Nope spidey wins this.
he is stronger
he is faster
he has better reflexes
he can dodge anything dd can throw at him
he has unlimited webbing (organic webbing)
you presented this hypothetical situation as to how you think DD will win so i will present my own. It is far shorter, simplier and (as far as I am concerned) more realistic.
daredevil goes to hit spidey, spidey dodges, spidey hits daredevil. DD is knocked unconcious by the ten ton punch.
plus the recent The Other : Evolve or die storyline will give Peter further upgrades, which he doesn't need to win this fight.