silver surfer vs superman

Originally posted by snoopdogg
He also states that there is enough kryptonite that Superman wouldd not be able to hurt him.

He was dead wrong.

Resists the red solar blasts to a degree? Cosmic read the comic and then make that assumption. He took some good double shots and still tore the suit up. Once again Eclipso feeds off anger so Superman had to take him out while going easy on him. If that were anybody else in that suit the fight would have been over much sooner.

Just face it guys Surfers chances at a victory via red sunlight or kyrptonite wavelengths are a long shot but are still there.

If you dont like it learn to live with it

I think I already responded to this. It was something like.

"Superman laid on the rooftop for five panels because he was holding back?

The point is, the suit wasn't intended to kill Superman. That would defeat Eclipso's purpose. Eclipso wanted to subdue Superman, and take over his body. Killing him wouldn't be a very good idea."

Superman/Batman #20 Superman goes hand to hand against a kryptonite villain called the Green K.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
AC #826 was the prelude to the fight they had in AOS #639.

I am aware of this. Doesn't change the fact that Superman was on his back for 5 panels as a result of a red sunlight blast.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube

The point is, the suit wasn't intended to kill Superman. That would defeat Eclipso's purpose. Eclipso wanted to subdue Superman, and take over his body. Killing him wouldn't be a very good idea."

Luthor designed that suit to take out Superman. 😱

All Eclipso wanted to do was piss Superman off but he failed.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Superman/Batman #20 Superman goes hand to hand against a kryptonite villain called the Green K.

And wins?

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Superman/Batman #20 Superman goes hand to hand against a kryptonite villain called the Green K.

*sigh* PLEASE! For the love god NEVER use Jeph Loeb's writing as a reliable source.

Ugh. SOOOOO many inaccuracies.

Batman defeating Lady Shiva easily.

Superman somehow breaking WW's indestructible bracelets.

And of course the above. It's just a needless ramping of their abilities to obscene levels. It's VERY bad writing.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Are you serious Cosmic?

Luthor designed that suit to take out Superman. 😱

All Eclipso wanted to do was piss Superman off but he failed.

I'm quite serious. Luthor designed the suit to fight Superman, not kill him.

Yea thanks to Batman.

But thats not the point Superman was trading punches and holding his own.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
I'm quite serious. Luthor designed the suit to fight Superman, not kill him.

Originally posted by Draco69

And of course the above. It's just a needless ramping of their abilities to obscene levels. It's VERY bad writing.

Draco knows just about everything there is to know about DC comics. From what he's saying, it sounds like bad writing.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Draco knows just about everything there is to know about DC comics. From what he's saying, it sounds like bad writing.

I never have used that excuse. 🙁

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Then anybody at anytime could just say well thats bad writing.

I never have used that excuse. 🙁

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Is this a question?

No. It is a statement of a fact.

Eclipso may have underestimated Superman, but he was quite sure that the suit wasn't enough to hurt Superman. And it wasn't.

Originally posted by snoopdogg

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
No. It is a statement of a fact.

Eclipso may have underestimated Superman, but he was quite sure that the suit wasn't enough to hurt Superman. And it wasn't.

On the flip side he didnt think Superman could hurt him in the suit but he destroyed it.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Then anybody at anytime could just well thats bad writing.

I never have used that excuse. 🙁

Not really. If something happens that is an obvious inaccuracy, (such as Wonder Woman's bracelets being broken,) it can be regarded as bad writing.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
He was talking about the kryptonite alloy in the suit.

On the flip side he didnt think Superman could hurt him in the suit but he destroyed it.

What are you disputing? You just agreed with me.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
What are you disputing? You just agreed with me.

But he said there was enough in the suit to where Superman could not hurt him but he was wrong Superman tore the arms off the suit after repeated doses of red solar energy.

All of this while not trying to get angry.

Have you fought anybody who has two of your weaknesses and not try to get mad and still win?

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Eclipso said there wasnt enough kryptonite in the suit the hurt Superman.

But he said there was enough in the suit to where Superman could not hurt him but he was wrong Superman tore the arms off the suit after repeated doses of red solar energy.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
What are you disputing? You just agreed with me.