KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Started by -Pr-6 pages
-Pr- Hey Yo!

KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

As a consensus is reached, I'll be closing the voting on certain characters. To that end, once they're underlined, voting is over until this thread is closed.

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald.

For: 2 (abhilegend, Raisen)
Against: 0

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

For: 5 (-Pr-, Badabing, curryman, Damborgson, TheHulk)
Against: 0

Circe to Mid Herald.

For: 3 (abhilegend, Jake, Raisen)
Against: 0

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

For: 8 (Jake, curryman, Badabing, Damborgson, abhilegend, TheHulk, TheGodKiller, dmills)
Against: 1 (Raisen)

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

For: 3 (abhilegend, -Pr-, Raisen)
Against: 0

Ghost Rider to Low Herald.

For: 1 (Sin I Am)
Against: 0

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta.

For: 1 (Oliver North)
Against: 0

Hammerhead to Low Meta.

For: 1 (StiltmanFTW)
Against: 0

Iceman to Mid Herald.

For: 1 (eaebiakuya)
Against: 0

Infinity Man to Trans.

For: 3 (abhilegend, -Pr-, Raisen)
Against: 0

Iron Man to Low Herald

For: 3 (Galan, Jake, Naija)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Nimrod to High Herald.

For: 1 (Sin I Am)
Against: 0

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

For: 2 (eaebiakuya, dmills)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Shaman X-Man to High Herald.

For: 2 (Id, curryman)
Against: 0

Spider-Man to Mid Meta.

For: 6 (Badabing, Raisen, Blair Wind, TheHulk, Oliver North, dmills)
Against: 0

Ultron to High Herald.

For: 2 (Jake, Raisen)
Against: 2 (TheGodKiller, Sin I Am)

WBH to Trans.

For: 9 (Jake, -Pr-, curryman, Damborgson, Naija, abhilegend, TheHulk, TheGodKiller, Raisen)
Against: 1 (eaebiakuya)

WBH to High Herald.

For: 2 (Badabing, dmills)
Against: 1 (Jake)

WWH to High Herald.

For: 7 (Badabing, -Pr-, Jake, Naija, abhilegend, TheHulk, Raisen)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Gonna need someone to nail down where they think Batroc will go if we're going to vote for him.

Anything I missed or tallied incorrectly, let me know please.

JakeTheBank Return of the King

I moved that King Thor be removed from the Trans tier list and instead be replaced by Odin Force Thor.

I also voted for DCnU Aquaman being made low herald.

-Pr- Hey Yo!

😐

Sin I AM Madame Mort

Batroc to high street

TheLordofMurder Senior Member

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald: For

Nimrod to High Herald: For

Ultron to High Herald: Against

WBH to Trans: For

WBH to High Herald: Against

WWH to High Herald: For

Iron Man to Low Herald: Against

Spider Man to Mid Meta: For

TheLordofMurder Senior Member

Oh yeah...

Ice Man to Mid Herald: Against

Rao Kal El DJ FrostByte

Mind if I say that I don't believe in popularity contests? 😛

Wait, where is my vote? Oh I see, I am North Dakota in here.

Badabing Gym rat

Re: KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Originally posted by -Pr-
As a consensus is reached, I'll be closing the voting on certain characters. To that end, once they're underlined, voting is over until this thread is closed.

[b]Adam Warlock to Mid Herald.

For: 2 (abhilegend, Raisen)
Against: 0

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

For: 5 (-Pr-, Badabing, curryman, Damborgson, TheHulk)
Against: 0

Circe to Mid Herald.

For: 3 (abhilegend, Jake, Raisen)
Against: 0

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

For: 8 (Jake, curryman, Badabing, Damborgson, abhilegend, TheHulk, TheGodKiller, dmills)
Against: 1 (Raisen)

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

For: 3 (abhilegend, -Pr-, Raisen)
Against: 0

Ghost Rider to Low Herald.

For: 1 (Sin I Am)
Against: 0

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta.

For: 1 (Oliver North)
Against: 0

Hammerhead to Low Meta.

For: 1 (StiltmanFTW)
Against: 0

Iceman to Mid Herald.

For: 1 (eaebiakuya)
Against: 0

Infinity Man to Trans.

For: 3 (abhilegend, -Pr-, Raisen)
Against: 0

Iron Man to Low Herald

For: 3 (Galan, Jake, Naija)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Nimrod to High Herald.

For: 1 (Sin I Am)
Against: 0

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

For: 2 (eaebiakuya, dmills)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Shaman X-Man to High Herald.

For: 2 (Id, curryman)
Against: 0

Spider-Man to Mid Meta.

For: 6 (Badabing, Raisen, Blair Wind, TheHulk, Oliver North, dmills)
Against: 0

Ultron to High Herald.

For: 2 (Jake, Raisen)
Against: 2 (TheGodKiller, Sin I Am)

WBH to Trans.

For: 9 (Jake, -Pr-, curryman, Damborgson, Naija, abhilegend, TheHulk, TheGodKiller, Raisen)
Against: 1 (eaebiakuya)

WBH to High Herald.

For: 2 (Badabing, dmills)
Against: 1 (Jake)

WWH to High Herald.

For: 7 (Badabing, -Pr-, Jake, Naija, abhilegend, TheHulk, Raisen)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Gonna need someone to nail down where they think Batroc will go if we're going to vote for him.

Anything I missed or tallied incorrectly, let me know please. [/B]

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald 👆

Doctor Strange to High Herald 👆 (If it's Sorcery Supreme)

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - Possibly, if we're taking intelligence into account.

Hammerhead to Low Meta 👆

Iceman to Mid Herald 👇 (I could be persuaded otherwise if someone would like to PM me recent feats.

Iron Man to Low Herald 👆 His power output, versatility and intelligence (if we're considering brains).

Spider-Man to Mid Meta 👆

Ultron to High Herald. I'm leaning 👆 on Ultron. He's mostly been a planetary threat.

WWH to High Herald 👆

WBH to Trans. As a Hulk fan, I wanna give this an 👆. As a mod, I worry what it does to our forum.

eaebiakuya Senior Member

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald: For

Iron Man to Low Herald: For

WBH to High Herald: For

WWH to High Herald: Against

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

Re: KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For.

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For.

Circe to Mid Herald. - For.

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For.

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For.

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.

Infinity Man to Trans. - For.
.
Iron Man to Low Herald - For.

Nimrod to High Herald.

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For.

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.

Ultron to High Herald. - For. Some of his incarnations belong in Trans.

WBH to Trans. - For.

WBH to High Herald. - See above.

WWH to High Herald. - For.

Badabing Gym rat

Re: Re: KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
WBH to Trans. - For.

WBH to High Herald. - See above.

WWH to High Herald. - For.


osheet

shocking

jawdrop

faint

Rao Kal El DJ FrostByte

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald.

Ok

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

Ok

Circe to Mid Herald.

Ok

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

Ok

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

Ok

Ghost Rider to Low Herald.

Ok

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta.

Not sure

Hammerhead to Low Meta.

Ok

Iceman to Mid Herald.

Not sure

Infinity Man to Trans.

Not sure

Iron Man to Low Herald

Undecided

Nimrod to High Herald.

Ok

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

Not sure

Shaman X-Man to High Herald.

Undecided

Spider-Man to Mid Meta.

Ok

Ultron to High Herald.

Ok

WBH to Trans.

Has my vote, IF any herald not holding back who can accomplish a planet killer goes up with him.

WWH to High Herald.

Ok

Not that my voice counts but i still vote like a good kmcr

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

World Breaker isn't Trans because he can break a planet. He's Trans because he can clap his hands and incinerate Superman.

Rao Kal El DJ FrostByte
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
World Breaker isn't Trans because he can break a planet. He's Trans because he can clap his hands and incinerate Superman.

Cool, lets not get that in here. Is just my vote an oppinion. I dasagree that mindless ones are as durable as superman, thor or silver surfer.

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member
Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Cool, lets not get that in here. Is just my vote an oppinion. I dasagree that mindless ones are as durable as superman, thor or silver surfer.

Fine.

I don't either, but Bi-Beast, Wendigo, Fing Fang Foom, Armageddon are on their level often enough. Especially Armageddon.

Omega Vision Face Flowed Into Her Eyes

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
World Breaker isn't Trans because he can break a planet. He's Trans because he can clap his hands and incinerate Superman.

I like that you used Superman and not Thor.

Horrificus Senior Member

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald.

Ok

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

Ok

Circe to Mid Herald.

Ok

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

Ok

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

Ok

Ghost Rider to Low Herald.

No

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta.

OK

Hammerhead to Low Meta.

Ok

Iceman to Mid Herald.

No

Infinity Man to Trans.

Not sure

Iron Man to Low Herald

No

Nimrod to High Herald.

No

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

OK

Shaman X-Man to High Herald.

No

Spider-Man to Mid Meta.

Ok

Ultron to High Herald.

No

WBH to Trans.

No

WBH to High Herald

No

WWH to High Herald.

No

Rao Kal El DJ FrostByte

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Fine.

I don't either, but Bi-Beast, Wendigo, Fing Fang Foom, Armageddon are on their level often enough. Especially Armageddon.

Tbh, I yet have to see impressive durability feats of troians or him.

He is known for his energy manipulation, but not that much for his invulnarabiliy.

Maybe we should pm this.

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For.

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For.

Circe to Mid Herald. - For.

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For.

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For.

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.

Infinity Man to Trans. - For.
.
Iron Man to Low Herald - For.

Nimrod to High Herald.

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For.

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.

Ultron to High Herald. - For. Some of his incarnations belong in Trans.

WBH to Trans. - For.

WBH to High Herald. - See above.

WWH to High Herald. - For.


Agree to all.

pym-ftw Mizukage

For everything in Op except Ghost Rider only being Low Herald & WBH for HH

Depends on the Ultron

SW Ultron, Phalanx Ultron, & Adam Warlock Ultron are solid Trans lvl