Face it , if a movie "tanks" at the box office it because either nobody cares about seeing it in the first place or others have seen it and warn everybody else that its bad. If you look at the history of movies in general this holds true.
I know you are a mod , but I am still going to say what I feel. It seems to me that because you dont like this movie, you want to label it with "numbers at box office , dont mean anything", but if you were talking about some movie like...Lord of the Rings, Godfather, Star Wars, or just about any other "all time" box office giant, you would say that shows that they were good movies!
I would really be interested in what some of your favorite movies are? What movies do "matter"? What movies were directed well?
I just know for a fact , that nobody in hollywood, the world of movies, society, etc thought that this movie would do what it has! Mel Gibson believed in the story and did what others told him NOT to do! I find that courageous and daring! The fact that it has been so well recieved(not matter what you or others on here say) shows me that "society" does what movies like this to be made!
I dont know why you really dont like it( I can only guess), but I know that I saw how people acted the night I saw it! They loved it, thought it was great, well done, well directed, etc!
Sure you can disagree with me(and the MASSES)and like most things in life.....numbers do mean something...whether its numbers as in dollars or numbers as in people of one mind or thought!