JEDI DEATH

No-one in the suit when it burns do you mean, Yerssot? I'll have to check it out.

Yeah, it is difficult for me to explain so I'll try again, queeq if you read this please translate also

If you look at him when he is on the pile, you notice that the mask is almost fallen in the mask, it doesn't lay on the mask.

Wat ik bedoel is dat het masker ingevallen is, het ligt niet OP het masker maar IN het masker

Yeah, I understand, The literla reason for that, of course, is that there actually WAS no-one in the suit when filmed, but I'll happily take it as evidence that Anakin had disappeared...

You agree Ush?? You must be sick!

Anything that helps me fight Queeq on this one...

I'm getting emotional here!!!
The guys at lucasfilm aren't stupid, if there was supposed to be someone IN the suit, they could make a dummy and put it in there, but they didn't; so logically he disappeared

I truely believe that if Lucas had wanted us to believe that he disappeared then we would have seen it.

We saw him at the end, I think that is more than enough

HOw is that relevant to disappearance?😕

I think that it is obvious that disappearing and being a ghost are connected

That's the whole point, pretty much everyone thinks that. Which is how the problem occurs, it appears that Vader dies on the floor of the hanger, but does not vanish yet he appears as a ghost.

The only one that spontanious vanish is Obi-Wan, Yoda closes his eyes and there is still a few seconds before he vanish. Vader who doesn't understand it, he is surprised when Obi vanished would take a few seconds more to vanish.

Yes, but Obi Wan is pretty much instantly killed where as Yoda slips into death. A fair comparrison can't be made between natural death and dismemberment...

From my point of view they all die a natural death.
The one just goes quicker to the eternal fields than anothern, espesially when one doesn't know how he has to go there

That's a rather unique point of view I would say. What is natural about being cut in half?

I always thought he disappeared BEFORE being cut in half.

And I agree with Yerssot that his ghost appearance was to show you that Anakin DID disappear after all.

What? You mean the shock of realising he was about to die gave him a heart attack??? 😂

No, I always thought the disappearing trick was something you did voluntarily.

When Obi One was killed, he disappeared completely, leaving his clothes behind, when Yoda dies, his clothes go with him. When vadar dies, he disappears leaving his vader suit behind(or so we presume) but when we see him he's wearing his Jedi chlothes 😕

I believe that when they die then disappear is because they were one with the force. If they die like Qui-Gon did he was surprised by his impending death. So he couldn't get into synch with the force. Evidence Obi-Wan knew let himself be struck down he knew he was going to lose anyways. Yoda died slowly, he knew he was going to die. Vader knew he was going to die.