Thor needs to breathe --- he is no Superman

Originally posted by Stoic
I think that this applies to both. Both Superman and Thor have showings of not needing air to survive both in space and in the ocean. I guess that it depends on the writer. One example of this for Thor is his battle against Scrier in space unless my recollection is off?

Bingo bango - it should apply to both. But notice my wording? I was saying that since we have EXPLICIT scans SPECIFICALLY saying Superman didn't need to breathe, we can throw the others out as low showings.

For Thor, IF we say that these are all low showings...then surely, SURELY, Carv is able to Google respect threads and Quora threads to find scans where Thor explicitly does not need to breathe. And I don't mean extended scenes like you say - I meant EXPLICITLY stated he does not need to breathe.

After all, the Flash needs to breathe - but I have scans of him running around in space, fighting, without breathing apparatus.

Originally posted by cdtm
Bios don't mean anything. Lobos bio stated he has "super strength and then some" while Supermans merely says he has super strength. Does anyone think Lobo is stronger than Superman?

This is true but this is said on panel AND in his bio.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Bingo bango - it should apply to both. But notice my wording? I was saying that since we have EXPLICIT scans SPECIFICALLY saying Superman didn't need to breathe, we can throw the others out as low showings.

For Thor, IF we say that these are all low showings...then surely, SURELY, Carv is able to Google respect threads and Quora threads to find scans where Thor explicitly does not need to breathe. And I don't mean extended scenes like you say - I meant EXPLICITLY stated he does not need to breathe.

After all, the Flash needs to breathe - but I have scans of him running around in space, fighting, without breathing apparatus.

Or Kitty Pryde drifting in space, or surviving in walls for hours, despite needing to breath.

Originally posted by cdtm
Bios don't mean anything. Lobos bio stated he has "super strength and then some" while Supermans merely says he has super strength. Does anyone think Lobo is stronger than Superman?

The problem is that Superman has bios AND on-panel statements that number far more in favour of not needing to breathe, than the opposite.

Bios are admissible as supporting evidence, after all.

Originally posted by carver9
This is true but this is said on panel AND in his bio.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Bump

And..........

Thor really isnt Superman
https://i.ibb.co/7jpnss1/RCO022-1469008071.jpg
https://ibb.co/k5ZS5v9
https://ibb.co/gTS6vNv

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
No

https://ibb.co/qybmvNC

Still running, Carver?

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998

Again, are you going to post scans that state thor doesnt require oxygen or just getting raped by the whole forum...like countless times before?

Now we have Superman and his young cousin are both said that they dont have to breathe, and Thor has none, You really made a good effort to prove he really isnt Kryptonians

And reposting this scene, just to remaind Kara doesnt need to breathe either.

https://ibb.co/HdgbM8P

Carver's Thor isnt going to beat a kryptonian

Hilarious when you consider how Carver is the one who always loves to focus on current versions of characters, ignoring their history.

Tbf he just scanned those respect threads 😛

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Hilarious when you consider how Carver is the one who always loves to focus on current versions of characters, ignoring their history.

I posted current showings though, for both. 🤷🏾‍♂️

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Bingo bango - it should apply to both. But notice my wording? I was saying that since we have EXPLICIT scans SPECIFICALLY saying Superman didn't need to breathe, we can throw the others out as low showings.

For Thor, IF we say that these are all low showings...then surely, SURELY, Carv is able to Google respect threads and Quora threads to find scans where Thor explicitly does not need to breathe. And I don't mean extended scenes like you say - I meant EXPLICITLY stated he does not need to breathe.

After all, the Flash needs to breathe - but I have scans of him running around in space, fighting, without breathing apparatus.

Hello!!

Originally posted by -Pr-
The problem is that Superman has bios AND on-panel statements that number far more in favour of not needing to breathe, than the opposite.

Bios are admissible as supporting evidence, after all.

So does Thor.

Originally posted by carver9
So does Thor.

Post the bios, then.

Post the scans saying he doesn't need to breathe.

Originally posted by carver9
So does Thor.

I never denied that. I don't know enough about Thor to judge. I was just calling you out for lying (again) about Superman.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I never denied that. I don't know enough about Thor to judge. I was just calling you out for lying (again) about Superman.

Lmao, how is that lying when my scans said everything I put in my response? I wouldn't say lying, I would just say you disagree and that's fine. We are human, it's ok to disagree with me (even though I provided solid evidence).

Originally posted by carver9
Lmao, how is that lying when my scans said everything I put in my response? I wouldn't say lying, I would just say you disagree and that's fine. We are human, it's ok to disagree with me (even though I provided solid evidence).

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Post the bios, then.

Post the scans saying he doesn't need to breathe.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Still running, Carver?

And reposting this scene, just to remaind Kara doesnt need to breathe either.

https://ibb.co/HdgbM8P

Carver's Thor isnt going to beat a kryptonian

Also, this part made me laugh

Originally posted by carver9
Lmao, how is that lying when my scans said everything I put in my response?

When you ouright got proved wrong+lying+didnt even read the scans you posted just scanned through internet, found random scans that suit you

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Are you incapable of reading the character name that youre debating?
[B]Please post the scans that state Thor doesnt need to breathe, Like Superman and Supergirl did

No, You didnt. I posted the scan to prove Superman can hold his breath with corresponding scans that state he and Supergirl do not need to breath. You just googled "does Superman need to breathe" and chose random scans that suit you without even reading the comics. Again, if you want to prove Thor doesnt require oxygen then post scans that state so. Like I did

Also you seem to ignore the fact that you did post Byrne era Superman scans. Looks like you are wrong again [/B]

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
And you also posted a Byrne era Superman scan again
https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-ac352b280ac5f3c805fecccf023d5b17-lq

Its from Byrne's Exile story arc

Reading the comics ffs

Again
Please post the scans that state Thor doesnt need to breathe, Like Superman and Supergirl did

Originally posted by carver9
Lmao, how is that lying when my scans said everything I put in my response? I wouldn't say lying, I would just say you disagree and that's fine. We are human, it's ok to disagree with me (even though I provided solid evidence).

No. You lied by cherry-picking. As usual. "Disagreement" implies that you had an argument of any considerable weight.

So in summary

1 We have the scan that specifically states that Superman doesnt need to breathe

https://i.ibb.co/7jpnss1/RCO022-1469008071.jpg

2 We have scans that either states Superman doesnt particularly need to breathe and unfazed by drowning

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

https://ibb.co/qybmvNC

3 We also have some extended scenes like Superman non-stop traveling through space for sixty days

https://ibb.co/k5ZS5v9

Supergirl, a kryptonian, also specifically stated she doesnt need to breathe

https://ibb.co/HdgbM8P

4 And aside from all of this, we also have bio that supports Superman doesnt require oxygen

https://ibb.co/gTS6vNv

On panel statements+bios+many extended scenes that suggest Superman doesnt need to breathe

But when I asked what scans does Thor have that specifically state Thor doesnt need to breathe, Carver ran away and still reposted the same shit that already addressed from the beginning and explained again and again in this thread

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
1 Flying in space means shit when plenty of characters who need to breathe did that. Comics nonsense stuff like that

Also forum rules, my child-intelligence friend

Originally posted by DarkSaint85

After all, the Flash needs to breathe - but I have scans of him running around in space, fighting, without breathing apparatus.

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
So in summary

1 We have the scan that specifically states that Superman doesnt need to breathe

https://i.ibb.co/7jpnss1/RCO022-1469008071.jpg

2 We have scans that either states Superman doesnt particularly need to breathe and unfazed by drowning

Or states he can hold his breath indefinitely when under water

https://ibb.co/qybmvNC

3 We also have some extended scenes like Superman non-stop traveling through space for sixty days

https://ibb.co/k5ZS5v9

Supergirl, a kryptonian, also specifically stated she doesnt need to breathe

https://ibb.co/HdgbM8P

4 And aside from all of this, we also have bio that supports Superman doesnt require oxygen

https://ibb.co/gTS6vNv

On panel statements+bios+many extended scenes that suggest Superman doesnt need to breathe

But when I asked what scans does Thor have that specifically state Thor doesnt need to breathe, Carver ran away and still reposted the same shit that already addressed from the beginning and explained again and again in this thread

So wait, you ask me not to post older scans but you do it anyways? You're a funny guy...

https://m.imgur.com/rVZOZdM

Originally posted by carver9
I posted current showings though, for both. 🤷🏾‍♂️

No, you didn't.

At least don't lie.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
No, you didn't.

At least don't lie.

So this isn't recent?

https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-ed22a39fed9ac1b77bfb887c6a00839f-lq

Originally posted by carver9
So wait, you ask me not to post older scans but you do it anyways? You're a funny guy...

https://m.imgur.com/rVZOZdM

Second, forum rules

Third, your scan is from Superman: The Last God of Krypton. A book that is defined as alternative reality in 2013 handbook, a phucking non-canon book.

Finally, scans stating Thor doesnt need to breathe please