Smurph! You should participate in this thread more. 👆

I know there are limits on characters to discuss and I don't want to open cans of worms that have already been debated ad nauseam, but I wanted to throw a couple questions out there:

- I saw Nate Grey --> HH was discussed. Why not move him? My rationale: I see FP Cable/Nate Grey as a good dividing line between the tiers. IMO, FP/God Cable is firmly at the upper end of MH, and Nate is a solid step above him. A bit like BRB/Thor.

- Black Widow should be HS (currently at MS).

- Bane (w Venom) to LM, at least.

- What about Talon? LM cause of healing factor?

*Added the following characters to the List:

Quake (Daisy Johnson)- HM
Baron Mordo- HM
Doctor Voodoo- HM
Jack O'Lantern- HS
Agent Coulson- LS
Leader- LM
Mysterio- HS
Mojo- HM

Originally posted by Smurph
Yeah, will do - didn't even realize we were taking another crack at the tiers, lol. Brings some life back into this forum.

I know there are limits on characters to discuss and I don't want to open cans of worms that have already been debated ad nauseam, but I wanted to throw a couple questions out there:

- I saw Nate Grey --> HH was discussed. Why not move him? My rationale: I see FP Cable/Nate Grey as a good dividing line between the tiers. IMO, FP/God Cable is firmly at the upper end of MH, and Nate is a solid step above him. A bit like BRB/Thor.

- Black Widow should be HS (currently at MS).

- Bane (w Venom) to LM, at least.

- What about Talon? LM cause of healing factor?

**So with that being said, here are the new set of proposals:

Captain Nazi- HM
Lord Satanus- Trans
Asmodel- HH
Nate Grey- HH
Black Widow- HS
Bane (w Venom)- LM
Talon- LM

👆 for Bane to LM. Especially now that Cap is in it.

And I repeat - DP Odin to HH. For now, at least. Could be lower.

My take:

Agree

Captain Nazi- HM
Lord Satanus- Trans
Asmodel- HH
Bane (w Venom)- LM

Disagree

Nate Grey- HH
Black Widow- HS
Talon- LM

Reasons:

- I don't see Nate/Cable as dividing lines between tiers, since neither of them are in the upper one. The same reason John Stewart/Guy & Baz/Jessica aren't dividing - because they all fit at mid. There's too many inside the tier that are around that area of power [besides the two aforementioned lanterns and Beta Ray]: J'onn, Graviton, Loki [we'll see, won't we? hehe], Blue Marvel, Morg, Captain Atom, Count Nefaria etc.
- Black Widow isn't a tier above the likes of Tim Drake [w/equipment], Punisher, Deadshot, Moonknight and whatnot.
- just having superhuman stats [i.e. strength/healing and whatnot] doesn't make you low meta, as we define the tier. The Talons would get beat by many in the high street

I actually agree with every word Phil posted. He completes me. 😍