Originally posted by Insane Titan
😂 at the anti superman brigade saying he gets flattened. Like most have said if the magic vulnerability comes into play he gets hurt but not much. Without that Superman tanks it like Thanos did.
You think he'd tank it? Not sure why if he's vulnerable to magic? I'm a Superman fan, and won't just jump in trying to use any reason to make him look bad. I'm just going by what has been stated. I can't see him no selling it. On the other hand I could see him tanking a blast from an equally powerful attack that wasn't magical.
Originally posted by Stoicyeah I think he would tank it in the same way Thanos did it as the magic thing isn’t isn’t always played up.
You think he'd tank it? Not sure why if he's vulnerable to magic? I'm a Superman fan, and won't just jump in trying to use any reason to make him look bad. I'm just going by what has been stated. I can't see him no selling it. On the other hand I could see him tanking a blast from an equally powerful attack that wasn't magical.
Originally posted by Damborgson
A)It doesn't take that powerful magic to hurt Superman.
Because while Enchantress is pretty powerful
https://comicvine1.cbsistatic.com/uploads/original/8/80103/4325851-superman%20batman%2003-17.jpg
Nightshade isn't that crazy.And neither is Viking:
So it ranges quite a bit. It's meant to be a weakness. This is explicitly states in every incarnation Superman has ever had.
You even have character who make a point of pointing out that they're different than Superman, like SBP and ignore magic instead of being vulnerable to it.
So Odin, the highest of Skyfathers in Marvel would 100% roast his ass with a direct Gungir blast like that, knock that crap out of here.
I'm willing to list the times Superman has done well against magic vs the times he's been specifically affected by it. /shrug
The topic is can Superman replicate the feat. Therefore examples of him doing poorly against magick are irrelevant. He has plenty of examples to say yes he can replicate it.
I love though how AJA claims he doesn't hate Superman but makes a topic that asks if he can replicate the feat (so does he have similar) but then masturbates to posting low showings of Superman against magick.
Why is it irrelevant? It's very relevant that he is susceptible to magic, in fact, it's a key point as to whether he can or can not take it. It's literally the most relevant point to this entire thread right after the most important questions to answering this.
1. How much energy can Odin produce? 2. How much energy can Superman take while standing completely still and unmoved?
3. Is there any key points about Superman's durability or Odin's energy output that would change the outcome? Yes. Odin uses magic and Superman is not immune to magic (not an actual weakness last I remembered, he just can be harmed same as a regular person)
And there is probably as many or more instances of him being susceptible to magic as not, or at least enough to warrant this.
On his higher levels like OWAW he would tank this.
An average Superman is not gonna tank a high end magic blast from a Classic Odin who shakes galaxies. He is gonna be injured or hurt at least.
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Why is it irrelevant? It's very relevant that he is susceptible to magic, in fact, it's a key point as to whether he can or can not take it. It's literally the most relevant point to this entire thread right after the most important questions to answering this.1. How much energy can Odin produce? 2. How much energy can Superman take while standing completely still and unmoved?
3. Is there any key points about Superman's durability or Odin's energy output that would change the outcome? Yes. Odin uses magic and Superman is not immune to magic (not an actual weakness last I remembered, he just can be harmed same as a regular person)And there is probably as many or more instances of him being susceptible to magic as not, or at least enough to warrant this.
On his higher levels like OWAW he would tank this.
An average Superman is not gonna tank a high end magic blast from a Classic Odin who shakes galaxies. He is gonna be injured or hurt at least.
I didn't bother to read most of it. The topic is asking "can he." You actually need me to explain why it's irrelevant.....after I already explained?
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Why is it irrelevant? It's very relevant that he is susceptible to magic, in fact, it's a key point as to whether he can or can not take it. It's literally the most relevant point to this entire thread right after the most important questions to answering this.1. How much energy can Odin produce? 2. How much energy can Superman take while standing completely still and unmoved?
3. Is there any key points about Superman's durability or Odin's energy output that would change the outcome? Yes. Odin uses magic and Superman is not immune to magic (not an actual weakness last I remembered, he just can be harmed same as a regular person)And there is probably as many or more instances of him being susceptible to magic as not, or at least enough to warrant this.
On his higher levels like OWAW he would tank this.
An average Superman is not gonna tank a high end magic blast from a Classic Odin who shakes galaxies. He is gonna be injured or hurt at least.
Yeah, Dambo posted several, and I added some to support the notion he's extremely susceptible to magic but fanboys will outright ignore that and label you as an SuPeRmAN HaTeR When the own character blatantly calls it a weakness 😂
Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Yeah, Dambo posted several, and I added some to support the notion he's extremely susceptible to magic but fanboys will outright ignore that and label you as an SuPeRmAN HaTeR When the own character blatantly calls it a weakness 😂
So you don't understand English on a junior high level. Gotcha.
Originally posted by Stoic
If he's amped I can see him doing the same, but the OP doesn't mention this. I assumed a base unamplified Superman operating under optimal conditions, which is a base level Kal El.
Base unamped Superman HAS in fact tanked magical blasts (as Abhi showed).
So yes, he CAN. Would he do it for the majority, or 100% of the time? No.
But OP merely asks for the possibility. Can he? And based on his history, yes he can.
