Superman vs. Gladiator, Hyperion, Sentry and Count Nefaria

Started by Endless Mike39 pages

Even if we assume they would naturally fade away after the moon was shattered, that still leaves the following points:

1. They didn't fade away until after GL searched for and found him floating unconscious. By that time any fragments heading towards the Earth would almost certainly have hit the atmosphere, if they were moving at the same speed as the moon was before it was shattered.

2. Superman had no way of knowing they would fade away. So he would have used enough power to fully stop the moon's momentum, if he wanted to save the Earth.

KE calc for this feat is perfectly legitimate IMO.

Originally posted by Astner
1. Sure, it was a regular exercise but there's still a lot of things we don't know about it, for all we know those five days could've amounted to one rep. But you're missing the point here. There's nothing to imply that Hyperion was at the limit of his strength when he held the two Earths apart, or that Superman's feat is necessarily greater. That's your interpretation, but it's not a necessary interpertation.
Superman did the feat with extreme ease for 5 days to the point that he broke a single drop of sweat due to lack of sunlight, and he was disappointed afterwards of how easy it was. Hyperion was trying to save his whole Universe and only managed to do it briefly, failed, and then the whole Universe was destroyed.

If both you and Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson would lift 100 kg, but you'd have your balls fall off after a few seconds, while he'd be disappointed that it's so easy and he can't get something heavier, it wouldn't make you comparable.

Regarding the mountain statements -- one thing doesn't negate the other, the same way Flash going absurdly fast and then getting tagged by The Trickster doesn't negate his speed feats.

Originally posted by Astner
2. Volume is not indicative of mass, especially not when we're dealing with a setting with nature defying properties. And as far as I recall, we were never given a number of its mass. However, what is indicative of mass is gravity, and the gravitational influence of the mothership had on the Earth and the Moon was not significant enough to imply that we were dealing with anything close to planetary-masses.
Comics aren't scientific papers and various laws of physics are circumvented all the time -- you're literally talking about Hyperion using his palms to separate planets, and you're coming at me to give you exact technical specifications for Brainiac's ship or why the author didn't include gravitational effects? Lol, ASStner. The ship was bigger than the entire Earth-Moon system and the author put an emphasis on it bigger than the planet to show the above planetary-level magnitude multiple times -- but I'm sure the intention is that it's actually very light, and Superman is laughing inside because he deduced it with his super-senses so he's just trolling Martian Manhunter.

Originally posted by Astner
3. It's been some time since I read the story. But Superman wasn't negating any natural force, he was negating Stardestroyers pull on the planet...which similarly is never quantified. Not to mention, wasn't he losing before the Justice League figured out that Stardetroyer was a vampire that fed on hopelessness. Anyway, the point is you can't put a number on this feat.

Of course, this isn't Hyperion's only planet-level feat in Avengers (2013) vol #23 he stops a planet-sized asteroid heading towards Earth.

I see abhi has already addressed this -- be that as it may, they stopped the Earth from plummeting into the sun as it was thrown, and after thatwere only starting to lose ground as Starbreaker was using his power constantly to hurl it, until he was drained. Once he was drained, they moved Earth back into orbit. In essence -- temporarily resisting Earth being thrown in the sun by Starbreaker's [immense] power and then moving the Earth back to its normal place. Hyperion briefly holding and then failing Earth at best comparable with this. The other was addressed by abhi.

Originally posted by Astner
Granted, I can't recall any specific instances of Gladiator moving planets, but he has matched Hyperion in physical in Quasar #54 (if that counts?) And Gladiator did shatter a planet with his bare hands in Marvel Comics Presents #49, which makes the Shadow Moon feat pale in comparison.

Note that the point I'm trying to make isn't that they're stronger than Superman, my point is that they're comparable to him.

ASStner, that's a different Hyperion than the one in this thread.

I'll let you have the Shadow Moon discussion with the rest, since you weirdly brought it up when I didn't even mention it.

You're confidently incorrect in all of your statements, but it is amusing to see you type them nevertheless.

Their absolute best is at best comparable to young post-Crisis Superman [in terms of strength] and nowhere near the weakest Superman [in terms of speed].

Also I want to mention in Superman The Ultimate Guide to the Man of Steel bio also cements Superman's 5 days Earth bench pressing feat

During tests conducted by Dr.Veritas, Superman exercises in a machine that replicates the weight of the Earth(5.972 sextillion metric tons) for five days straight

https://i.ibb.co/1MmvBVc/1.jpg

So, it is more illogical to assume the feat of Superman is questionable due to some information we don't know rather than take the limited information the comic gave literally IMO

I really don't know why Hyperion 'holding' the earths apart still gets routinely brought up as though it is even remotely quantifiable, anyway..? /shrug

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
Also I want to mention in Superman The Ultimate Guide to the Man of Steel bio also cements Superman's 5 days Earth bench pressing feat

[B]During tests conducted by Dr.Veritas, Superman exercises in a machine that replicates the weight of the Earth(5.972 sextillion metric tons) for five days straight

https://i.ibb.co/1MmvBVc/1.jpg

So, it is more illogical to assume the feat of Superman is questionable due to some information we don't know rather than take the limited information the comic gave literally IMO [/B]

I don't see how it has ever been questionable.

The implication in the comic itself is that he was just sitting there repping earth-weight for 5 days straight, without pause. Do we know the exact number of times he repped it? No. Can we logically assume that it was [a lot] more than once? Absolutely.

Why? Because even on the fifth day of being completely removed from any source of sunlight(ie. when Supes was at his weakest), he was STILL able to pull off a rep. So you mean to tell me that 5 days earlier(ie. when Supes was at his strongest), he wasn't able to pull off any reps? Nah, can't follow that logic.

Saying it could be one rep in 5 days legit made me lol, though. Then I read the "chains feat is a dream" and lol'd again.

Originally posted by Endless Mike
Not even feats involving the exact same power, such as super strength?

If you believe that Hulk is stronger than Thor, then it stands to reason that you also believe that if Thor can lift X tons, then the Hulk can also lift X tons, right?

I would use Hulk fts to prove he is stronger than Thor. I don't need Thor fts to prove Hulk is stronger. I can't use Thor fts for Hulk. I can't post a Thor strength ft for the Hulk. Does not work like this.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Careful, Carver is the world's biggest expert on mobile phones, he can violate you by telegram.

This is a true statement. I tend to be in a lot of youtube videos my friend by big channels. This is the latest video...

https://youtu.be/S8c93dIdfdU

Originally posted by abhilegend
That was supplementary evidence.

Yes, he did.

😂

We straight up see the planet shatter below him, what are you smoking?

We also know that the planet had enough gravity to stop Superman from flying off, so it was absolutely bigger than Earth.

😂

You think you can give a feat?

No, they are not?

This man mentioned the planet having gravity when World Forger outside said he put things into play for Superman not to leave the planet and dense gravity wasn't one of them. Then, the size of the planet is small AF. Then, the showing happened in the 6th dimension.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Actually he hit the moon so hard that the fragments faded away from existence.

Let's calculate how much force it needs to make a moon fade out of existence.

🤣

Originally posted by carver9
I would use Hulk fts to prove he is stronger than Thor. I don't need Thor fts to prove Hulk is stronger. I can't use Thor fts for Hulk. I can't post a Thor strength ft for the Hulk. Does not work like this.
Originally posted by carver9
Hulk nearly overpowered an Abstract entity off of brute strength alone. This same entity presence was ripping reality apart. His PRESENCE and it nearly took every piece of energy he had to hold Hulk and Hulk was getting stronger. Planetary is a non ft. Let's also not forget about him having the weight of a freaking sun on top of him. An all consuming sun. Yep, just like Tony said, Hulk is strong enough to juggle suns. This is NOTHING to him.

Not the same thing. Hulk presence obviously can't rip reality apart.

Originally posted by carver9
This man mentioned the planet having gravity when World Forger outside said he put things into play for Superman not to leave the planet and dense gravity wasn't one of them. Then, the size of the planet is small AF. Then, the showing happened in the 6th dimension.

What things did Forger put for Superman to not fly away from the planet carver? Let's see the scan.

Originally posted by abhilegend
What things did Forger put for Superman to not fly away from the planet carver? Let's see the scan.

https://ibb.co/1bHCpGw
https://ibb.co/7JDg00s

Where did abhi say it was dense gravity? I think Carver misread something, lmao.

He thinks abhi is arguing that WF made the garvity superdense on that planet. Abhi never said this.

Originally posted by carver9
https://ibb.co/1bHCpGw
https://ibb.co/7JDg00s

Just thought about it. Superman jumped to a star. There were no stars around (light years away). That takes wayyyyyyy more force to shatter a planet.

Originally posted by h1a8
Just thought about it. Superman jumped to a star. There were no stars around (light years away). That takes wayyyyyyy more force to shatter a planet.

Uuuuummmmm, Batman made those stars appear.

Originally posted by h1a8
Just thought about it. Superman jumped to a star. There were no stars around (light years away). That takes wayyyyyyy more force to shatter a planet.

Actually since that would be FTL, you can't quantify the energy required.

I really like that WF scene...it was very anime-like. Love the art, it also proves just how much more powerful supes is compared to other fictional characters like Goku etc

Originally posted by Sin I AM
I really like that WF scene...it was very anime-like. Love the art, it also proves just how much more powerful supes is compared to other fictional characters like Goku etc

Stop. Just stop.