Wolverine vs Superman Rogues (& Hulk is somehow involved)

Originally posted by carver9
😂 😂 ... do you use Thor and Surfer at their best? Answer carefully because I can easily pull up a thread.

Well, you are the OP, so am SPECIFICALLY asking you. What you do or don't do in other thread that are not created by you, I am not asking about.

So again, as OP:

Is only Wolverine's best allowed here?

Why are you asking me this question though? Do you ask these type of questions in every thread? Also, you're trying to create a circular argument because if I say yes, you'll mention WWH but I never knew someone getting ktfo is their best showing? Is Superman getting knocked out by Mongul his best showing?

Originally posted by carver9
Why are you asking me this question though? Do you ask these type of questions in every thread? Also, you're trying to create a circular argument because if I say yes, you'll mention WWH but I never knew someone getting ktfo is their best showing? Is Superman getting knocked out by Mongul his best showing?

I'm asking.... because you are the thread creator, lol. And as such, define the stips.

So are only Wolverine's best allowed? Or are all characters allowed their Full Capacity?

Why didn't you ask me here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t676345.html

You didn't ask here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=618415&pagenumber=6#post17451438

Here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t676317.html

Or here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t676332.html

I'm missing A LOT of threads. Start with all of those and then come back and let's discuss this thread.

Carv. Carvy. Carverooni.....Look, I know you're all excited and hyped up because you just discovered the Search function or something, but you are missing the point.

THIS thread, was created by YOU. THIS thread, SPECIFICALLY says:

Originally posted by carver9
Wolverine is at his best

So, my question to YOU, the OP, is, are the OTHER characters also at their best?

I ask you, because this is your thread.

So with that said....

Originally posted by carver9
Why didn't you ask me here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t676345.html

You didn't ask here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=618415&pagenumber=6#post17451438[

I don't care who wins between Thing/Colossus, lmao - I only cared that Sue had a beastly feat

Here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t676317.html

OP doesn't state 'Alucard at his best' or 'Magneto at his best'

Or here...

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t676332.html

I'm missing A LOT of threads. Start with all of those and then come back and let's discuss this thread.

Does OP state 'Mera at her best' and ignore the others? No?

Start with that, lmao.

I don't know why this is so difficult for you to grasp. I am asking you, YOU, because 1. you are the OP and 2. you specifically stated one was at their best.

Everyone minus Wolverine is at their average, everyday, comic showings. Don't understand why that question had to be asked when I specifically only typed Wolverine in my OP.

Originally posted by carver9
Everyone minus Wolverine is at their average, everyday, comic showings. Don't understand why that question had to be asked when I specifically only typed Wolverine in my OP.

Don't know why you had to avoid it 😂

Still wondering though about Metallo - does he have any feats in Rebirth/n52?

Your mind games are troublesome.

Let's use Pre-Neron Metallo since current Metallo is ftless.

Well am just curious why your threads are so stacked against one side...most mysterious.

Why is it stacked? Do you feel Wolverine is Herald level?

I took it as high end Logan vs average showings rogues. But he did say Superman rogues so I assumed it was only when they faced Superman.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
I took it as high end Logan vs average showings rogues. But he did say Superman rogues so I assumed it was only when they faced Superman.

Partially this.

Not too sure about the others guys, but it definitely stops at mongul.

Originally posted by carver9
Partially this.

So high end wolverine and low end rogue feats? Care to explain

Originally posted by carver9
Why is it stacked? Do you feel Wolverine is Herald level?

Does he need to be? When you, the thread starter, are bringing in Kalibak Vs a dog, why does Logan have to be herald level to beat him?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Does he need to be? When you, the thread starter, are bringing in Kalibak Vs a dog, why does Logan have to be herald level to beat him?

Logan's a weird character as we both know. It's actually a bit funny that even though he can be scaled to be within Spiderman's tier, he can physically do more damage to objects (flesh or inanimate) than a herald because of the strength of his skeleton. I talking strictly striking of course.

100% agree - Batman, for example, can be shown in comics to withstand a punch from Mongul, but replace that punch with a stab from Logan, and he'd be dead.

It's just how comics work.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Does he need to be? When you, the thread starter, are bringing in Kalibak Vs a dog, why does Logan have to be herald level to beat him?

I brought up the dog showing for one reason and one reason only. As I've stated on too many occasions in this same thread, these characters have more than one showing. This is the problem, Mr. Saint. You cling to one showing so much that it makes it next to impossible to debate with you. Well, you don't do this for all characters but hey.

Originally posted by carver9
I brought up the dog showing for one reason and one reason only. As I've stated on too many occasions in this same thread, these characters have more than one showing. This is the problem, Mr. Saint. You cling to one showing so much that it makes it next to impossible to debate with you. Well, you don't do this for all characters but hey.

😂

I want to ask why you're laughing at that amazing, great, outstanding post but I feel like I don't need to know why.