Silver Surfer vs Thor

Started by abhilegend92 pages

Nah, Galactus didn't depower surfer by that barrier. Its made perfectly clear several times.

Originally posted by abhilegend
This again? You are repeating the same "misleading interpretation" argument? Sad.

It's not an argument. It's you legendary reputation you've built yourself on this forum.

Your delusions are.

Surfer raging out and only able to hurt himself rather than Thor while Thor dents his skull and no sells his point blank blast means Surfer was getting his ass kicked.

Was he?

That's because Fraction Thor is a retarded brute. Thor kep shoving mjolnir up surfer's ass regularly too.

So he's martian manhunter lite? Big deal, J'onn gets his head punched in often enough as it is. You can repeat it as much you want, it would change nothing. By that definition nothing would beat hulk or wolverine because they can heal damage.

Thor's forehead was bloody, surfer's forehead was ****ing caved in. He healed back but who got worse by that attack is obvious to everybody but you.


Rather not go back in forth arguing against your false interpretation of the recent fight between Thor and Surfer. I thought it was a stalemate, you thought that Surfer was getting a butt whooping of a lifetime. You are literally the only one on this forum that thinks Thor was whooping Surfer's butt, when almost everyone else (even Rage and Khazra) think it was roughly a stalemate give or take. But okay, hold on to your delusions.

And Loki said he is more powerful than ever. Without the amp Loki said he was no match for Thor at all.

Makes sense, since without Loki's amp Surfer would only possess power that "was a fraction of what it once was."

So in other words Surfer might of had Loki's power added to his own, but at the time he only had a "fraction" of his original power.

That's invalid per rules here. He was backtracking anyway.

The armbar is invalid too, yet you keep bringing it up.

But both happened under the same writer, why is one PIS and other isn't? With inductors? Pretty much classic surfer. Not with inductors. Johnny wielded his power and he didn't note any increase in surfer's power either.

One is a street leveler armbaring a high herald. The other is using Dr.Doom style tech to drain a comic being's powers.

Name one another instance where surfer mentioned his amp. Heck even in Annihilation its mentioned that Galactus merely restored his power, not augmented it. Its not my job to prove it didn't stuck, its your job to prove it stuck. Fraction made that surfer would be weakened away from earth but in Infinity there was no mention of it.

http://imageshack.us/a/img109/9894/newpower.jpg

What? Upgrades are suppose to be dismissed according to you? What does it even matter? We saw how post-annihilation Surfer did against Thor currently, and it was a stalemate

Nothing as low as armbarred by Black Panther though.

PIS doesn't count, and Surfer let him armbar him to get information out of BP. We know later on Surfer said he could incinerate BP with a thought.

I called it flip-flopping because you are applying different standards for surfer and Thor. And you're ****ing wrong. Move on.

That's right.

You are grasping at straws now. Stop this foolishness.

If she phases someone from behind its most assuredly a cheapshot. Have you like ever read an X-men comic?

Nope.

Stop. You are just being inane at this point with nonsensical analogies.


😂

Are you serious? Your counter-argument is to just dismiss my argument and plug your ears and say "Nope" and "Stop." Stop avoiding my points and address them, but until you actually do that, I'll accept your concession.

Right back at ya.

Says the person with the notorious reputation.

While Bill was heavily weakened and wounded. But that's ignored, right?

It's amazing how much an advantage you get if you start a fight with a surprise sucker shot, unlike Surfer who created an advantage when the fight already started.

Of course it does.

In your Bizzaro world maybe, no one's buying it I'm afraid.

Which he did just recently as FF discovered. "Recent depletion" of ozone layer means surfer just recently discovered ozone layer blocked the rays an he blasted a hole in it. That absolutely retcons why he seemed weaker.

No it doesn't, you throw the word retcon around like candy during Halloween. It doesn't retcon his depowerement at all. You're taking a totally random scene that happened decades later which has nothing to do with his depowerement, and taking an out of context statement, and trying to pass it as a retcon that he was never depowered? Even worse is that it has no logical consistency whatsoever. Again, part of your reputation.

Surfer (decades later): I gather energy from space and accidentally burned a hole in the ozone = I was never depowered at all, even though I clearly was, and made references to it multiple times.

This is as bad as you trying to pass off the scan of Surfer drinking tea as a retcon too, which made me burst out laughing.

😂

Depowerment but not by a specific being. In FF 74 he described it because he was denied the power of endless cosmos, not because he was drained by sonic shark.

http://i.imgur.com/2bDJ7Fy.jpg

😂

That shows yet another reference to Surfer's depowerement. How does that mean he was replenished to full power? He can still channel power from the cosmos, but to lesser extent due to being weakened.

Read below.

Nah, it was to show that when he went back to space after galactus' barrier, his strength is replenished. Your reading comprehension sucks.

No it doesn't. Again, stop making stuff up. The barrier doesn't block his ability to gather energy into Earth or himself. It only blocks his surf board from passing through.

Here Surfer is trapped under the barrier and he can still channel and gather energy from "the endless cosmos" and uses it to blast the Flying Dutchman.

There goes the barrier BS.

Again, the barrier doesn't so sh*t except block his board. The depowerment was to his personal reserves and nearly killed him. But the FF4 stopped it before it could, but it left him extremely weakened.

Stop trying to make outlandish claims to prove Surfer was full power when he fought Thor. He clearly wasn't.

I made a mistake as I remembered the scene taking place after SS 2. Honest mistake bro, that scene took place after SS 18.

http://i.imgur.com/RScydNw.jpg

"Merely hours ago."

The scan you posted happened decades after the Thor fight. If Surfer did re-absorb his power in that scan, it would mean it did it decades after the Thor fight. So I don't see any argument here.

And that's all that matters. He was more powerful than ever and even then he agreed that mjolnir>>PC.

Surfer stated his power was a "fraction" of what he once possessed. So it does matter. Surfer also said his power could destroy a galaxy. I take statements, unless backed up by action, with a grain of salt. Like Spiderman saying Sentry beat Galactus.

And what that perspective would be?

That Surfer might have had Loki's amp, but he only had a fraction of his original power when he fought Thor.

Surfer wasn't losing to Thor but he was more powerful than ever and still claimed mjolnir>>PC. Not hard to imagine what Stan had in mind.

Yeah, Surfer was actually winning, and had Thor at his mercy. Again, Surfer claimed his power could destroy a galaxy. Statements don't mean much until backed up.

Totally false.

uhuh


Don't play coy. It got to the point where Pr was begging you to stop posting Superman scans.

😛

Bump

Fight depends on how fast SS fights and his perception speed.

Still Thor of course...

Originally posted by h1a8
Fight depends on how fast SS fights and his perception speed.
Surfer can only beat Thor if he did nasty exotic attacks. Casual blasts and he will lose to Thor.

Silver Surfer wrecked Cancerverse Thor, who is equal to regular Thor.

Prove it.

Originally posted by h1a8
Surfer can only beat Thor if he did nasty exotic attacks. Casual blasts and he will lose to Thor.

Mjolnir Thor would eat up all exotic attacks.

And Thor has a fair few exotic attacks himself in case you never noticed.

Originally posted by XLR87T3
Silver Surfer wrecked Cancerverse Thor, who is equal to regular Thor.
Lol

Whatever happened to One Punch? I sent him a pm asking if he was alive, guess we'll find out

Originally posted by XLR87T3
Silver Surfer wrecked Cancerverse Thor, who is equal to regular Thor.

👆

Open and shut case

Silver Surfer is stronger than Thor, he has lifted and moved far heavier things with his TK than Thor with his bare hands

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111324203/6600178-7728682006-6599530-6310242531-aNihjqapnsxEt-7hn2rAyfGaeLqNFlmbvKuR5nuH3QmqBKGLTvws8viaJdvohuuhOekl7kCD9KNi%253Ds0

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111324203/6600179-7525173037-6599531-8743658029-rDW9Ln89koAYoa5Nv4z3mKAYAzwlDXdGsgIz6HRAfY-nJEv2pa1nYO9MDME-CAO-Rew-j3RaetVc%253Ds0

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11132/111324203/6600180-5355525084-6599532-7567998379--ewc_K5Wr8G4u_yFjqRkMeeHij8v_OEXFEZdeAJHH6_FdrBOogoGBEtvJr5vi_XQMlTAa1pqB_NI%253Ds0

He lifted a star, a freaking star.

Another thing, his energy blasts can destroy planets, Thor's lightning or energy (including godblast) has never destroyed something that massive. He needs to rely on physically hitting with his hammer to do what Silver Surfer does with a casual blast.

Fact is, Silver Surfer holds back, and the only reason he doesn't use hax during fights is due to morals. (confirmed in Silver Surfer: In Thy Name #1)
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111324203/6600190-7206662131--ye_ImzSgaVUqMgYNla7coLRTd5uHkZ6CyedMYyEpiKkVxElixVAGOB0ZVBg-8ntI5YIMwJc9xRyxkMH4OjA7sYEQh4zkblkCrmJ7wEM0a8LZvcbmvXm7cB_3puJHcYpgWCaCKA%3Ds0

Thor typically outperforms Surfer whenever they've matched up.

Thor also tends to perform better against big foes.

I agree with Juntai, but Surfer also jobs less.

Thor's taken many more dives against lesser foes.

Originally posted by XLR87T3
Silver Surfer is stronger than Thor, he has lifted and moved far heavier things with his TK than Thor with his bare hands

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111324203/6600178-7728682006-6599530-6310242531-aNihjqapnsxEt-7hn2rAyfGaeLqNFlmbvKuR5nuH3QmqBKGLTvws8viaJdvohuuhOekl7kCD9KNi%253Ds0

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111324203/6600179-7525173037-6599531-8743658029-rDW9Ln89koAYoa5Nv4z3mKAYAzwlDXdGsgIz6HRAfY-nJEv2pa1nYO9MDME-CAO-Rew-j3RaetVc%253Ds0

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11132/111324203/6600180-5355525084-6599532-7567998379--ewc_K5Wr8G4u_yFjqRkMeeHij8v_OEXFEZdeAJHH6_FdrBOogoGBEtvJr5vi_XQMlTAa1pqB_NI%253Ds0

He lifted a star, a freaking star.

Another thing, his energy blasts can destroy planets, Thor's lightning or energy (including godblast) has never destroyed something that massive. He needs to rely on physically hitting with his hammer to do what Silver Surfer does with a casual blast.

Fact is, Silver Surfer holds back, and the only reason he doesn't use hax during fights is due to morals. (confirmed in Silver Surfer: In Thy Name #1)
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11132/111324203/6600190-7206662131--ye_ImzSgaVUqMgYNla7coLRTd5uHkZ6CyedMYyEpiKkVxElixVAGOB0ZVBg-8ntI5YIMwJc9xRyxkMH4OjA7sYEQh4zkblkCrmJ7wEM0a8LZvcbmvXm7cB_3puJHcYpgWCaCKA%3Ds0

More excuses from the Sufer camp for him proving incapable of defeating Thor throughout their comic history.

Mjolnir could always soak up whatever planet busting blasts Surfer throws out. But Surfer has never been able to handle Mjolnir strikes very well.

Thor wins as usual. (Classic Mjolnir Thor that is). Best Surfer can achieve is a stalemate.

Silver Surfer was holding back on all of those occasions where he fought Thor. Morals Off, he uses hax to kill Thor
http://www.majorspoilers.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/10/silversuferinthynameprev/SilverSurferInThyNamePg04.jpg

Technically Surfer should be much faster (movement speed) than Thor. This should make it extremely hard (if not impossible) for Thor to land any significant blows.
Surfer has his problems too.
His blasts against heralds are just not very powerful.
Surfer can wreck the hell out of some fodder though.
But if Surfer was allowed to blast Thor for a few seconds then how much damage do you think Thor will accrue?

Originally posted by h1a8
Technically Surfer should be much faster (movement speed) than Thor. This should make it extremely hard (if not impossible) for Thor to land any significant blows.
Surfer has his problems too.
His blasts against heralds are just not very powerful.
Surfer can wreck the hell out of some fodder though.
But if Surfer was allowed to blast Thor for a few seconds then how much damage do you think Thor will accrue?

So you dont think planet destroying attacks would be effective against Heralds?

I want you to make out with h1, carver.

Has Thor ever beat BRB as easily as Surfer has?