Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
How is it trolling?Hulk's always been the strongest there is.
Its trolling using a movie joke as some kind of evidence.
Also depends how you define strength. Strength can equate to power.
What you guys mean is that Hulk is physically the strongest. Hes the teams physical beast, we all know that.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I've been debating Carol on her binary form.I don't think Carol on her normal form would last in space forever.
So then how do you think Carol would sleep in space? Do you think the maintains her binary form even while unconscious? Or do you think she simply doesn't need to sleep?
Originally posted by FrothByte
So then how do you think Carol would sleep in space? Do you think the maintains her binary form even while unconscious? Or do you think she simply doesn't need to sleep?
Stop trying to lure me into an absolutism.
I am claiming that as long as Carol is in her binary form everything should be fine.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Stop trying to lure me into an absolutism.I am claiming that as long as Carol is in her binary form everything should be fine.
I am simply using your same tactics on you. This is how nitpicky you are against Thor, yet when it comes to Carol you seem perfectly fine making assumptions.
So don't you answer the question? Are you saying Carol can survive in space while unconscious like Thor did?
Originally posted by FrothByte
I am simply using your same tactics on you. This is how nitpicky you are against Thor, yet when it comes to Carol you seem perfectly fine making assumptions.So don't you answer the question? Are you saying Carol can survive in space while unconscious like Thor did?
No, I don't think Carol outside her Binary transformation can survive the void.
How does this change anything? Thor isn't Carol, nor are his powers the same.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No, I don't think Carol outside her Binary transformation can survive the void.How does this change anything? Thor isn't Carol, nor are his powers the same.
Just so we're clear (since you keep hedging) you're saying Carol can't survive in space unconscious, right?
Because that means you're now contradicting your earlier claim that Carol can survive in space indefinitely.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I didn't say that, but who knows.
Who knows? Are you saying you're unsure? Because your original statement was this:
"CM is certainly inmune to space."
Now it seems you're not so sure. Which one is it? Are you sure that Carol can maintain binary form even while unconscious in space?
Or are you not so certain now?
Originally posted by FrothByte
Who knows? Are you saying you're unsure? Because your original statement was this:"CM is certainly inmune to space."
Now it seems you're not so sure. Which one is it? Are you sure that Carol can maintain binary form even while unconscious in space?
Or are you not so certain now?
I was making reference to her binary form. I cannot say for sure.
Originally posted by FrothByte
And now I'm asking you if you think she can maintain binary form indefinitely. Because if she can't, then you can't really claim she can stay in space indefinitely right?
I said she could survive in space indefinetly whilst in her binary form. Obviously I am limiting her ability to that form.
Again, how does this make a matter?
We saw a hint of Carol traversing space without an issue, and assumingly hinting at long time exposure to it.
Thor's level of resistance to the void has never been portrayed/hint to that extent.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I said she could survive in space indefinetly whilst in her binary form. Obviously I am limiting her ability to that form.Again, how does this make a matter?
We saw a hint of Carol traversing space without an issue, and assumingly hinting at long time exposure to it.
Thor's level of resistance to the void has never been portrayed/hint to that extent.
It matters because it showcases your double standards. Thor has a feat where he survived in space without issues while unconscious, as in he is apparently capable of surviving in space without putting any effort into it. He is shown engaging in a relaxed conversation while in space and has a feat where he sustained serious physical effort while in space.
CM has no such feat that proves she can be just as nonchalant about floating around in space as Thor did. Yet for all that your conclusion was as follows:
Carol can be in space without problem whilst Thor's resistance to the void is questionable.
Like I said, double standards.
Originally posted by FrothByte
It matters because it showcases your double standards. Thor has a feat where he survived in space without issues while unconscious, as in he is apparently capable of surviving in space without putting any effort into it. He is shown engaging in a relaxed conversation while in space and has a feat where he sustained serious physical effort while in space.CM has no such feat that proves she can be just as nonchalant about floating around in space as Thor did. Yet for all that your conclusion was as follows:
Like I said, double standards.
No double standards, just the fact that Thor was unconcious on space.
Again, his resistance to the void is quostionable.
He being briefly exposed to space doesn't prove anything (Doesn't prove he can be in space for long periods without going unconcious AGAIN )
Again, Carol was hinted at traveling through space without an issue for assumingly long periods of time.
That gives her an advantage over Thor. As simple as that.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No double standards, just the [B]fact that Thor was unconcious on space.Again, his resistance to the void is quostionable.
He being briefly exposed to space doesn't prove anything (Doesn't prove he can be in space for long periods without going unconcious AGAIN )
Again, Carol was hinted at traveling through space without an issue for assumingly long periods of time.
That gives her an advantage over Thor. As simple as that. [/B]
And again, you're assuming that Carol was traveling in space for an extended amount of time despite it not being shown.
In comparison, you refuse to assume that Thor was exposed in space for a prolonged period despite it being heavily implied multiple times.
That's clear proof of your double standards.
If that wasn't enough proof, then the simple fact that you keep saying Thor's exposure in space was "brief" despite his outerspace scenes actually being longer than CM's should be more than enough proof of your double standards.
Originally posted by FrothByte
And again, you're [b]assuming that Carol was traveling in space for an extended amount of time despite it not being shown.In comparison, you refuse to assume that Thor was exposed in space for a prolonged period despite it being heavily implied multiple times.
That's clear proof of your double standards.
If that wasn't enough proof, then the simple fact that you keep saying Thor's exposure in space was "brief" despite his outerspace scenes actually being longer than CM's should be more than enough proof of your double standards. [/B]
No, am just listing what the movie hinted at.
In this case, the movies hint at Captain Marvel having a bigger exposure to space. As simple as that.
Thor was seen briefly on space, and if we are talking about assuming things then we can assume that Thor's unconciousness was product of his long exposure to the void.
In this case, I am being objective by saying that Thor's resistance to the void is questionable (There are feats that question his resistance to space).
It's called objectiveness, something you've always lacked when Thor is concerned.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No, am just listing what the movie hinted at.In this case, the movies hint at Captain Marvel having a bigger exposure to space. As simple as that.
Thor was seen briefly on space, and if we are talking about [B]assuming things
then we can assume that Thor's unconciousness was product of his long exposure to the void.In this case, I am being objective by saying that Thor's resistance to the void is questionable (There are feats that question his resistance to space).
It's called objectiveness, something you've always lacked when Thor is concerned. [/B]
I think this might be the most ridiculous post I've seen. Congratulations.