Originally posted by Dizzle
"Top of their game" suggest using PIS? Consistant feats are sometimes PIS, inconsistant feats are sometimes perfectly good examples of one character's powers. Most of the time, Silver Surfer and Flash forget they can react at beyond lightspeed. Champion forgets he has been training for millenia, etc etc etc. [/B]
🤨 I don't follow this logic... at all...
Originally posted by Dizzle
Doc Ock has computers controlling each of his arms independantly. I'd say that's outweigh good smelling. That's 4 of them, conveniently enough... And that was Xavier exercising hyperbole anyway,[/B]
that's another brash assessment and specualtion.. you don't know it's hyperbole.. who else has ever read logan's mind when in berserker rage?
Originally posted by Dizzle
not Logan actually beating 4 chess computers. His AI are plenty intelligent when it comes to fighting, so yes, his skill is matched fairly well. The arms themselves do. Ock's frail human form, unfortunately, does not. I never said it was as simple as "Spdierman beats Ock, Spiderman beats Wolverine". I said Ock is faster than Wolverine, Spiderman dodges Ock. Therefore, Spiderman dodges Wolverine. .[/B]
again.. not entirely accurate or supported by feats..
and again.. it's not that black and white...
Originally posted by Dizzle
Once again, consistancy does not equal accurate. Wolverine should not be able to take a nuke, but he can reform from having all of his organs but his skin and skeleton liquefied? In less than a second? It's physically impossible for a healing factor that is essentially human, but faster. Consistant feat, but still PIS used to make the fights interesting.[/B]
those aren't the consistent feats to go by.. so why use them to make a point? 🤨
Originally posted by Dizzle
Good point, actually... I never did say that Spiderman can beat Wolverine solely because he can beat Ock, however. I brought him in solely as an example of something that would be very very hard to dodge that Spiderman DOES dodge. It wasn't necessarily in beating him, but in the fact taht he CAN dodge the tentacles. However, that also brings in the "are they always working to potential?" question... I didn't think, my apologies. .[/B]
I never claimed that , that was your argument.. I understood what you were saying I just brought into question you standard.. if we are to assume that a villain jobs to one hero.. be it a single punch that the hero dodges or the entire fight.. what's to assume he didn't do so for another? you have to have some sort of base to built your assessment for each characters "power level" right?
again.. you just claimed that spiderman CAN dodge the tenticals.. but how do we know that this incident isn't PIS for dock ock? thus his dodging tenticals can't even be used as evidence going by your standard ❌.... but if he CAN dodge them... then wolverine CAN hit spiderman as he's shown he could do..
the main question is.. how did you come to the conclussion that spiderman can dodge them in the first place? how do you know spiderman can do it?
Originally posted by Dizzle
"Everything I've got" only applied to how hard he was hitting. It had NOTHING to do with how intelligently Spiderman was fighting. Beast is fighting Bishop. Beast knows Bishop absorbs kinetic energy. He runs up to Bishop and punches Bishop as hard as he can. Bishop liquefies him. He's using "everything he's got" in the one blow, yet he's clearly not fighting in an intelligent manner.[/B]
I've given him "everything" I've got.. could that not be interpretted to include intelligence as well?
Originally posted by Dizzle
You're not arguing that in SvFL, yet you ARE arguing it for WOlverine vs. Spidey. Your following "consistancy" is basically saying "It's happened fora good percentage of the time, therefore it WILL happen that way". Wolverine has hit Spiderman in a good percentage of their fights. Spiderman has beaten Firelord in 100% of their fights. Both are therefore "consistant" right? Despite the fact that PIS and additional circumstances are involved heavily in both?.[/B]
not that it WILL happen but that it is most likely to happen again until proven otherwise...
the difference between the firelors example and the wolverine one is that spiderman had a number of plot devices used as weapons working in his favor to overcome firelord.. when wolverine overcomes spiderman he does it by himself...
that alone changes things greatly..
Originally posted by Dizzle
Crossovers are disregarded because they are typically filled with PIS. Many of the fights that you use as support are filled with PIS. Nonfanvoted crossovers are disregarded because they involve a lot of PIS, not because they are out of continuity.[/B]
company crossovers are not used because they are not canon...
if they were canon they COULD be used.. because they are not canon. it's hard to say.. you claims for their use are based off specualtion.. they do indeed have quite a bit of PIS IMHO.... I agree.. but would you not also agree that cross-comapany crossovers are different from intercompany ones?
Originally posted by Dizzle
Has he outsped anyone with both Spiderman's level of reactions AND superstrength? Logically, every hit he takes will knock Logan a little ways. So while he can stand there and anticipate Speed Demon's attack, he can't even stand there against Spiderman.[/B]
first off: he wasn't "standing there" for speed demon he was in constant motion trying to strike until he landed a blow.. something spiderman couldn't do....
and second:
falsy dychotomy.. you're assuming he HAS to outspeed spiderman to hit him.. he doesn't he can wear him down.. or draw him in..
Originally posted by Dizzle
Fighting to his fullest mentally, not physically.[/B]
everything would seem to imply... everything.. unless his brain conviniently shuts down like his spider sense does.. (any time he's losing.. lol)
Originally posted by Dizzle
PIS in Spiderman's favor? 🤨 How? Wolverine rips through webs, when they were holding him to the wall in a spot that he could not possibly have reached. Spiderman's spider sense either does not go off or he does not react to it. Spiderman fights like an idiot. Yup, everything's in his favor all right.[/B]
lol I wrote that funky.. my bad.. I meant to say I'd have to agree to an abundance of pis... therefore my agreeing to such would be in spiderman's favor because doing so would discard the feats... I don't agree that there was tons of PIS... everything can and has been explained through the grand mess of consistency...
wolverine was against a wall.. by strands.. we don't even see the webbing connecting his arms to the wall... that's always just been assumed.. but again it was organic webbing.. takes time to set.. more time than wolverine allowed for...
another fals dycotomy on the spidersense thing.. it assumes there's no possible way with wolverine's attributes that one can hit spiderman.. that's not true yet again thanks to consistency...
ans spiderman fighting like an idiot when wolverine either lets spiderman hit him or forgets to wave his arm out infront of him?..hmmmm
Originally posted by Dizzle
Wolverine's wrists were webbed, Spiderman had to break him out. .[/B]
wasn't a fight.. isn't valid...
Originally posted by Dizzle
Wolverine was webbed between two buildings, Wolverine had to wait for them to dissolve..[/B]
I have that issue.. he gets our before they dissolve.. 😕
that was the whole point of hurting himself....
Originally posted by Dizzle
Wolverine actually initiated the fight, Spiderman jumped over him before webbing him. With that much warning, Wolverine must be one slow little kid when he can shred it easily when ready for it. Oh wait... Has he ever blocked stuff like machine gun fire? This stuff engulfed Hulk within a second or so, it's easily as fast as bullets.[/B]
he was in mid conversation.. not much of a fight.. 🙄
there you go again.. using a feat as a standard of evidence and discarding your own standard.. completely engulfing the hulk in a second with webbing is physically impossible... you can't consistenly argue against feats if you're using them to support a point... 🤨
tell me that too was on purpose..
Originally posted by Dizzle
Are they anywhere near as fast as Spiderman? Flexible? Agile?Anything resembling precognition? Nope. They're about as strong, nothing more. And they stab through Wolverine's gut. They don't tear it out...[/B]
actually cyber's as fast.. sabretooth's faster. flexability and agility are neccessities to gut someone? there's that strawman again..
sabretooth was AS strong before his upgrades he's easily surpassed spiderman by now.. cyber was a little stronger...
tearing out wolverine's gut isn't credible anyways.. even with bloodlust on they still preform within character...
Originally posted by Dizzle
Characters are made more powerful when fighting stronger characters, and weaker and slower when fighting less powerful opponents. Head to head is, once again, not a good comparison. [/B]
...and then of course there's those who job...
so..
then how do you make a good assessment?