Agnostics or Atheists

Started by Fire17 pages

says who?

it's not because a theory is wrong (tho I doubt it) that that means god is the answer

The theory is wrong and God is definitely not the answer!

again who says the theory is incorrect?

It's my personal opinion. So there!

yea and that's almost worth a damn to the scientific community

Originally posted by Arahael
It's my personal opinion. So there!

We all have our opinions here! You chose something that you found to be reasonable that's fine! Don't diss other people's beliefs or ideas.

you can't claim something to be incorrect just cause you think it is

Originally posted by Arahael
The entire theory of evolution is scientifically and mathematically incorrect.

I'm no scientist, but I might be able to handle the mathematics. What's the problem?

I feel like sounding smart.

Utinam logica falsa tuam philosophiam totam suffodiant! 🙁

Right.

Quo signo nata es? 🙂

What is 'proof'? Its a word we created to give us power over the universe. If you have proof then you can obviously explain the essense of something, right? But what do you base the explanation on?

How do you know your proof is correct? Because a group of scientists said so? What makes them absolutely right? Granted, they make a lot of sense and I really have no reason to question their findings, but what if theyre wrong? What if it really is Gods will that keeps us planted on the ground? And what if Gods will can be described with manmade ideas like mass and pressure combined with the rotation of the planet?

I'm not saying science has it all wrong, maybe theres just other ways to describe the world around us. People shouldnt get stuck on one discipline or belief, whether scientific or religious. Minds should be open to the possibility that factions other than their own have a piece of the puzzle.

Theories need to be corroborated by other scientists before being taken as proven, right? The only problem is that theres no way to prove all the foundations of our own knowledge. If we could meet a society from another galaxy that used the same methods we did and explained the universe in the same way, it would 'prove' something to me. Otherwise, its all stuff we've made up. Really good stuff from really intelligent minds, but made up nonetheless.

That is why scientists normally don't talk about a theory being proven; just supported by the evidence. If new evidence comes along, a theory is changed accordingly.

As to why we evolved from monkeys, but theres still monkeys around, I'd say its like this:

Say you got a bunch of monkeys. After generations of breeding, 50% of those monkeys' descendants gain more useful opposable thumbs, so they can better interact with their surroundings. Later, 50% of those monkeys gain better eyesight so they can gather food and watch for predators. Later still, 50% begin walking upright. Pretty soon you got humans. Since half of the monkeys never evolved and kept breeding though, you also still have a lot of monkeys.

I guess there wasn't much wrong with monkeys in the first place, or they would have died out. What a sad world it would be then, because monkeys are funny, especially when they wear human clothes and walk little dogs and stuff.

Originally posted by Creechuur
I guess there wasn't much wrong with monkeys in the first place, or they would have died out. What a sad world it would be then, because monkeys are funny, especially when they wear human clothes and walk little dogs and stuff.

😆 ...meanin' no disrepect to monkeys...

think it's less than 50% creechuur

I just picked a number at random...

Originally posted by finti
NO we have the knowledge that gravity keep us planted on the ground

I would say faith, because unless you yourself experimented and discovered gravity, aren't you just believeing it's there?? 🤨