Thanos vs Thor, Silver Surfer & Hulk

Originally posted by carver9
Your question should be "why not". Hulk gets more powerful by the second, even when your pounding on him. Thanos even admitted fighting Champion is like fighting the Hulk during the time Champion had the power gem and he hid behind his shields the entire time and beat Champion via trickery. Then let's not forget multiple writers stating Hulk power is equal to that of Celestials, Phoenix Force, Galactus himself, etc... yes, a serious Hulk should be able to outright wreck Thanos.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Writers nevr said Hulk was equal to the Phoenix wtf.

Originally posted by Diesldude
the comparison was about a physical confrontation not their power levels. 😂

Okay, just going to end the Thanos vs Hulk thing here.

PG Thor cracked Thanos' shield with one shot. Thanos' regular durability was enough to take multiple shots. So, Thanos' durability is at least relative to his shields. Hulk punches said shield and does... absolutely nothing. Thanos then slaps him away casually. It's as simple as that.

Originally posted by GenghisJuan
Okay, just going to end the Thanos vs Hulk thing here.

PG Thor cracked Thanos' shield with one shot. Thanos' regular durability was enough to take multiple shots. So, Thanos' durability is at least relative to his shields. Hulk punches said shield and does... absolutely nothing. Thanos then slaps him away casually. It's as simple as that.

Not the same shields.

Originally posted by GenghisJuan
Okay, just going to end the Thanos vs Hulk thing here.

PG Thor cracked Thanos' shield with one shot. Thanos' regular durability was enough to take multiple shots. So, Thanos' durability is at least relative to his shields. Hulk punches said shield and does... absolutely nothing. Thanos then slaps him away casually. It's as simple as that.

Thanos slaughters team and uses Hulk's corpse as masturbation cup. Carver cries in his bedroom while watching this.

Hulk and Green Scar are two different things. Thanos beat regular Hulk (savage or professor) but Green scar is a different beast.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
you are a complete idiot in every sense.

He tanked the blasts, each blast was directed at him. The people who died were stood around/nectar to him.

The same ship the blast came from destroyed planets. Then later in the issue the very same ship attacks Thanos. Drax even says “Annihilus is bringing his planet destroying power to battle” -writers intention

All these happened in the infinity finale, you’ve been shown the scans before troll.

Scans or issue numbers of blasts destroying planets and same blasts hitting Thanos.

Originally posted by GenghisJuan

2. Ah yeah because fighting Odin and Tyrant aren't Planetary feats.

2. No they are not planet busting feats especially when those 2 are not operating at planet busting levels.

I'm still waiting on:

-Why Surfer would hold back against Odin
-Why Odin would hold back against Thanos despite using Gungnir
-How Drax vs Thanos caused a chain reaction in the Planet
-Starlin stating Hulk > Thanos

I guess I'll need to add why they were different shields to the waiting list as well.

Originally posted by h1a8
2. No they are not planet busting feats especially when those 2 are not operating at planet busting levels.

Originally posted by GenghisJuan
I'm still waiting on:

-Why Surfer would hold back against Odin
-Why Odin would hold back against Thanos despite using Gungnir
-How Drax vs Thanos caused a chain reaction in the Planet
-Starlin stating Hulk > Thanos

I guess I'll need to add why they were different shields to the waiting list as well.

Neither held back. It was just they were each not operating at planet busting power at the time. Fiction inconsistency.

In one scene Supergirl lifts a half million ton key, but in another scene from another show she is seen struggling with weights that are not even 100 tons. The reason behind that is the same reason all characters operate at different levels at different times.

What? If they're not holding back, then they're operating at their peak. Which is Planet busting. Hell, even if they did have energy to spare, Odin says Thanos has a similar energy reserve, with a reserve meaning accessible things you're not using. So Thanos scales to the rest of the reserve as well.

Originally posted by GenghisJuan
What? If they're not holding back, then they're operating at their peak. Which is Planet busting. Hell, even if they did have energy to spare, Odin says Thanos has a similar energy reserve, with a reserve meaning accessible things you're not using. So Thanos scales to the rest of the reserve as well.

So the fiction inconsistency went over your head.
Ill repeat, characters operate at different levels at different times due to the plot and fiction inconsistency (not because they are holding back). That is why supergirl was straining when trying to exert forces less than 100tons when she before lifted a half million ton key without any strain.

For you to ignore the supergirl example is pure trolling.
I can post many other examples too.

Is this your first time on a battleboard? In comic debates, people find a consistency for a character. When said character appears in the comic, people check the context to see if they're holding back, serious, weaker than usual, etc. Within this comic, Surfer and Odin have no anti-feats to suggest they're not written at their peak, nor do they have reasons to hold back, and, if anything, the opposite. So, with that, we can make the supported claim that these characters are at what has been established as their consistent power level for when they're serious.

Originally posted by h1a8
Hulk and Green Scar are two different things. Thanos beat regular Hulk (savage or professor) but Green scar is a different beast.

Scans or issue numbers of blasts destroying planets and same blasts hitting Thanos.

2. No they are not planet busting feats especially when those 2 are not operating at planet busting levels.

Originally posted by h1a8
Neither held back. It was just they were each not operating at planet busting power at the time. Fiction inconsistency.

In one scene Supergirl lifts a half million ton key, but in another scene from another show she is seen struggling with weights that are not even 100 tons. The reason behind that is the same reason all characters operate at different levels at different times.

Il wait for your bullshit answer.

Originally posted by GenghisJuan
Is this your first time on a battleboard? In comic debates, people find a consistency for a character. When said character appears in the comic, people check the context to see if they're holding back, serious, weaker than usual, etc. Within this comic, Surfer and Odin have no anti-feats to suggest they're not written at their peak, nor do they have reasons to hold back, and, if anything, the opposite. So, with that, we can make the supported claim that these characters are at what has been established as their consistent power level for when they're serious.

So now you are beginning to understand my argument. Why is it so hard for people to understand my arguments?

99% of the time neither is operating at planet busting levels. So on average, they are not.

Again holding back has nothing to do my argument. Stop talking about that. You are going backwards again.
Characters operate at different levels (using all their might) at different times.

Typical non holding back Surfer and Odin do not operate at planet busting levels. If you disagree then argue against that and nothing else.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
it’s graphic novel you complete clown, stop with the troll excuses.

So no issue numbers or scans to support your argument?
But insults?

Flaming and trolling at the same time.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
You do know what Odin staff is used for a why he uses it?

Il wait for your bullshit answer.

With Gungnir, Odin was still operating at less than planet busting power when blasting Thanos.

Originally posted by h1a8
So now you are beginning to understand my argument. Why is it so hard for people to understand my arguments?

99% of the time neither is operating at planet busting levels. So on average, they are not.

Again holding back has nothing to do my argument. Stop talking about that. You are going backwards again.
Characters operate at different levels (using all their might) at different times.

Typical non holding back Surfer and Odin do not operate at planet busting levels. If you disagree then argue against that and nothing else.

Most of the time they're not at Planetary Levels, it's because they're holding back. So no, holding back is an important factor. Typical Surfer and Odin aren't going anywhere close to all out. And I wouldn't call Odin with Gungnir "typical Odin" either. The rest of my post still stands.