Iron Man vs Aquaman

Started by Old Man Whirly!8 pages

Originally posted by -Pr-
I don't disagree.

I just think that coming in here and saying that is like going in to a pub and telling people how great sobriety is. I mean, it's not wrong, it just seems... pointless, to me. Debating which character can beat which (and i use the word debate loosely) doesn't work without creating standards and frameworks.

Though it would be easier if writers weren't so damn lazy a lot of the time.

I only do it when people want to engage in a "serious debate". No poster on this forum, in it's busiest heyday was probably lauded as "da best debater" more than me outside of tourneys which I have never engaged in. Not that I have a problem with people being engaged in Tourneys, as you said you get what you put in and take out of any hobby? Was I the best debater? Hell no! I was just a guy who spent too much time on a forum (I probably still do) arguing about the unquantifiable. I learnt from my point of view no one can convince everyone of anything in comics and view points never or rarely change. Now and again a poster comes a long at a time in their lives where they need to be engaged in "serious debates" about characters who don't know underwear goes on first and you get a board impressed by Phoenix, or the Surfer to a ridiculous level and board bias becomes a thing. Boards have to be busy for that mind, and battle boards are no longer busy.

Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
(I probably still do)

"PROBABLY" 😂

Happy Birthday again, you legend 😍

I hope this doesnt sound impolite, but I genuinely wonder how old is Whirly.....

Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
I only do it when people want to engage in a "serious debate". No poster on this forum, in it's busiest heyday was probably lauded as "da best debater" more than me outside of tourneys which I have never engaged in. Not that I have a problem with people being engaged in Tourneys, as you said you get what you put in and take out of any hobby? Was I the best debater? Hell no! I was just a guy who spent too much time on a forum (I probably still do) arguing about the unquantifiable. I learnt from my point of view no one can convince everyone of anything in comics and view points never or rarely change. Now and again a poster comes a long at a time in their lives where they need to be engaged in "serious debates" about characters who don't know underwear goes on first and you get a board impressed by Phoenix, or the Surfer to a ridiculous level and board bias becomes a thing. Boards have to be busy for that mind, and battle boards are no longer busy.

Okay? Gonna be honest, you've kinda lost me. Could be my fault though.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
"PROBABLY" 😂

Happy Birthday again, you legend 😍

Oh, O.K. Definately Stilt 😍
Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
I hope this doesnt sound impolite, but I genuinely wonder how old is Whirly.....
👆 😂Not impolite at all Qwerty, I am 55. Younger than Lawest Asbestos Flaygon or Mindship but older than Bada, Rob or
Bruce
Originally posted by -Pr-
Okay? Gonna be honest, you've kinda lost me. Could be my fault though.
Always my friend 🙂

Explains the pointless rambling

Did I miss the part of forum history where Whirly was a seriously respected debater?

😛

Originally posted by Juntai
Did I miss the part of forum history where Whirly was a seriously respected debater?

😛

An easy one would be the first 33 pages of the best debaters, now guy and Rao thread old pal.

Culminating in this,

Originally posted by leonidas
<<I agree with that Its not about the best debater its about good debates>>

all hail whirly the great!! well said, my friend . . .

ps-thanks so much to those few of you who mentioned me in your 'whirly-cursed lists'! i'll not name you, for fear of putting you on whirly's naughty list . . .

🙂

There's a load of best debater threads from people too... most closed by Paola, as I suspect you are aware.

Originally posted by EcstaticGrace
Explains the pointless rambling
mmm you love Aquaman? Are you a Sturgeon?

Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
An easy one would be the first 33 pages of the best debaters, now guy and Rao thread old pal.

Culminating in this,

There's a load of best debater threads from people too... most closed by Paola, as I suspect you are aware.

I was teasing.

Originally posted by Juntai
I was teasing.
😮 I thought you were, but we don't interact like 15 years ago sadly, so I couldn't be sure.

Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
mmm you love Aquaman? Are you a Sturgeon?

You caught me

Originally posted by EcstaticGrace
You caught me
😉 👆

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
I hope this doesnt sound impolite, but I genuinely wonder how old is Whirly.....

Check out his official birthday thread:

Happy 75th Birthday Whirly!!!!!!!!!

vin

Well happy belated, 3 quarters of a century that’s amazing &#128579;

you see, this:

Originally posted by -Pr-
Oh, please don't misunderstand me; I was just accusing you of being a flat-out racist.

Though I can see where the Nazi thing came from, sure.

and this:

Well, that would kind of defeat the whole purpose.

is what i've missed.... 😍

Iron Man has the stats and versatility to take a reasonable majority over Arthur here. If Stark fights dumb he may get impaled by that Trident.

Yeah depends on what Stark does. If he fights how he typically fights he loses though.

Tony has nearly every advantage. It's his fight to lose imo

Originally posted by Stoic
Tony has nearly every advantage. It's his fight to lose imo

Not the strength advantage.

Iron Man has matched the Hulk. This is something that Arthur wouldn’t be able to do, and that was while wearing a far older suit.