L O S T

hes not the smoke monster

they're gonna have a face off!!!

Smokey actually being Esau is definitely a possibility. They have to explain the smoke monster at some point - and that seems like a acceptable explaination without people being like "Oh thats gay!"

As for the Guitar Case, it's gotta be Charlie's.

S_D_J, I like it. It is very possible that Esau, or whatever his name is, is in fact the smoke monster. It DOES make sense, the way you explained it. That guy may in well be a master manipulator, using people's memories and feelings against them to progress his plan. Think about this(this just came to me): If Jacob is supposed to be God and Esau Satan, that would explain why Smokey killed Mr. Eko, a priest.

you know what

remember when locke saw the smoke monster? in the first or second season, i cant recall... They never showed it but he saw it

what if the smoke monster possessed him, he was a bit weird when he came back

Originally posted by Mairuzu
you know what

remember when locke saw the smoke monster? in the first or second season, i cant recall... They never showed it but he saw it

what if the smoke monster possessed him, he was a bit weird when he came back

Like the whole thing started back then, at that point? Hmmm, I think I will go back and watch my DVD's from the beginning from this point of view and see how it works.

Dude, I love this show! 😱 😱

imagine!??? it would be insane!

im still trying to find the time to watch it all

Like it's been in our face the whole time, and we never saw it coming.

No way. If he was possessed way back then, he would have killed Jacob already. Not waited 5 seasons.

***** couldnt find jacob!

He couldn't kill Jacob himself. He had to have someone have blind faith in him enough do wahtever he wanted. That's why he made a point of dying and resurrecting. That, and the fact that his dead daughter told him so, made Ben become Locke's servant. That was the loophole.

Originally posted by SpaceMonkey
He couldn't kill Jacob himself. He had to have someone have blind faith in him enough do wahtever he wanted. That's why he made a point of dying and resurrecting. That, and the fact that his dead daughter told him so, made Ben become Locke's servant. That was the loophole.

I get the loophole.

What I'm saying is, Locke wasn't possesed yet. Not a chance.

pretty sure he wasn't possessed back then.... because he has never been possessed... his dead body is there, dead.
The Locke we saw is an illusion (albeit a tangible one), a doppelganger...

He being confronted by the monster, and coming out of it alive, what's just to show he was special... or make him believe so...

something is up... something

Originally posted by S_D_J
pretty sure he wasn't possessed back then.... because he has never been possessed... his dead body is there, dead.
The Locke we saw is an illusion (albeit a tangible one), a doppelganger...

He being confronted by the monster, and coming out of it alive, what's just to show he was special... or make him believe so...

Yeah, I get that then. Good point.

I have to refer back to Mr. Eko though. He had a face-to-face with him too, the same way he had one with Locke.... so why did it kill him and not Locke? What was the difference there?

left the show... hahahahahaha

Eko refused to confess his sins.

Smokey is Judgement.

Is that what it was? Doesn't make much sense to me.... then again, I can be rather dense sometimes.

thought he killed him because he was black

Hahahaha! Wow!

what shock_erm