Thing vs Colossus

Started by who?-kid60 pages

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
The only area thing betters Colossus in is in fighting skills, but then colossus is no chump by any means. He has been trained by the likes of Wolverine and regularly trains to improve his skills and strength further in the danger room. He is more durable than the thing, he doesnt need to breathe in his armoured form, he is stronger than the thing and also more agile. Id give it to him 6 out of 10 times with the things superior fighting skills giving him the remaining matches.

Yup.

How is Colossus more agile than Thing?
Peter was a farmer before he came to X-Men.
Ben was a gang-leader, football player, military soldier, airforce pilot before the Fantastic Four.
We know Colossus has had lots of training in the Danger Room over the years.
Thing is NATURALLY more athletic, agile, better fighting skills, not to
mention experience. He's been fighting since he was a child....
How often has Thing fought against Hulk and last for a while?
Too many to even begin counting.
Things lasted longer against the Champion than anyone else.
Colossus went down. Thing lasted longer. Took more punishment.
Asked for more.....

Okay even if thats so, I still believe this is close, and thats only with a 5.5/10

I'd give the fight to Thing 7 outta 10 or better....

colossus by miles

and that's not because im an x-fan

X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!X FO' LIFE!!!!

I'm thinking 6/10 to Colossus... cos eventually Thing's gonna get hungry or thirsty 😄

Originally posted by Pointinel
colossus by miles
and that's not because im an x-fan

Then why Colossus by a mile X FO' LIFE!!!!
Back it up!

Here is the stats between The Thing and Colossus according to Marvel Encyclopedia:

CATEGORY THING COLOSSUS
INTELLIGENCE 2 3
STRENGTH 6 6
SPEED 2 2
DURABILITY 6 6
POWER PROJECTION 1 1
FIGHTING SKILLS 5 3

TOTAL 22 21

Thing Wins!!

STATS-DONT-MEAN-SHIT.

I agree that Colossus would win, but I don't like it when people always use stats.

"durr, he can lift 85 and the another can lift 80 the first one wins." 🤪

Originally posted by shaolin9976
Here is the stats between The Thing and Colossus according to Marvel Encyclopedia:

CATEGORY THING COLOSSUS
INTELLIGENCE 2 3
STRENGTH 6 6
SPEED 2 2
DURABILITY 6 6
POWER PROJECTION 1 1
FIGHTING SKILLS 5 3

TOTAL 22 21

Thing Wins!!

It really doesnt work like that. If you think you can decide comic battles by tallying up their stats then you really cant be a comic book reader.

Originally posted by Zahit
Then why Colossus by a mile X FO' LIFE!!!!
Back it up!

dont you know me dude?

i cant

Originally posted by Pointinel
dont you know me dude?

i cant


😕 😆 😕

Originally posted by Zahit
How is Colossus more agile than Thing?
Peter was a farmer before he came to X-Men.
Ben was a gang-leader, football player, military soldier, airforce pilot before the Fantastic Four.
We know Colossus has had lots of training in the Danger Room over the years.
Thing is NATURALLY more athletic, agile, better fighting skills, not to
mention experience. He's been fighting since he was a child....
How often has Thing fought against Hulk and last for a while?
Too many to even begin counting.
Things lasted longer against the Champion than anyone else.
Colossus went down. Thing lasted longer. Took more punishment.
Asked for more.....

Even though Colossus grew up on a farm, he has always been exceptionally athletic. Actually, a little known fact, part of his mutation is to just be in perfect physical shape and be naturally athletic. That's why, even without working out on the farm, he was always in such incredible shape (no, not from the farm work). So Colossus is just as much a natural athlete as Thing is.

Oh, and of course, Piotr has also been fighting since he was a child. He'd been fighting the Russian mafia since he was just a boy, and grew up always fighting them until he and the X-men defeated their empire and such.

Colossus is proven to be much more agile, since he doesn't lose any agility in his transformation. Also more durable, probably has the same endurance, not sure. I've honestly never seen Thing use any form of martial arts that wasn't judo. So if that's the extent of his fighting ability, than Colossus has him there, too. It helps being trained by some of the best fighters in the X-men (Wolverine, Cyclops, etc.).

Colossus takes this victory 6.5/10.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
1. Beat Sasquatch in a fight.
2. Knock Juggernaut on his @ss.
3. Survive underwater.

boxing

How about not getting his ass knocked out by The Champion?

1. Ben's lung capacity allows him to stay underwater for hours.
2. He's never really truly fought Juggs that SW bs didn't count.
3. Ben has made Sassy look silly but they didn't actually fight.

😎

Can somebody show me ANY pics and examples of Colossus doing
something that indicates greater agility than Thing????
Anybody???
Has Colossus ever lasted as long against classic Juggernaut
as Thing has against the Hulk on many occasions???
Anybody???

Originally posted by Zahit
Has Colossus ever lasted as long against classic Juggernaut
as Thing has against the Hulk on many occasions???

First of all, Thing has had his ass kicked around by Hulk on many occasions. They first trade some punches, and then Hulk gets bored and punches him in the ground or whatever.

Second, Thing has been humiliated by Juggernaut in SW II. Colossus also loses of course, but boy, Thing sure was humiliated.

Now let's return to the thread and look at some facts:

1. Strength : probably Colossus, but not by much. A half point for C.
2. Durability : Colossus. Organic steel over organic rock any day.
3. Experience : Thing, but not by much. A half point.
4. Personality : they both have plenty of it, but Colossus doesn't make a big deal of a fight as Thing does. No points here.
5. Agility : probably Colossus, but I don't think it will matter in this fight, so only half a point.

This means : Colossus 2 points, Thing half a point.

Don't forget HEART and WILLPOWER.
Colossus got knocked out by The Champion.
Thing lasted longer and kept fighting even though he was getting destroyed.
or shall we just keep ignoring this one......

I forgot about that, been has a heart-o-gold!

Originally posted by Zahit
Don't forget HEART and WILLPOWER.

I covered that under "personality". Both have plenty of heart and willpower.
Colossus got knocked out by The Champion.

Colossus actually put up a good fight, but he was seriously outmatched. So was Thing by the way ! And how old is this comic ? 20 years ? Lot has happened since (like for example an upgraded Colossus).

Don't get me wrong, I really can see Thing winning this one. But Colossus is not to be taken lightly and has as much chances to win as Thing.

I never take Colossus lightly.
He's always been one of my favorite X-men.
He just doesn't have the balls of Ben Grimm.
Colossus can win, but not as often as Thing would.

your right though....a lot has changed in 20 years......
.....Wolverine can heal from Nukes now and kill Hulk don't ya know......