Shazam vs. Captain Marvel

Started by Darth Thor10 pages
Originally posted by h1a8
I gave a conditional argument.
To prove it wrong you have to argue that he loses if he always uses his speed.

He did use his speed regularly.

He was just messing around a lot being the kid/amateur superhero he was.

Regardless, Carol is too much for this kid right now.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, a debate works by the person providing evidence for their argument. Then the other side attempts to disprove the evidence. as you have provided no evidence there's nothing for the other side to do except laugh at you and correctly label you a troll.
Carol has human level reflexes and reactions. Shazam can Blitz faster than she can react. Therefore the argument is if he uses his speed at all times then she loses. If he doesn't then she wins. What evidence are you referring to in that argument?

Originally posted by carthage
She reacted to Ronan’s ships while blowing them up. That would be in combat

Billy didn’t utilize his combat speed in any similar fashion, he did it in short bursts or flight.

It took her seconds to react. A human can react in 0.2 of a second.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
He did use his speed regularly.

He was just messing around a lot being the kid/amateur superhero he was.

Regardless, Carol is too much for this kid right now.

"always" has a particular meaning

Making even more claims isn't providing evidence.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Making even more claims isn't providing evidence.

I agree. But that has nothing to do with anything here.

Ok, let's BZ whether or not you've provided any evidence in this thread. winner gets to pick the losers new avi and sig.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Ok, let's get this over with. Which Captain Marvel will reign supreme?

Shazam vs. Binary.

Both are at their full powersets. They're not allowed to call for backup. Fight takes place in the abandoned island of Themyscira.

Carol beats the shit out of Shazam... His feats are very very weak

Originally posted by Silent Master
Ok, let's BZ whether or not you've provided any evidence in this thread. winner gets to pick the losers new avi and sig.

What evidence do I need to supply?
That Carol has human level reactions?
That Shazam can blitz faster than a human can react to?
That CM is super strong and durable?

The argument was if Shazam ALWAYS uses his speed then he wins.
If not then he loses. Again what evidence, other than the obvious I mentioned, needs to be presented?

Do you accept the BZ?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Do you accept the BZ?

Now you are trolling.

Challenging someone to a BZ isn't trolling, now. do you accept?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Challenging someone to a BZ isn't trolling, now. do you accept?

In this case it is.

Do you accept the Battle Zone?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Do you accept the Battle Zone?

Stop trolling in the thread!

Again, I'm challenging you to a battle Zone, not trolling.

Do you accept the Battle Zone?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Again, I'm challenging you to a battle Zone, not trolling.

Do you accept the Battle Zone?

You are trolling. Anyone can see that.

Originally posted by h1a8

"always" has a particular meaning

Oh who Always uses Super Speed?

Superman sure doesnt.

Originally posted by h1a8
You are trolling. Anyone can see that.

You could end this whole thing by just answering the question, do you accept the BZ?

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Oh who Always uses Super Speed?

Superman sure doesnt.

It was an "if then" argument.

^ Point is He clearly has speed, but it wont help much against someone who flies around taking out armies of starships.

I bet we can squeeze at least 3 pages of just straight bz's to h1 out of this bad boy.