Originally posted by DarkSaint85
[b]Every other showing of Widow contradicts thisone twothree showings of her being beyond a peak human.That's ok, I'll just redefine what peak human means. [/B]
"if" is a very important word. Learning it's meaning will prevent you from appearing stupid.
Reread my post, focus on the word "if".
Well, y'all were kind enough to provide feats.
I still see something fundamentally wrong with h1's entire premise though.
Black Widow requires feats.
This mythical real life peak human only requires hypothetical speculation that a real human might maybe possibly perform comic feats if we use our imaginations.
Originally posted by StyleTimeI understand your confusion. Allow me to explain:
Well, y'all were kind enough to provide feats.I still see something fundamentally wrong with h1's entire premise though.
Black Widow requires feats.
This mythical real life peak human only requires hypothetical speculation that a real human might maybe possibly perform comic feats if we use our imaginations.
Originally posted by h1a8
If I wrong then please provide proof.[...]
I don't have scans.
In Black Widow's case, multiple feats and citations aren't enough to displace h1's preconceived belief based on, I can only assume, the tiers thread and her Wikipedia entry.
In Wonder Woman's case, h1 doesn't need to provide feats or citations, just his recollection of "writer's intent":
Originally posted by h1a8
Writer's intent is That WW is very comparable to Batman at h2h.
Writer's intent.
Funny how the Venn diagram between "writer's intent" and "my personal impression of the character" is... a circle
Originally posted by StyleTimeWhat's my premise?
Well, y'all were kind enough to provide feats.I still see something fundamentally wrong with h1's entire premise though.
Black Widow requires feats.
This mythical real life peak human only requires hypothetical speculation that a real human might maybe possibly perform comic feats if we use our imaginations.
Originally posted by h1a8
What's my premise?
Originally posted by h1a8
A peak human is the strongest a human can possibly be. It's a theoretical limit.
Originally posted by h1a8
She didn't do anything from my memory that makes me believe no human can ever do.
Originally posted by StyleTime
Black Widow requires feats.This mythical real life peak human only requires hypothetical speculation that a real human might maybe possibly perform comic feats if we use our imaginations.
Originally posted by h1a8
The 2 quotes from me are true statements. Therefore there is nothing wrong with them. The last quote is your own.
Well, no. There is something wrong with your statements -- there is no reason to believe a real life human could hypothetically do these things.
People have been desensitized to peak street feats because they are seen so often, but they are absolutely beyond what a human could hope achieve.
Even the common trope of a street hero disarming/evading/beating a room full of trained, armed gunmen is so wildly beyond human limits that you'd need to cough up some pretty extraordinary evidence to say otherwise. They'd look like blurs in real life, and a human isn't replicating that without external enhancements.
Straight up...even Stephanie Brown and Tim Drake aren't achievable goals for a real person. Not even in theory.