Pfft. It seems to me that everyone just likes Sirius because total attention was brought forth to him because of his death. I am sure if you asked anyone before the book was written, they would say practically anyone was their favorite, but NOT Sirius. And I am sure if JKR killed off Ron, or Harry then you would all be saying that THEY were your favorite characters. The fact is: SIRIUS IS DEAD, but that doesn't mean he won't come back.
Originally posted by RoseBloom
Pfft. It seems to me that everyone just likes Sirius because total attention was brought forth to him because of his death. I am sure if you asked anyone before the book was written, they would say practically anyone was their favorite, but NOT Sirius. And I am sure if JKR killed off Ron, or Harry then you would all be saying that THEY were your favorite characters. The fact is: SIRIUS IS DEAD, but that doesn't mean he won't come back.
Bullshit 😠 Sirius has been my favorite character since book 3. So, SHUT THE **** UP!!!
I don't think that Sirius' influence and spirit will ever leave Harry, but I don't think that we'll see a living Sirius in the books again either. I mean, the books aren't a happy little fairy tale story, they're dark and sad. And even if it is a magical world, have you ever heard of anyone being brought back to life before? As much as I hate it, Sirius isn't coming back.
Originally posted by RoseBloom
Though, you can't exactly say that once you go past the veil you can't come back, then say they can pop out for a chat.
Wow I'm quoted a lot. Firstly, this is for KAI HAIDER. Tisk tisk tisk. I hope you don't kiss your mother with that mouth...or whatever. Its sad when you get so offensive, and I think that people should learn by now that primitive curses will never silence me. Shame on you, shame shame shame. I am sorry that this poor thread must be plagued by you, you silly person.
This is for ARIADNE: Yes yes, how right you are. But just because Sirius is dead doesn't mean he can't come back, or contact Harry somehow.
LUNA: Pfft, another shame on you. I never said the veil was not important. You shouldn't fill up a good portion of your post telling me that I should read yours more carefully when you misquote me. But, as for the other stuff you said...its correct that we shouldn't take Luna so literally, and people are taking what she said about talking to her mom to be some major clue as to what is behind the veil. Sorry, but I got to add another SHAME ON YOU for Kai Haider.
When i said. You dont think the viel isn't importantr thats cuz i couldn't be bothered to say. You think people are makeing the viel out to be more important then it is but if we keep correcting each others mistakes we might be hear a long time. Siruis wasn't really my fav character i never really had one till Luna was introdced we should make a thread about luna 😄. Anywayz i dont think siruis will ever come back or contact harry unless is somthing like that prior incantatem thing but that wont work because..of too many reasons to type out
Blah blah blah. I haven't the time to read something that doesn't have grammar. Anyway, just because Sirius is dead doesn't mean we won't see the last of him. Must I repeat myself...I suppose so. But I do agree with some of your thoughts Luna...the veil is being made out more than it needs to be, some people just come up with these radical ideas, and I, the "defender of the universe" must tell them how wrong they are. Few can handle the job, but I seem to be doing a bang up job at it.
Originally posted by RoseBloom
...Firstly, this is for KAI HAIDER. Tisk tisk tisk. I hope you don't kiss your mother with that mouth...or whatever. Its sad when you get so offensive, and I think that people should learn by now that primitive curses will never silence me. Shame on you, shame shame shame. I am sorry that this poor thread must be plagued by you, you silly person...Sorry, but I got to add another SHAME ON YOU for Kai Haider.
I am sorry I resorted to such "primitive curses", I assumed you were someone of lower intellect. Thus, I figured using such "primitive curses" would more easily allow someone such as yourself, to comprehend the standpoint I am coming from. I must admit, I was incorrect in my analyst of your posts. You must concur that most individuals on fourms such as these, would not fully grasp a more intellectual response. Do you not?
Zeig's ihr, Kai!!!!
Well, I am not sure whether I should belive that Sirius is dead or not. Dumbledore and Lupin stated it very clearly, but long as we don't know which spell Bellatrix used and what the veil is...
But on the other hand it would be very clever of JKR to kill everyone's darling (-->gives the story some tragedy and makes it realistic, everyone's sad and so on...) and let him re-appear in the last chapter of the 7th, shaking back his black hair and saying something like "You really thought I broke out of Azkaban to let someone like Bellatrix kill me?!" -->total happy ending!
Somewhere on page 12 I posted a theory why Sirius should hide again, but as far as we don't get more information about the veil and the spell...
Originally posted by RoseBloom
Blah blah blah. I haven't the time to read something that doesn't have grammar. Anyway, just because Sirius is dead doesn't mean we won't see the last of him. Must I repeat myself...I suppose so. But I do agree with some of your thoughts Luna...the veil is being made out more than it needs to be, some people just come up with these radical ideas, and I, the "defender of the universe" must tell them how wrong they are. Few can handle the job, but I seem to be doing a bang up job at it.
I dont really give a toss about my gramma. As long as people can understand me then thats fine. Also when i said the viel is made out to me more then it is i was repeating you. I think the viel will have some importance in the future also i didn't say." Sirius wont come back "
I said "i dont think siruis will come back" So i think people would like it if you stopped correcting peoples opinions. They cant change that. You would hate if we started saying "your wrong you stupid moron the viel is important jees did you ever go school how the hell did you think up that ridiculas idea". And the whole point of this board if for people to express there view so if you want to be all "thats wrong that right" Then piss off! p.s thank you but i dont need you to correct my gramma.
Again, this if for KAI HAIDER. Pfft, please do not think for one moment that by using "big words" that you sound intelligent because you don't use them correctly. By using analyst instead of analize, I must "conquer" that you took quit a long moment in putting that thread together. Shame on you, you poser. I haven't the time to listen to people who try to act intelligent by merely using words that they are certain make them sound so. This is a Harry Potter thread, so be quiet if you haven't anything to say about it, and stick to your level. Not only are you primitive, but so is your speech. And by the way, typos are okay but you must learn how to spell. Another shame on you. In fact, I dish out all my shame on you's. Shame on you.
For KRISTINA: I agree with you, but on the last paragraph, I don't think Sirius is hiding without anyone's knowledge.
For LUNA: Too bad I dished out all my shame on you's. But if you say "I think Sirius is dead," then you are stating your opinion that you THINK SIRIUS IS DEAD. And as for the other stuff about people calling me a stupid moron and such...Pfft. Its happened. Do you honestly think I am going to let people take away my cynical thoughts? Tisk tisk tisk. Just because you can't back up your thoughts, and I can back up mine doesn't mean you should throw a tantrum.
Opinions dont need to be backed up. I could say i think Luna is going to turn into a purple pumpkin in book6 if i felt like it because its my OPINION. Also i wasn't calling you a Moron I was merely saying you wouldn't like it IF we started saying those things. I am staring to think i might need to be more articulat on this thread if you are ever to understand me as you keep misreading my threads so either i need be more articulat or you could be a phoney and in actual fact be stupid. Also i think your being hypicritical saying this is about harry potter when you spend nearly a whole thread telling kai how bad his grammar is.
I probably wont post on this thread any more. It should be called. "argue with the weirdo who doesn't respect other peoples views"
RoseBloom, I think you'd better go and live up to your motto: "Eat, drink, and die fat!" I think your posts and criticism are way too exaggerated and create a tense athmosphere. Isn't anyone except for you allowed to have their own opinion and share it with people on this thread? I hope you do realize that your statements are merely reflections of your opinion which you evolved upon facts, like the rest of us. I am not sure though whether you are trying to defend your opinion or just arguing with everybody for the fun of it. I suggest you don't take everything so seriously. Nobody is trying to offend you personally by posting their messages.
I hope siruis comes back as a ghost or somthing so harry can still talk to him but i dont think he will 🙁 . I dont think we will see siruis again. Mabey as a memory in a pensive or sumthing like that but i dont think he will be able to talk to harry properly ever again. I liked siruis why did she have to kill him 🙂 silly joanne. O well i hope she never kills Luna 😮
ROFL @ Luna! I could be a "phoney" who is only acting smart? HAHA! How do dumb people act smart, isn't it impossible for them? Anyway, Articulate (its with an 'e' Einstein.) deals with the division of syllables. So do you think you would be willing to go over each and every syllable for me? I think you meant something else there. Don't worry, I'll wait until you use words correctly. And wouldn't that be blazing glory if they changed the same of the forum just for me?
For JRIndy: Ha, I think sthat's funny how you think I take everything so seriously. I might even have to try and be "sirius" once in a while. (Haha, get it?) Anyway, if people are going to post opinions, and I, the Defender of the Universe just so happen to argue with them...why is it that they must go on the defense. Don't say anything if you are going to cry about getting argued with. Good golly people, what do you do out in the real world? call them mean and prance away? I can't help it if I am simply taking what you say and finding the holes in it. Come up with something good, and I'll agree with you. And as I said before, if I do go eat, drink and then die fat at least I'll die right.
For LUNA: I think that just because Sirius is gone doesn't mean we won't hear about/from him ever again. (Not saying that I disagree or no with you, so don't post a flippy okies?) Everyone hopes he comes back, and JK has never been one to disappoint her readers for long. (There, sincerity. You people happy?)
Originally posted by RoseBloom
Pfft. It seems to me that everyone just likes Sirius because total attention was brought forth to him because of his death. I am sure if you asked anyone before the book was written, they would say practically anyone was their favorite, but NOT Sirius. And I am sure if JKR killed off Ron, or Harry then you would all be saying that THEY were your favorite characters. The fact is: SIRIUS IS DEAD, but that doesn't mean he won't come back.
I can understand you and agree totally that everyone just likes Sirius because of his sudden death. Also i just wanted to let you know that i like listening to you expressing your opinion to other people even though others would rather not. i dont think you should stop posting just because you have stomped on some toes or ruffled some feathers. I find it quite amusing.
Well my englsh teacher told me that if your *articulat* then it means you use more advanc words. Bt to hell with it all to his won is what i say. You type how u like (preobably containingthe words: idiotic ridiculas and moronic) and ill use mine. (probably containing to words: f*** and off) Or might use pure english slang. That would be well funny.
Also harry wont see siruis the way he saw his mum and dad come out of voldermorts wand. Because te prior incantatem only worked because harry and voldermort pheonix feather was both from falks. Plus voldermortdidn't kill siruis and maybe bellatrix didnt' iether. So that wouldn't work. Also when harry smashed the mirror he just left it and went home it probably got cleared away so harry will have to think of a new way of contacting him.
I agree that it wouldn't be possible for Harry to see Sirius because of Priori Incantatem again. I reckon the mirror has got a meaning, but at the moment I can't see which. But I doubt that it's possible to talk with the help of the mirror to a dead person. I mean, given this, Sirius must have been able to talk to Harry's dad, mustn't he?! And I also doubt that Sirius's got the mirror with him when he fell through the veil. But Harry will probably find another way of contacting Sirius (as e.g. Luna hinted one in the last chapter.)
And RoseBloom: English's not my mother-tongue, and I'm not very good at English slangs, but even I can perfectly understand Luna150, so leave her alone.