Captain America vs Black Panther

Started by supremthor18 pages

so cap is ONLY a better fighter but panther is smarter

I just went to http://marvel.com/universe/index.htm and its like Captain America....why dont i show it.

Captain America

Intelligence=level 3
Strength=level 3
speed=level 2
durability=level 3
energy protection=level 1
FIGHTING=level 7+

Black Panther

Intelligence=level 5
Strength=level 3
speed=level 2
durability=level 3
energy protection=level 3
FIGHTING=level 5

Uh oh. Don't look now, Nathaniel Grey, but Cap is winning the poll. I told you not to count out the Red, White and Blue.

Cap wins.

Rofl. You're an admitted fanboy. I've already won this fight as I see it. 😉 Your views as such don't allow you to believe that anyone but Cap could win this fight. Even if I stated that Black Panther was invulnerable and immoveable you'd still scream that Captain America could take him. This is done. Lol.

Hulk Wins.

http://newsarama.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=22839

It's funny. In this interview by NEWSARAMA with Reggie Hudlin who's going to be the up coming writer for Black Panther he states that Black Panther is richer than Tony Stark, richer than BATMAN and tougher than Captain America in hand to hand fighting. I mean if a writer says that you really can't dispute it. After all he's writing the comic now. Seems like he knows who'd win between Captain America and Black Panther. You know...him being a Marvel writer and all. 😉

reggie hudlin is awesome, i cant wait till BP #1

He's very passionate about the character, which is a huge plus, and him being a Priest fan cements the deal for me. I can't wait either.

I'm just glad he said he's going to be adding and working from what Priest already established. I mean if that isn't a confidence builder I don't know what is.

Physically these two are almost identical. But, I think Panther should win due to his suit and equipment.

Originally posted by norrin radd
yes but at least weed is natural, it is on mother nature.

very true

Originally posted by Nathaniel Grey
http://newsarama.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=22839

It's funny. In this interview by NEWSARAMA with Reggie Hudlin who's going to be the up coming writer for [b]Black Panther he states that Black Panther is richer than Tony Stark, richer than BATMAN and tougher than Captain America in hand to hand fighting. I mean if a writer says that you really can't dispute it. After all he's writing the comic now. Seems like he knows who'd win between Captain America and Black Panther. You know...him being a Marvel writer and all. 😉 [/B]

Dude, he's the new writer for the Black Panther comic. What do you expect him to say?

"Uh, yeah... see... Black Panther is... like, poor... and uh... like, lots of people could whip his ass... uh, wait. Can we start this interview over?"

You can't POSSIBLY be that naive. Of course he's going to say lots of positive things about the character. He would probably like to keep his job. But notice how he picked CAP to compare his fighting skills to. Hmmm...

Face it, fanboy; Cap wins.

The same thing I expect Captain America writers to say. That their character is the greatest and most innovative rendition ever bestowed upon the eyes of their comic book reading audience. Black Panther has always been viewed by the majority of the comic book reading community as a second string character in a cat suit. Naive? Are you asking me do I believe it's naive that with some exceptional writing and character development that Black Panther can be give as much importance and recognition as Spider-Man, Wolverine and Captain America? That he can also be considered to be one of the greatest warriors known and even surpass that of Captain America? Then my answer is yes. I am naive. But I believe that it's even more naive to have no doubts about a comic books character's ability to falter. Black Panther isn't a god nor is he considered a super-powered being but in a battle against Captain America he'd win 5 times out of 10 and likewise for Cap.

If we disregard what this writer is stating about what he's planning for Panther why not just disregard the gentlemen who decided to make Captain America's shield of an unbreakable alloy? Or the gentlemen who decided that Captain America was going to be the pinnacle of human strength and so forth. Why don't we ignore those writers? Does Reginald Hudlin have any less merit because he's new to the scene? I'm sure at one time when Captain America's writers began they were new and their ideas were met with some scrutiny. Yes, he picked Captain America to compare his skills to so you should be flattered. But to say what you said about him just wanting to " keep his job ". I think that can go ALL around the board for every writer ever known. But you see for this character who's had little exposure to the mainstream reader it's more than him just writing to keep his job. He's pouring a lot of emotion and strength into a character that he can relate to but VERY few can. Few writers have been able to capture the true essence of what the Black Panther is and have dulled him down because he was considered to be a lower tier character. But thanks to ( Chris Priest ), Joe Quesada, Reginald Hudlin and John Romita Jr. the character will be displayed with the respect he deserves as a front line character. And yes, he'll be tougher than Captain America in hand to hand fighting. It's a new day...accept it. Btw. Buy BLACK PANTHER#1 February 2005.

I think everyone has already established our views in this debate. But you calling me a fanboy? Heh. The pot calling the kettle black, homie.

Interesting.

I just found this funny. If you look on the Black Panther Message board -- there's a female Black Panther! I about died laughing. But she actually looks amazing. Check it out.

But the man definately gets the respect he deserves. :: Salutes Cap. ::

Originally posted by Capt.JK
Dude, he's the new writer for the Black Panther comic. What do you expect him to say?

"Uh, yeah... see... Black Panther is... like, poor... and uh... like, lots of people could whip his ass... uh, wait. Can we start this interview over?"

You can't POSSIBLY be that naive. Of course he's going to say lots of positive things about the character. He would probably like to keep his job. But notice how he picked CAP to compare his fighting skills to. Hmmm...

Face it, fanboy; Cap wins.

Exactly this is the most smartest thing that has been said after reading what Hudlin wrote. Black panther tougher than Captain America(interesting choice of words). But please for crying out loud. Lets just stop the silly talk. And him being richer than Bruce Wayne. This particular subject is still subject for debate. Black panther gets rich from a cave with rare minerals (only found on wakanda by selling it to different countries all over the world. But the Wayne Enterprise has its hands in every part of the globe (ask Donald Trump: you have a multi billion dollar company what do you do?) the answer you spread like hell (and turn your multi billion dollar company into something even bigger.) See what I mean😉.

(Black Panther comes from a society where scientifically is beyond Reed Richards.) NO TECHNOLOGY IS BEYOND REED RICHARDS Wakanda society more scientific than any country yes but against reed richards😕.

Originally posted by Nathaniel Grey
If we disregard what this writer is stating about what he's planning for Panther why not just disregard the gentlemen who decided to make Captain America's shield of an unbreakable alloy? Or the gentlemen who decided that Captain America was going to be the pinnacle of human strength and so forth . Why don't we ignore those writers? Does Reginald Hudlin have any less merit because he's new to the scene? I'm sure at one time when Captain America's writers began they were new and their ideas were met with some scrutiny.

As for the Merit thing compared to Stand Lee Yes. Hudlin has no merit.
I do believe that the creator of Captain America is Stand Lee (Since way back when). Unfortunately for you he did not give him superpowers but he did give him peak human form and an unbreakable shield. The reason the creator is stand lee. Captain was not meet with scrutiny since as he was fighting the Nazi and first made his first appearance during I think World War 1 or World War 2. If anything else people welcome him. Anything short of a w..h..o..r..a..h would have been considered unpatriotic. And boy.... you do not what to be branded unpatriotic during those days.

captain america was created by joe simon and jack kirby......stan lee created black panther.........

jack kirby the greatest of all time

very true, he of course took part in drawing black panther