5 enter and one leave

Started by carver98 pages

Originally posted by carver9
And this is where you're comprehension fails again. I used old scans because Surfer is more powerful RIGHT NOW than he was back then. I didn't use Pre Crisis Superman scans for current Supes because Current Supes is WEAKER than Pre Crisis Supes. What does this mean? Surfer scans is relevant and Precrisis scans are irrelevant since current Supes can't replicate the fts. Again, 1+1=2.

Where did the mods make a rule on Precrisis fts = current Supes? They have a lot of work on the forum and they need some major modifications to the entire forum and characters if Pre Crisis showings are relevant again. I wish them the best of luck.

Originally posted by Galan007
I am currently of the opinion that everything in DC's published history is now canon and therefore up for grabs -- most material seems to paint that picture.

But yeah, if you don't want the 'composite canon' thing to be used, just specify a particular version of the character in the OP.

Originally posted by carver9

It's not a rule. Post that all you want. It's not in the ruling.

Patience, little carve.

Funny thing is, I even gave you a chance to edit and a chance to specify which version was being used, on page two of this thread:

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Why wouldn't Sentry attack Magician? Surfer? Remember, they all know each other's powers, why wouldn't a reality warper (Sentry) see another reality warper (Magician) as a threat?

I don't care about recently. It's all canon. You don't like it, as OP you can handicap Superman as you want, it's your thread.

But thanks for providing the drive to get a ruling.

Originally posted by carver9

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Still dodging the point I see. Scaling all you want, I dont care. My whole point is you using a showing that surfer performed decades ago while not allowing other using old showings for Superman. And the reason you gave is YOU THINK
But there are
1 A mod thinks we can use it if we want. And another mod thinks precrisis is canon
2 DC canonized all eras of DC, So precrisis Superman and postcrisis Superman are the same character
3 Also DS gave a ruling(Full Capacity), Which you seem to have problem with

Edit: So according to galan, everything in DC's published history is now canon

I grabbed me a glass of wine. I'm patiently popping up a chair waiting for your miracle.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I underlined the important part for you. Flash has that level of speed.

Superman has that level of speed. Level of strength etc.

As for the second post, that rule is indeed in play. Guess you missed it 😂

Doesn't matter since even PreCrisis Superman said 4 1/4 light years would take him a while to achieve even though people like Surfer do things like this in his sleep...

https://m.imgur.com/lCVldLq

Please stop drinking.
Although is Goober online?

How would I know if Goober is online? 😕

I just assumed, because there was no way you'd be able to find that out on your own

Although saying that, theres no way he'd be that silly to argue what you're arguing.

Full Capacity, my friend.

Originally posted by carver9
I grabbed me a glass of wine. I'm patiently popping up a chair waiting for your miracle.

How's the waiting?

It's going good. Checked the rules and still haven't seen that update yet. I like Captain Marvel, so him having access to his precrisis fts means a lot.