Captain America vs. Wolverine

Started by Mindset164 pages

Originally posted by Battlehammer
yes he is and he fights just like he does. Please I love to know what he normally does so different? Please enlighten me what was so out of character in his fighting ability in his fight with wolverine.

Before you speak he used similar moves in there fight in captain america annual issue 8

I'm saying mainstream Cap in general is superior to the one shown in Origins.Have you actually been reading it, the most impressive things he has done was fight some nazis.

Who cares if he used similar moves, Ult Spiderman uses similar moves as 616 Spiderman, he is still inferior. Don't try and tell me they operate on the same levels when they don't. I'm not trying to use this as an excuse for him losing, it's just a fact. Origins Wolverine isn't as impressive as mainstream, neither were Bucky, Sabertooth, and Deadpool during his very short appearance.

Originally posted by Mindset
I'm saying mainstream Cap in general is superior to the one shown in Origins.Have you actually been reading it, the most impressive things he has done was fight some nazis.

Who cares if he used similar moves, Ult Spiderman uses similar moves as 616 Spiderman, he is still inferior. Don't try and tell me they operate on the same levels when they don't. I'm not trying to use this as an excuse for him losing, it's just a fact. Origins Wolverine isn't as impressive as mainstream, neither were Bucky, Sabertooth, and Deadpool during his very short appearance.

HHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Your not even talking about the same thing as me.

Im talking about there fight , your refferring to current origins which takes place while Captain America is still inexperience.

There was nothing incorrect nor did capt not fight as he normally does in origin 4 and 5 issue.

Capt does not fight as well in the current origin issues due to the fact he inexperienced which is the whole point of the latest origin story.

Also origins is main stream.

also all capt did for years in comics was fight nazi's..........

Originally posted by Battlehammer
HHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Your not even talking about the same thing as me.

Im talking about there fight , your refferring to current origins which takes place while Captain America is still inexperience.

There was nothing incorrect nor did capt not fight as he normally does in origin 4 and 5 issue.

Capt does not fight as well in the current origin issues due to the fact he inexperienced which is the whole point of the latest origin story.

Also origins is main stream.

also all capt did for years in comics was fight nazi's..........

I know what fight you're talking about, I'm saying origins in general has these characters fighting on a lower scale than their mainstream counterparts. And I'm using mainstream because origins is essentially a side story although it is not an alternate universe, thus not mainstream. Also Cap in the recent origins issue beat Wolverine, although I don't remember if Wolverine let him do it.

None of those characters I mentioned fight as good as they do in the "mainstream" stories they are in. You don't agree, if so post some scans of what they are capable of in origins and I could easily find ones that trump it.

Yes I know Cap fought Nazi's, he was in WII, but then he joined the Avengers...

Originally posted by Mindset
I know what fight you're talking about, I'm saying origins in general has these characters fighting on a lower scale than their mainstream counterparts. And I'm using mainstream because origins is essentially a side story although it is not an alternate universe, thus not mainstream. Also Cap in the recent origins issue beat Wolverine, although I don't remember if Wolverine let him do it.

See here the thing he not though. Nor can you give valid evidence that in the origin issue 4 fight, that capt fought out of character and not as skill full as normally would.

The fact is he fought in character and just as good as normal. He lost plain and simple

Oh wolverine was unarmed and did not wish to fight capt when wolverine was on the losing end though capt never KO him.

Originally posted by Mindset
None of those characters I mentioned fight as good as they do in the "mainstream" stories they are in. You don't agree, if so post some scans of what they are capable of in origins and I could easily find ones that trump it.

Im talking about one issue here. The origin 4 fight. Im not referring to the other origin issues sinc ethe whole plot of them is the fact capt is in experienced.

wow that so ahrd to find a scan that trumps an issue. are you kidding me you can do that for almost an issue of any story. Theres always a superior feat or scann.

Originally posted by Mindset
Yes I know Cap fought Nazi's, he was in WII, but then he joined the Avengers...

yes and the issues your comlaining about take place in WW2 prior to the avengers.........

Originally posted by Battlehammer
See here the thing he not though. Nor can you give valid evidence that in the origin issue 4 fight, that capt fought out of character and not as skill full as normally would.

The fact is he fought in character and just as good as normal. He lost plain and simple

Oh wolverine was unarmed and did not wish to fight capt when wolverine was on the losing end though capt never KO him.

Im talking about one issue here. The origin 4 fight. Im not referring to the other origin issues sinc ethe whole plot of them is the fact capt is in experienced.

wow that so ahrd to find a scan that trumps an issue. are you kidding me you can do that for almost an issue of any story. Theres always a superior feat or scann.

yes and the issues your comlaining about take place in WW2 prior to the avengers.........

My god, I'm not just talking about Cap or just one issuse, I'm talking about every ****ing character in Origins...is it really that hard to understand?

In Origins no character is as good as they are in the mainstream comics they appear in, so using fights and feats in it don't really translate well.

Originally posted by Mindset
My god, I'm not just talking about Cap or just one issuse, I'm talking about every ****ing character in Origins...is it really that hard to understand?

No, but why are you talking about it. The discussion was about one issue and you try and turn it into the entire series which has zero to do with this debate.

way to go off topic.

The point being made was, if none of these characters fight on the same level as they have shown in their mainstream stories, than using their fights doesn't work out.

Like saying because Ult. Wolverine could beat Ult. Spiderman, that means 616 Spiderman would lose to 616 Wolverine as well.

And I know Origins isn't an alt. universe, but since the levels of skill are different it is a similar situation. Basically it's best not to base your argument on this one fight.

Originally posted by Mindset
The point being made was, if none of these characters fight on the same level as they have shown in their mainstream stories, than using their fights doesn't work out.

Like saying because Ult. Wolverine could beat Ult. Spiderman, that means 616 Spiderman would lose to 616 Wolverine as well.

And I know Origins isn't an alt. universe, but since the levels of skill are different it is a similar situation. Basically it's best not to base your argument on this one fight.


sorry, but here the thing. They dident fight less skilled in the issue. They both fought in character and to there normal levels of skill.

Im not basing my opinion on this one issue. Logan wins reguardless of this issue. this issue shows that if the playing field is equaled out Logan is just as skilled in combat as Capt. Just helps to further the evidence that Logan and capt are equals in term of fighting skill.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Don't people use a scan from that arc to try and prove Cap is better than everyone?
Anyway, OK. 🙂

Only Captain America fan boys who interpret the scene incorrectly. Though it rather foolish to interpret the scene in such away, when later in the arc. Mr.x says those names mean nothing to me and insults both captain America and daredevil.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Ultimate? Are you talking about the universe where Wolverine got ripped in half by Hulk?

No its simply the title of the guide. It’s info on the 616 x-men team.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Plus... doesn't Cap bench enough to put him in with the 10 tonners or something according to handbook qualifications?

Capt never been listed beyond peak-human in the hand books.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Almost every time they've fought.

I think you are mistaken. Captain America has never been shown to look stronger then Spiderman in 616 universes.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
So... Spider-Man would fight like a tool against Cap then? Which would make him weaker, less durable, etc... ermm

He did fight like a tool. But no it won’t make him weaker or less durable. But I am not sure why this is such a feat I mean Captain America is easily skilled enough and strong enough to damage Spiderman

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Might have to check it out some time...

Also, I don't know if that's as impressive... ermm


Go a head. Why would it be not as impressive? I mean for starters we know it was tons and implied more then simply two. We also know that he became so heavy that the extremely thick floor gave out before he did. That’s quite a feat.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Rough House doesn't fight everyone though.

True, but the people he does fight he does not job too.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
http://img184.imageshack.us/my.php?image=capthunder3kb2.jpg

Nice though he bee only a 30 tonner. He also looked as if he fought jane prior to Captain America’s assault.

Logan did similar in the new avenger’s annual issue 1 if not mistaken.

Here a cool feat
http://img139.imageshack.us/my.php?image=claws200603page05xs3id5.jpg

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Sexrax:
http://img276.imageshack.us/my.php?image=avengersv2012288ui.jpg

That looked as if he used a judo throw of sorts. That would mean he did simply lift that weight he used Sexrax momentum.

So that’s really not a strength feat.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Elevator:
http://img85.imageshack.us/img85/3338/captainamericav303315dr7.jpg
http://img261.imageshack.us/img261/4476/captainamericav303316gr6.jpg

Not bad. Though not quite sure how impressive it really is.

This feat of Logan holding and elevator full of people seems a good deal superior.
http://img253.imageshack.us/my.php?image=supportelevatorxa0jn4ns5.jpg

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Nuke silo doors:
http://img176.imageshack.us/img176/7842/capiii12p21gz7.jpg
http://img177.imageshack.us/img177/2135/capiii12p22bh4.jpg
http://img159.imageshack.us/img159/7582/capiii12p23jl5.jpg

No idea how much strength that would require nor is there a way to figure it out so I am going to assume this is as impressive lol.
http://img267.imageshack.us/my.php?image=d3b7c104rv7.jpg

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
And I remember Cap holding up a jeep... don't have a clue where to find it.

That’s ultimate Captain America if not mistaken.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
"Negative comments"

Didn't mean you were disrespecting Cap.


K cool.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
OK.

Mind controlled... like, was he in control?


He had been brainwashed. He was fighting him self, but at the same time he would likely have done even better if he had not been forced to attack fantastic 4, but rather of his own choosing.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Also, that's because he sliced through his shoulder. Speed I'll give you, but it wasn't that great of a skill feat. 😬

It was due to the fact it dropped thing right away. That was likely due to the fact that area of the arm holds a large nerve cluster.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Either way, Thing turtled like a b*tch. 🙂

lol

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
I'm not using Cap using his shield though to compare the two... plus, Cap's shield doesn't permanently damage people... or is meant to kill them.

True, but it helps add damage to Captain Americas attacks as well as aid him in defense.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
I was meaning to use skill, as in a well placed punch, or something of the sorts. Because Cap has to use his skill to even things up.

His shield aids him there in both attacking and keeping him alive.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
A n00b using Wolverine's claws could cause serious damage to class 100's.

Perhaps, but not nearly as effectively. Nor could they put 100’ classes down so quickly.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
However, Cap was outwrestling Starfox, and Black Knight... and Starfox was said to be fifty times stronger right before he got pwned.

What issue?

Logan out fought and grapple warpath back when he was a bad guy and would have defeated him to if not for being distracted by kitty pride which got him sucker punched.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
And the reason Cap would be trying to crush Wolverine's tendons so his claws couldn't come out, would be?
Certainly not because they are dangerous...

To Captain America. I thought you said Captain America was trying not to hurt Wolverine.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
If it was a 'fair' fight, Cap wouldn't have had to be on top of Wolves crushing his tendons, and therefore wouldn't have been caught with a kick. 😬

It was fair for Capt. Capt had his shield and Logan his claws. Bother were armed, with there weapon of choice making it quite fair.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
And by fair, I mean on equal terms... no skeleton, no claws... meh.

Are you serous? It could not have gotten any fairer for Capt. Capt had his shield and armor. Wolverine had not eaten or slept in close to a month. Logan had just been in a fight and Capt attacked him from behind……….and your acting like wolverine had an unfair advantage………

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Plus, would that knee have even worked on Cap? The man has taken bullet wounds without slowing down.

You mean kick and why would it not? Is Capt now immune to pressure points and so forth? A bullet does not have the knowledge and skill of an individual who has spent over 100 years fighting and training like Wolverine.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Haven't read that in a while, but by scans, Cap looked battle damaged before the fight. Judging by him being cut up and shit...

Nope not at all. Captain America was not damaged before the fight, but Logan was.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Sure. Bio strength...

Perhaps.


No I mean stated in comics and implied in comics.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
I'm still arguing schematics about them being equals.

No one is equal judging by 'comparable' feats. 🙂


lol

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Both preferably.

So... do you want me to match these?

Somewhat comparable to the first. Breaking the bonds of chains.
http://img83.imageshack.us/img83/7158/captainamericav302605ab5.jpg

Anyway, this seems pretty impossible. He bent the flaps of a jet from outside of it.
http://img243.imageshack.us/my.php?image=captainamericstrenf3dz2.jpg

If you wish to.

The first really is not comparable. He did not break it in such away as wolverine, which would have been far harder to do. He also did not do so while poison, drugged and extremely weaken from the beating he had taken to the point were he almost dies after breaking out of the chain and fighting omega red for a few seconds.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Also, can I show Cap beating up Hulk, since you showed Logan bending supposedly unbreakable alloy? 😛

lol

I like Doom more. 🙂

---

F*ck. I forgot how taxing running to respect threads is (damn Cap, and him being somewhat foreign to me... and his f*cking unorganized thread).

I'm done here though.

Good debate. 🙂 [/B][/QUOTE]

You to my friend. see you later .

Originally posted by Ha-Son
During the end of Origins #3, when Cap shows up he has no scratches, but during the beginning of # 4 he has a gash on his leg. This could be due to the off-panel fighting between him and Wolverine. I could be wrong though.

I have to admit I think you are right, but im biased.

Originally posted by Mindset

In Origins no character is as good as they are in the mainstream comics they appear in, so using fights and feats in it don't really translate well.

For starters Cap was all riled up acting aggressively. To be quite honest I dont think its PIS that Wolverine won because it could happen but I see at as alow shoinwg for Cap, it should be Cap outhtinking Wolverine not the other way round.

Wolverine 7/10.

Originally posted by Phantom Zone

For starters Cap was all riled up acting aggressively. To be quite honest I dont think its PIS that Wolverine won because it could happen but I see at as alow shoinwg for Cap, it should be Cap outhtinking Wolverine not the other way round.

Which is not out of character for him in such a a scenerio were he see's Logan about to murder a helps opponet who Capt believes him self responsable for Nuke creation.

It was not a low showing. The two of them is a coin toss when it comes to who gunna out fight who. Also Capt not gunna out think wolverine in one on one scenerio. Also it instinct that matter in this type of battle. Capt used a devasting attack and got caught. It was far from a low showing and it was not an attack one would see coming.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
Which is not out of character for him in such a a scenerio were he see's Logan about to murder a helps opponet who Capt believes him self responsable for Nuke creation.

It was not a low showing. The two of them is a coin toss when it comes to who gunna out fight who. Also Capt not gunna out think wolverine in one on one scenerio. Also it instinct that matter in this type of battle. Capt used a devasting attack and got caught. It was far from a low showing and it was not an attack one would see coming.

origins is not really a good source to use to compare characters

Originally posted by Master-Borg
origins is not really a good source to use to compare characters

says the person who has never even read the issue we were discussing.

It was also merely a source and example of how equal the two of them are in terms of skill.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
says the person who has never even read the issue we were discussing.

It was also merely a source and example of how equal the two of them are in terms of skill.

I did read it, the tpb...I know the one you guys are talking about...with nuke and capt. and that is really getting old, accusing me of not reading what I proved I have read.

Originally posted by Master-Borg
I did read it, the tpb...I know the one you guys are talking about...with nuke and capt. and that is really getting old, accusing me of not reading what I proved I have read.

No you havent read it and youve never proven to have read it or any comic for that matter.

Must I quote what you said earlier?

when you said I was bias and capt got the blood clot from being medically sick...........if you read the issue you would not talk such nonsense.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
No you havent read it and youve never proven to have read it or any comic for that matter.

Must I quote what you said earlier?

when you said I was bias and capt got the blood clot from being medically sick...........if you read the issue you would not talk such nonsense.

so you remember EVERY detail of every comic you read?

I'm sorry, but my memory isn't that good. 🙄

Originally posted by Master-Borg
so you remember EVERY detail of every comic you read?

I'm sorry, but my memory isn't that good. 🙄


Not,but I remeber the big parts and that was a big part of the comic.........

and even when reminded what happen you said I was making it up and capt had medical problems..........and yet you wonder why I think your lying.

every time you say you read a comic you end up getting it wrong over and oevr agin.

Then you go "Ive proven to you I read them" but then you get them wrong again. It rediculous.

Anybody have a link for all the fights these two have had? I'd like to see them.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Anybody have a link for all the fights these two have had? I'd like to see them.

nope I posted the issue numbers

One fight Logan had mind of a were wolf

another was the origins fight.

one was in capt annual number 8 which ended after a few attacks, becuases a giant robot showed up.

last one was another origins fight in issue 21 I believe.