501st vs. Hogwarts

Originally posted by KingD19
I was using a missile platform as an example, and yes, an AT-AT is a vehicle, but it is a strictly ground vehicle, unless it is specifically stated that the 501st is restricted to Infantry(foot soldiers), all ground based forces and vehicles are able to be used.

Again, Lum has made it clear that it's the ground troops only, no vehicles. Just the clones advancing on foot.

No AT AT's, no ships, no AT ST's.

Why are you ignoring this?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Again, for the umpteenth time, this aint your thread, you cant change the conditions.

This coming from YOU.........?

😆

😆

😆

🤣

😮‍💨

😆

I aint trying to change SHIT, Mr. "I'll try to alter Physics to suit my argument that Magic is Energy/Energy isn't magic/Magic gimps energy, despite being it/not being it".

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Again, Lum has made it clear that it's the ground troops only, no vehicles. Just the clones advancing on foot.

No AT AT's, no ships, no AT ST's.

Why are you ignoring this?

Because its a ground vehicle.
And therefore is a part of the ground forces.

Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Gimpey.

Wh-hyyyyyyyyyy are you not getting that, gimpy..?

Hey! Gimpy! Dry your tears, champ, its time to get back in the box until Zed needs ya.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Because its a ground vehicle.
And therefore is a part of the ground forces.

Duhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Gimpey.

Wh-hyyyyyyyyyy are you not getting that, gimpy..?

Hey! Gimpy! Dry your tears, champ, its time to get back in the box until Zed needs ya.

And if Lum steps in here and allows AT AT's, trust me, I am fully prepared for it. If vehicles are allowed, Dumbledore or Voldemort solos. I'll explain why IF Lum allows vehicles.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
This coming from YOU.........?

😆

😆

😆

🤣

😮‍💨

😆

I aint trying to change SHIT, Mr. "I'll try to alter Physics to suit my argument that Magic is Energy/Energy isn't magic/Magic gimps energy, despite being it/not being it".

And if you notice, I dropped the energy argument long ago. Stop using it as a crutch.

Dont you talk to me about crutches, Gimp boy.

Im not. Groundforces are ground forces.

I repeat: Explain Magic and energy's relationship here, and why Hogwarts have the advantage in any way, because of it....

Oh. Cant...?

Just was a gimpline as usual...? Oh right.

Then GTFOaSTFU. 😄
Our non-suppositions about the effectiveness for the clones have all been examplified by things we've seen on screen.

YOU are so crutch wielding a person, that you have attempted to misrepresent what science is in order to fit you own gimp agenda.

*shouts above the gargling*

Hey! RJ! When Snape is done, "Dumbles" needs emptying.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Dont you talk to me about crutches, Gimp boy.

Im not. Groundforces are ground forces.

I repeat: Explain Magic and energy's relationship here, and why Hogwarts have the advantage in any way, because of it....

Oh. Cant...?

Just was a gimpline as usual...? Oh right.

Then GTFOaSTFU. 😄

So, you gonna counter the portkey scenario, using clone troops only, no vehicles or ships whatsoever?

Yeah I thought not. There is no counter. Itso facto.

But by all means, keep spamming and trolling.

I tried but to use logic, but alas you kept gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping and gimping until you had deprived the clones of having got there in the 1st place, since you deliberately overlooked how the Clones would be there in the 1st place:

IE Dropped in to the battlefield by the airforces, ergo: Ground based forces dont get their gear gimped by you, you heinous, remorseless gimpoid.

Your desperate multitude of fails are making you now the personification of HP fanboyism at its very worst.

So the troops are dropped with their gear, and the vehicles may not be used in the fight.

Not that hard to grasp.

For a man from bizarro world.
Besides, being easy to grasp doenst automatically make a concept true.

I could say "Im Jesus" or "Im from Mars" both simple concepts...
Doesnt neccessarily make it true though, does it...?

Threadstarter said nothing of the vehicles that are a part of the Ground forces of the 501st.

If he DID it'd be gimpage.

(Although the Republic/Empire forces are already heavily gimped out by lack of their airbourne support against Wizards.)

I'm gonna entertain you on this.

How many walkers, missile platforms, in your opinion, would the 500 members of the 501st have?

You have little choice.

I'll be back with figures shortly.

But if its more than even three of those small AT AT type vehicles, its over for Hogwarts.

Bring it on, and prepared to be buried.

I wont need to, thanks. 🙂

24 Walkers per 1 Venator class star destroyer.
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Venator_Star_Destroyer

A thousand troops in the 501st. So thats safe to assume that the full 24 would be in use.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
I wont need to, thanks. 🙂

24 Walkers per 1 Venator class star destroyer.
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Venator_Star_Destroyer

A thousand troops in the 501st. So thats safe to assume that the full 24 would be in use.

Now if the crew compliment of a Venator class vessel is like 500, then its 2 destroyers and 50 of them.

Im looking in to this as we speak.

Only 500 clones in this battle, do the math with 500 clones, not 1000 clones.

And yes, you will need to.

Signing off now, I'll respond when I get home in a coupla hours.

I love you heartbeat

Oh thats 500 troops in 24 walkers, then. Awesome. 🙂

Thats a little too much info, but sleep tight, Judith.
You'll no doubt be dreaming of Hogwarts. 😛

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
😂 Reaching again I see. No vehicles or ships may be used in the attack on hogwarts. This is Lum's thread, talk to him about it.

Reaching...?

Your the one interpretting the air as terrain.

I think the cat would agree that in order for the troops to be there in the 1st place, that the vehicular assistance will already have taken place. 🙂

'Cause he would think, unlike you, logically, presumably. 🙂

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Hey, I went by the thread rules and buried the ****ing clones, along with every argument in their favor. If Lum wants to change the conditions, up to him.

It might be, but I unlike you, give the man some credit for thinking as a reasonable person would.

IE: Troops HAVE to have Vehicular help already in getting there, and that their ground forces employ those walkers.

So I agree. Lets see what he says....but out of science and logic, I'll be accepting that they be there, for now.. We can see if they are gimped away, later.

this thread makes my head hurt. >>.

if there are 1000 troopers per 24 walkers, then for 500 troopers we have 12 walkers, then.

hm. according to hp wiki there is no limit to magic- it depends on the user. I don't really know much about portkeys, so I can't say if they can do what RJ says.

well, if wizards are taken by surprise, 501st would have a chance if they move quickly.

but if they had the chance to prepare for the attack, well, I think it is possible that the clones would get screwed. 😬

but then, I'm no HP fangirl to say how their spells work and stuff, so...

I'm at a complete loss here now.

No-one/just one has actually shown to be able to use the portkey spell. Going by forum rules of 'only feats shown in the movies apply' no-one/just one can use the portkey spell. And they can't turn the ground into a portkey, unless RJ wants to argue that they can turn the entire ****ing earth into a portkey.

Jesus Christ I can't believe I was the only one who remembered this.

The only other argument for Hogwats I saw was the invisibility-cloak Harry and Bellatrix flying around pwning. This wouldn't work, Vader would know where they were and pimp them.