Thing vs Colossus

Started by Wynndar60 pages

there r already like 4 of these...u should use one of them instead...

Yea and it was a good one. The Thing fanboys backed down.

well i consider muself a thing fan and all i did was show plenty of proof the Thing would win, while colossus fans simply proved....that they really liked colossus and that he was cool.

Oh ok.

I didnt see it that way.

yea just like ur previous statement...all u had to say was that the thing fanboys backed down. Thats a nice emotional appeal but it doesnt actually say anything or offer anything in actual comics that suggests colossus could win. We could go dig up those old posts of mine showing how many more feats of strength, courage, and fighting expertise the Thing has over colossus. Or how the Thing has fought dozens more impressive opponents than colossus and won. Or u could talk about how cool colossus looks because he's made of metal and prettier than the Thing. Or how the only reason the Thing has more feats of strength and better opponents because he's more regularly appeared in comics. Then u would say that colossus is all grown up now and way stronger and durable than he was in the past, ignoring how the Thing is constantly growing stronger himself.

Well in the just released FF Handbook it dont say he is class 100. He still has a strength rating of 6 which his 85 tons would fall into.

Its easy to say he is class 100. But you have no proof. Colossus is stronger. Thats it.

Ben couldnt even beat Sasquatch. Colossus beat him down right around the same time Thing fought him.

Colossus went toe to toe with GLADIATOR all by himself. How did Thing fair against him?

Then there is Juggernaut. HAHAHAHAHA

colossus is very shiny.....and thing wont be able to see him..also his armor is really cool and he is tall....on a serious note......i do think that colossus is more durable and stronger......he is more agile....and has battle experience.....but to a lesser degree then thing...colossus traines in the danger room and was trained by cyclops and wolverine.....whilw thing...well just eats all day..and wins money.......any way my money is on colossus...casue well i am a fanboy and he is on a slightly higher level.........i will not respond to this thread any more..becasue it will become a long pointless chain of arguments....

as has been said its been done before...

wynndar just because you don't like our arguments doesnt make them any less valid...

😮‍💨

Originally posted by Wynndar
Or how the only reason the Thing has more feats of strength and better opponents because he's more regularly appeared in comics.

you don't think thats a valid point?

Originally posted by pr1983
as has been said its been done before...

wynndar just because you don't like our arguments doesnt make them any less valid...

I have nothing against a real argument, but saying the Thing fanboys backed down doesnt say anything factual, and saying Thing doesnt train and just eats all day demonstrates a lack of FF knowledge.

Originally posted by pr1983
you don't think thats a valid point?

It is a point...and an excuse. But u cant take away from the Thing just because he has had more appearances. Colossus still hasnt beaten anyone tough and hasnt demonstrated as impressive feats of strength.

Originally posted by Wynndar
I have nothing against a real argument, but saying the Thing fanboys backed down doesnt say anything factual, and saying Thing doesnt train and just eats all day demonstrates a lack of FF knowledge.

i never said either of those...

you said:

while colossus fans simply proved....that they really liked colossus and that he was cool.

you really think thats fair?

i didnt claim that u said either of those things

Originally posted by pr1983
i never said either of those...

you said:

you really think thats fair?

I was refering to the past threads, not this one.

Originally posted by Wynndar
i didnt claim that u said either of those things

i never said you did, i was just pointing it out...

I was refering to the past threads, not this one.

i was in those past threads...

pr1983 are you gonna read his mini-series when it starts in September?

well im sorry if i offended u. I dont want this to get emotional or for annyone to feel bad from what i say, I like debating Thing and Colossus, its one of my favorite debates. Colossus is one of my favorite X-men. I do call people out though when they say things like "the Thing fanboys backed down" and still cant manage to name a single thing Colossus has done the Thing cant.

Originally posted by Wynndar
and still cant manage to name a single thing Colossus has done the Thing cant.

1. Beat Sasquatch in a fight.
2. Knock Juggernaut on his @ss.
3. Survive underwater.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
pr1983 are you gonna read his mini-series when it starts in September?

colossus is a favourite of mine so yeah, hopefully i will... i hate bachalo's art though...

Originally posted by Wynndar
well im sorry if i offended u. I dont want this to get emotional or for annyone to feel bad from what i say, I like debating Thing and Colossus, its one of my favorite debates. Colossus is one of my favorite X-men. I do call people out though when they say things like "the Thing fanboys backed down" and still cant manage to name a single thing Colossus has done the Thing cant.

i understand and its one of my favourites too. i'd be pissed if somebody did say something like that too...

im not devaluing thing at all... and i dont know of many(if any) things that thing couldnt do that colossus could...

but look at it this way, how many things can thing do (under normal circumstances) that colossus cant? very few i'd say...

both are very well matched imo...