Originally posted by FrothByte
If she was traveling in the speed of light then she would have been pretty much invisible to our eyes. And even if she was, I don't see how that makes it sure that she's immune to space whereas Thor is not.We see Carol flying through space (but only for a brief period of time). We see Thor walking around, talking and working out in space. I don't see why Carol's feat somehow makes it clear that she's immune whereas Thor is questionable.
Seems like you're applying double standard.
An unbiased person would simply conclude that they can both survive in space, as that is what their feats suggest.
Again, we saw her space jumping alongside a ship said to travel at the speed of light. She is traversing space for assumingly a long period of time, which to her seems fine, so she must be immune to it.
I am not saying Thor is vulnerable to the void, just saying that we don't know to what extent he is invulnerable to it.
No double standards here, just plain facts.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Again, we saw her space jumping alongside a ship said to travel at the speed of light. She is traversing space for assumingly a long period of time, which to her seems fine, so she must be immune to it.I am not saying Thor is vulnerable to the void, just saying that we don't know to what extent he is invulnerable to it.
No double standards here, just plain facts.
Yes and we saw Thor floating around in space unconscious for an extended duration of time without issues. I still don't see what the difference is, since Thor has spent at least an equal amount of time (if not more) exposed unprotected in outer space as what we've seen from CM.
You say we saw her fly away in space... but that doesn't mean she didn't hitch a ride on the ship after a few minutes when she got tired. You're simply assuming that she flew in space all that time. In the same manner, we know that Thor in the beginning of Ragnarok has been traveling the universe but has not been using the bifrost. We don't see any space ships around so we can assume he's simply been flying around on his own. In both cases, we can make assumptions based on their limited time in space.
It seems clear to me what your double standard here is:
You're willing to presume CM can survive indefinitely in space based on the few minutes we've seen her in space yet you're unwilling to do the same for Thor based on the few minutes we've seen him in space.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Yes and we saw Thor floating around in space unconscious for an extended duration of time without issues. I still don't see what the difference is, since Thor has spent at least an equal amount of time (if not more) exposed unprotected in outer space as what we've seen from CM.You say we saw her fly away in space... but that doesn't mean she didn't hitch a ride on the ship after a few minutes when she got tired. You're simply [b]assuming
that she flew in space all that time. In the same manner, we know that Thor in the beginning of Ragnarok has been traveling the universe but has not been using the bifrost. We don't see any space ships around so we can assume he's simply been flying around on his own. In both cases, we can make assumptions based on their limited time in space.It seems clear to me what your double standard here is:
You're willing to presume CM can survive indefinitely in space based on the few minutes we've seen her in space yet you're unwilling to do the same for Thor based on the few minutes we've seen him in space. [/B]
Define "extent", because nowhere in the movie was it stated the amount of time taken for the GOTG to arrive.
I never said this wasn't about assumptions.
But when you assume things you've got to have some sort of assurance that you are right, and in this case, Carol's got more backing than Thor!
You want to assume that Thor travelled through space without any feat hinting at that, that's on you. We saw CM outside a space ship and flying into the void, which does support my point that she is immune to space.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Yes and we saw Thor floating around in space unconscious for an extended duration of time without issues. I still don't see what the difference is, since Thor has spent at least an equal amount of time (if not more) exposed unprotected in outer space as what we've seen from CM.You say we saw her fly away in space... but that doesn't mean she didn't hitch a ride on the ship after a few minutes when she got tired. You're simply [b]assuming
that she flew in space all that time. In the same manner, we know that Thor in the beginning of Ragnarok has been traveling the universe but has not been using the bifrost. We don't see any space ships around so we can assume he's simply been flying around on his own. In both cases, we can make assumptions based on their limited time in space.It seems clear to me what your double standard here is:
You're willing to presume CM can survive indefinitely in space based on the few minutes we've seen her in space yet you're unwilling to do the same for Thor based on the few minutes we've seen him in space. [/B]
His response: my assumptions help my argument, so they count. Your assumptions hurt my argument, so they don't count.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Define "extent", because nowhere in the movie was it stated the amount of time taken for the GOTG to arrive.I never said this wasn't about assumptions.
But when you assume things you've got to have some sort of assurance that you are right, and in this case, [B]Carol's got more backing than Thor!
You want to assume that Thor travelled through space without any feat hinting at that, that's on you. We saw CM outside a space ship and flying into the void, which does support my point that she is immune to space. [/B]
More backing than Thor? Lol. Thor was in space longer than CM without protection. Heck, he was completely unconscious at one point, unable to tap into his powers for support. Do you even know if Carol can survive in space without surrounding herself with photon energy? Do you know if Carol can sleep in outer space without issues?
Originally posted by FrothByte
More backing than Thor? Lol. Thor was in space longer than CM without protection. Heck, he was completely unconscious at one point, unable to tap into his powers for support. Do you even know if Carol can survive in space without surrounding herself with photon energy? Do you know if Carol can sleep in outer space without issues?
Well, he was unconcious wasn't he?
The movie never explains what made Thor unconcious, it was either the explosion of the ship, the void, or a combination of both.
Again, his immunity to space is questionable. At least more than Carol's.
Well, last time I check photon energy doesn't create oxygen. :/
Originally posted by Darth ThorYes you are desperate.
So desperate 😂Grandmaster had to save Hulks green ass.
And that was Thor without Mjolnir or Stormbreaker 💃
That is in a fight not a strength contest. Hulk recovered so not proof hulk would have lost only that GM was taking no chances.
Thor is a better fighter and has other powers which still did not put down the Hulk because he is stronger. You do not show a ragdolling to demonstrate inferior strength. He is stronger than Thor. Stark agrees. Anyone reasonable does. You rarely if ever stay on point. Hulk is stronger. Period.
Originally posted by Darth ThorYou do not respond to my points because you are a biased fool. Personal attacks without replying to the points. I won as you cannot refute my points. I am reasonable you are emotionally out of control.
Lol go back to the Ragnorak Thor vs Hulk thread and see who the desperate ones were. Hint: You and Josh.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Well, he was unconcious wasn't he?The movie never explains what made Thor unconcious, it was either the explosion of the ship, the void, or a combination of both.
Again, his immunity to space is [B]questionable.
At least more than Carol's.Well, last time I check photon energy doesn't create oxygen. :/ [/B]
Don't dodge the question. Are you saying Carol can survive in space indefinitely even without engaging her photon powers?